Tuesday , February 27 2024
A missed opportunity...

U2’s Live at Red Rocks DVD Debut, Under a Blood Red Sky Remastered For Sept. 29 Release

U2 continues its "Season of Churn" by confirming rumors that Live at Red Rocks will make its DVD debut and that the "accompanying" live album Under a Blood Red Sky has been remastered for re-release.  Both the CD and the DVD will be available Sept. 29.

Let's start with the Live at Red Rocks film, originally released on VHS and now making its first appearance on DVD.  The show was filmed at Red Rocks Amphitheater in Colorado on June 5, 1983 while the band was touring in support of War. The DVD will include five songs that were not part of the Red Rocks VHS release and a director's commentary.  Additionally, the video has been digitally cleaned up and the sound has been re-mixed in 5.1 surround.

The Under a Blood Red Sky album has been remastered, but that's about it.  It's the same 8-song sampler of tracks culled from three different War tour shows that it was when it was released in 1984. 

The CD and DVD will be sold separately; they'll also be sold together in a collector's edition.  I wonder if they'll charge $29.99 for it.  Never mind.

I must say I consider myself… disappointed.  I am excited about Red Rocks coming to DVD, but the way this re-release is a missed opportunity.  It's also a slap in the face to every sucker out there who paid $29.99 (or whatever you paid) for the deluxe edition of War.

Under a Blood Red Sky is eight songs from three shows.  That in and of itself is about as worthless a live album as you could conceive.  That's not even an album.  Let's start calling it what it is- this is an EP.  Meanwhile, you have the Red Rocks show.  It was 13 songs.  It's now 18. 

Let's look at some possible ways they could have gotten this right and given fans value for their money.  Let's backtrack just a moment and look at the U2 re-issues from last month, War in particular.  It was released with a "bonus" disc that had seven remixes of two songs.  Blood Red Sky is eight songs from the War tour.  If you weren't going to add anything special to the Blood Red Sky album, why not blow off the pointless remixes and make it the War bonus disc?  You could still slap the three or four other non-remix songs on to the end of it. 

If they didn't want to do that, they could have scrapped the remixes in favor of non-BRS live material from the War tour.  We know that BRS was culled from three shows.  I'm betting there are other songs from those shows lying around that could have been mined.  Hell, I bet they have several shows in the can that could have provided more interesting material than those damn remixes.

All right, so let's say they decide to leave the War set as is because they think those stupid remixes are interesting.  Why not expand Blood Red Sky with more songs from the three shows that contributed the eight already present?  

Why not give us a 2-CD set of the entire Red Rocks show?  They could spread this out over two discs.  They could do Red Rocks in its entirety and tack on remastered Blood Red Sky tracks not from the Red Rocks show at the end. 

There are so many ways things they could have done to make the War re-issue and the Blood Red Sky re-issue more interesting for the diehard fans who are being asked to shell out money for this stuff a second time.

Under a Blood Red Sky CD

  1. Gloria
  2. 11 O’Clock Tick Tock
  3. I Will Follow
  4. Party Girl  
  5. Sunday Bloody Sunday  
  6. The Electric Co.
  7. New Year’s Day
  8. “40”

Live at Red Rocks DVD

  1. Out Of Control  
  2. Twilight  
  3. An Cat Dubh
  4. Into The Heart
  5. Surrender
  6. Two Hearts Beat As One
  7. Seconds
  8. Sunday Bloody Sunday
  9. Cry/The Electric Co.
  10. October
  11. New Year’s Day
  12. I Threw A Brick Through A Window
  13. A Day Without Me
  14. Gloria  
  15. Party Girl
  16. 11 O’Clock Tick Tock
  17. I Will Follow
  18. “40”

Original VHS Listing

  1. "Surrender"
  2. "Seconds"
  3. "Sunday Bloody Sunday"
  4.  "The Cry/The Electric Co./Send in the Clowns"
  5.  "October"
  6.  "New Year's Day"
  7.  "I Threw a Brick Through a Window"
  8.  "A Day Without Me"
  9.  "Gloria"
  10.  "Party Girl"
  11.  "11 O'Clock Tick Tock"
  12.  "I Will Follow"
  13.  "40"

About Josh Hathaway

Check Also

SXSW Film Review: Alt-Rock Documentary ‘I Get Knocked Down’

In Dunstan Bruce's quasi-documentary about his former band, Chumbawamba, he reflects on his life as he's rounding 60.