Sunday , February 25 2024
Lit only by the actors' headlamps, this dark poetic drama about trapped coal miners grew on me – like a clammy mold.

Theater Review (NYC Off-Off-Broadway): ‘Butcher Holler Here We Come’

Isaac Byrne Butcher Holler Her We Come
Isaac Byrne in ‘Butcher Holler Here We Come’ at The Tank. Photo by Yvonne Alloway

The Tank, a resourceful nonprofit that provides space and other resources to theatrical and other artists, is reducing its carbon footprint with Dark Fest 2015, a series of productions staged with the power off. The response of the troupe Aztec Economy is Butcher Holler Here We Come, a gut-punch of a play about a group of coal miners trapped by an explosion. The only illumination comes from their headlamps.

Written by the always-edgy Casey Wimpee and directed furiously by Leah Bonvissuto, it’s a snarl of a piece, jumbled and irrational, mostly id. Everything I’ve seen involving Wimpee and his brother Cole (who’s in the cast) has carried a threat of chaos. This is no different – but also different.

I wasn’t always sure what was happening in Butcher Holler. A narrative spoken in total darkness framed the action; I didn’t understand the need for it. Though terror and violence fleck the play, its power comes from the miners’ language. Given that, the tone felt uncomfortable at first, the actors seeming to overdo their delivery and hew imperfectly to their Virginia accents. Rather than trying to be real coal miners, they seem to embrace their status as actors playing miners.

The play won me over once I acclimated to the idea that it’s really a poem, an epic poem of sorts, with heroes and villains, elevated language, and exaggerated drama. A story emerges from the shouts and confusion and half-blind action, with shards of character development and a dark revelation of the cause of the explosion. But it’s the men’s talk that drives the action – talk of strikes, mining legends, their aboveground families and friendships, their past and present woes, their feelings about the comrades who haven’t survived the disaster.

As they unfurl their personalities and troubles, jerking their way towards survival with plenty of hesitancy and distraction, the action escalates from panic and verbal abuse to physical cruelty – in the dark.

Periods of complete darkness punctuate sequences with one or more of the miners turning on their headlamps, so that often we see little more than their faces lit like ghastly masks. There’s no set – none is needed for a play set in darkness – but the audience becomes a set as the actors pace and climb and shout and wheeze and hiccup and chase each other around and behind rows of seating.

It appears that in losing the standard tools of electrical power, especially stage lighting, Aztec Economy gained license for even more narrative iconoclasm than usual. A taste for the avant-garde may be needed to appreciate this dark concoction. It grew on me like a clammy mold in a dark, dank cave – but it grew on me.

Butcher Holler Here We Come runs through August 2 at The Tank, 151 West 46 Street, NYC. Click here for tickets or call 1-800-838-3006.


[amazon template=iframe image&asin=0374280606][amazon template=iframe image&asin=1933202777][amazon template=iframe image&asin=1401308899][amazon template=iframe image&asin=B00H26CGTI]

About Jon Sobel

Jon Sobel is Publisher and Executive Editor of Blogcritics as well as lead editor of the Culture & Society section. As a writer he contributes most often to Music, where he covers classical music (old and new) and other genres, and Culture, where he reviews NYC theater. Through Oren Hope Marketing and Copywriting at you can hire him to write or edit whatever marketing or journalistic materials your heart desires. Jon also writes the blog Park Odyssey at where he is on a mission to visit every park in New York City. He has also been a part-time working musician, including as lead singer, songwriter, and bass player for Whisperado.

Check Also

Page Clements and Deanna Henson in Flawless

Theater Review (NYC): ‘Flawless’ by Robin Goldfin – A Tale of Dementia, Memory, and Family Love

Infused with magical realism, 'Flawless' isn't the intense, gritty family drama that the subject of dementia might suggest.