Thursday , April 18 2024
'I'll Say She Is' will get a full production this summer at the New York Fringe Festival. Before this weekend's staged readings, the Marx Brothers' first Broadway musical hadn't been seen in any form in 90 years.

Theater Review: Staged Reading of ‘I’ll Say She Is,’ ‘Lost’ Marx Brothers Musical Not Seen for 90 Years

I'll Say She IsMarxFest – not a socialist symposium but a monthlong celebration of the Marx Brothers – draws to a close May 31. One of the highlights has been a new reconstruction of the comedy legends’ wonderfully titled first Broadway musical, I’ll Say She Is.

This loosely-plotted revue was staged in 1924-25 with numerous musical numbers and comic bits and tropes that became Marx Brothers staples. Unlike more famous productions that followed – The Cocoanuts, Animal Crackers – it was never made into a movie. Not only that, the script didn’t survive, so no one can even say for sure how the show went.

Nevertheless, years of hard work by actor and Marx Brothers enthusiast Noah Diamond and several collaborators have produced a reconstruction of I’ll Say She Is which received its first staged reading Friday night, with one more this afternoon. It will become a full production this summer as part of the New York Fringe Festival.

The story, such as it is, is just an excuse for songs, some silly and some sweet, and for lots of the physical and verbal Marx Brothers comedy – crude, clever, bawdy, and zany – that fans to this day know and love from the classic movies. To describe just a few: There’s a long sequence about Napoleon (Groucho, played by Mr. Diamond) and a bed-hopping Josephine. There’s a hypnosis segment: Chico (Robert Pinnock): “Be a dog.” Beauty (Melody Jane): “Ruff ruff.” Chico: “Be a cat.” Beauty: “Meow, meow.” “Be a snake.” “I don’t know how to be a snake.” “It’s like a worm, but more.”

There’s trendy Freudian pop psychology. Beauty, bored with her riches, uninterested in draperies, is desperately seeking a thrill: “I have complexes and suppressed desires!” So, as it turns out, does her prim, aging aunt Ruby Mintworth (Kathy Biehl), only hers burst out in song: “Just a Little Bliss at Sunset.”

And of course there’s Harpo, perfectly played by Seth Shelden, extremely unsuccessfully hiding the fact that he has stolen Mrs. Mintworth’s silver.

The full production promises much more, including, as Diamond told me, “the Apache Dance, the Pygmalion ballet, Harpo and Chico’s ‘tramp ballet,’ and numerous other Harpo routines too elaborate to attempt in a reading. The Fringe production will feature a larger cast, more chorus girls, and a band.” With costumes, enthusiastic singing, suggestive blocking, and hilariously convincing performances, the reading itself gave a good approximation of what the full production has in store. Marx Brothers fans will love it, and even non-fans or the merely Marx-curious will appreciate it from a historical perspective, as it demonstrates not only the popular styles of music and humor of the day but a fine example of the transition period between vaudeville variety shows and fully plotted musical theater.

About the Author

[amazon template=iframe image&chan=default&asin=B0001HAIP4][amazon template=iframe image&chan=default&asin=B002TSAAAG][amazon template=iframe image&chan=default&asin=0857687786]

About Jon Sobel

Jon Sobel is Publisher and Executive Editor of Blogcritics as well as lead editor of the Culture & Society section. As a writer he contributes most often to Music, where he covers classical music (old and new) and other genres, and Culture, where he reviews NYC theater. Through Oren Hope Marketing and Copywriting at you can hire him to write or edit whatever marketing or journalistic materials your heart desires. Jon also writes the blog Park Odyssey at where he is on a mission to visit every park in New York City. He has also been a part-time working musician, including as lead singer, songwriter, and bass player for Whisperado.

Check Also


Theater Review (NYC): ‘Harmony,’ Barry Manilow and Bruce Sussman’s Musical

'Harmony' is a musical about an internationally famous, all-male German ensemble that performed between 1928 and 1934 until the Third Reich banned them as degenerates.


  1. Only quality survives (The David, Mona Lisa, the 1812). The Marx Brothers showed that with the work of the brothers that we do have and we can assume when fully restored I’ll Say She Is will likewise reach the big screen, albeit with a different cast.

  2. Always loved the Marx Brothers. My grandfather always said he thought that Gummo was the most talented brother in the Vaudeville act. I would imagine things changed drastically when they went to Broadway and then on to Hollywood, but one can only imagine the mayhem and laughs generated by that original stage act. This “staged reading” sounds like great fun!