Wednesday , May 29 2024
Thomas Crawford conducts the American Classical Orchestra
Thomas Crawford conducts the American Classical Orchestra

Concert Review: American Classical Orchestra – ‘Eroica’ (NYC, 17 May 2019)

The American Classical Orchestra played Beethoven’s Third Symphony “Eroica” and Coriolan Overture on period instruments at Lincoln Center’s Alice Tully Hall on Friday night. I look forward to ACO concerts, and not only for the warm sound of the instruments and the musicians’ great collaborative skill. Conductor Thomas Crawford‘s revealing and amusing explanations and demonstrations of salient aspects of the music are also, for me, a big draw.

Hearing the orchestra play some of the music’s key themes and motifs in isolation is a boon to appreciation, whether you know the music well or have never heard it before. That’s especially so with a titanic piece like Beethoven’s Symphony No. 3, known as the Eroica (“heroic”). Often performed, but not so often on original instruments, and seldom explicated in concert, the symphony gained more meaning for me at this concert than it had in the past.

An understanding of what the composer was doing wouldn’t do much good, though, without a sterling performance. The ACO delivered one, beginning with an appetizer, Beethoven’s Coriolan Overture. That piece eased us into the orchestra’s relatively mellow sound, a sound we don’t often hear in these canonical works when they’re played by modern orchestras with their crisp technical precision (which the ACO shares) and up-to-the-minute equipment (which it pointedly doesn’t, visibly as well as sonically).

It was immediately apparent that Beethoven’s vocabulary of force and tension comes through quite clearly when played by the instruments of his time. In some ways, they even allow the subtleties of the orchestration to shine more clearly. Strings, winds, and brass slide securely into their places, never competing for focus or volume.

Acclimated by the Coriolan, itself in a “heroic” mood, I listened to the ACO’s humanized Eroica with deepened appreciation. Again, Crawford avoided extremes. Rolling the first movement steadily forward, he found the sweet spot for the tempo, keeping it as steady as one could ask for all the way to the righteous conclusion.

Beautiful balance, especially between the strings and woodwinds, made the second movement that rare funeral march you don’t want to end. The bass viols’ pickups and responses under the main theme sang with fatherly power. The tempo ebbed and flowed subtly as Crawford maintained the march’s strange momentum.

The orchestra found all the high spirits in the Scherzo movement’s contrasting rhythms and unexpected accents. The horn fanfares punctuated the music baldly but smoothly. Throughout, each voice came through distinct and assured.

The Finale too was energetically virtuosic, with a finely articulated fugue. The “Eroica” proved a seriously jubilant finish to the ACO’s season. Altogether Crawford and the orchestra showed once again their mastery of the classical repertoire, as well as their ardent feeling for this deathless music.

The orchestra is preparing for its upcoming 35th season, with music of Mozart, Vivaldi, Bach, Schubert, and Mendelssohn, the ACO Chorus, a Christmas concert featuring Scarlatti’s Christmas Cantata, a family program with recorder virtuoso Horacio Franco, and – naturally – more Beethoven, whose 250th birth anniversary arrives in 2020. Visit the ACO website for details and tickets.

About Jon Sobel

Jon Sobel is Publisher and Executive Editor of Blogcritics as well as lead editor of the Culture & Society section. As a writer he contributes most often to Music, where he covers classical music (old and new) and other genres, and Culture, where he reviews NYC theater. Through Oren Hope Marketing and Copywriting at you can hire him to write or edit whatever marketing or journalistic materials your heart desires. Jon also writes the blog Park Odyssey at where he is on a mission to visit every park in New York City. He has also been a part-time working musician, including as lead singer, songwriter, and bass player for Whisperado.

Check Also

Riverside Choral Society

Concert Review: Riverside Choral Society – New York Premiere of Scott Ordway’s ‘The End of Rain’

Riverside Choral Society sang music of John Luther Adams and Alberto Grau and the New York premiere of 'The End of Rain' by Scott Ordway, an impassioned response to the California wildfires.