Today on Blogcritics
Home » TV » TV Review: Supernatural – “Point of No Return”

TV Review: Supernatural – “Point of No Return”

Please Share...Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

Team Freewill is back! Once again this show, especially writer Jeremy Carver, manages to pack quite a bit into 40 minutes. To quote one of the writers on my website, “Point of No Return” is “flipping insanely awesome!”

For this very special 100th episode, themes that have driven the core of this show are brought to the forefront and delivered in mind-blowing fashion. One theme is the importance of family. This time, the family bond goes beyond blood, for Castiel and Bobby are there too, as well as a reluctant half-family member. Loyalty and heroism are explored too but come from different sources. Finally faith, which has been a dominant theme of late, gets its due as well.

The heart of this story rests in the heart of the series in general, the turbulent brotherly relationship between Sam and Dean. What makes this situation unique though is there’s a total role reversal from the end of last season. Sam is now the one who must step up and take control and the result is a big (and overdue) breakthrough for his character and the brotherly relationship.

The Breakdown

The opener is classic Supernatural. A dejected Zachariah shares “downsizing” stories with a “pig filthy” human in a bar. This episode may have been written by Jeremy Carver, but the grim humor in this scene has Ben Edlund written all over it. Zach bonds with the jobless man, but doesn’t seem to care too much when the guy’s eardrums explode and eyes burn out when his boss appears. Zachariah has a second chance and passes by the carnage while signing. Has he learned from his mistakes? Um, not really.

Meanwhile Dean sits alone in private agony in a motel room, pouring drinks and writing the farewell note to Sam. We all die a little as Dean somberly packs a box with what few belongings he has: his leather jacket, his gun, and the keys to the Impala. Luckily Sam can track Dean too, accenting the role reversal that takes place in the episode (nice touch of 100 on the motel room door too). Sam’s taking Dean’s disappearing act personally. “How could you do that?” he asks Dean with bitterness and hurt. Dean does what he can to discourage Sam, even throwing Sam’s similar behavior in the past back at him. Sam admits he was wrong and has to stop him. Dean alludes to their fight in “When The Levee Breaks,” for Sam isn’t hopped up on demon blood this time. Sam shakes it off because he has an ace up his sleeve. Enter one furious angel.

Sam takes the role of leader and fights to hold everything together (including himself). Thanks to Castiel’s interception of the latest dastardly angelic plan, Sam has to deal with two brothers on each side of him not acting with rationality. Taking lumps from Dean is one thing but he gets Adam’s defiant attitude, who turns out to be a carbon copy of the oldest Winchester. Sam tries hard to relate, to bond, to use “blood” as a reason to stay together, but Adam won’t accept any of that. John Winchester wasn’t his father in his eyes. His mother was all he had and he just wants to see her again like the angels promised if he becomes Michael’s “sword.” He’s not about to believe that angels would lie to him but definitely thinks his so-called brothers would.


In the meantime Dean at his lowest point does all he can to alienate those who are trying to stop him. He insults Bobby and gets a tongue lashing for that and he spends the entire episode trading annoyed glances and snide comments with Castiel. Dean’s treatment of Sam though is the harshest, and the tension gets really raw when Dean is locked in the panic room. Dean won’t allow Adam to say yes and while Sam is in agreement, he’s not letting Dean do that either. Sam pleads that he stop the self-sacrificing and they stick together. Dean, as seen in many situations before, gives the brutal honesty after Sam asks for it.
Dean: I just, I don’t believe.
Sam: In what?
Dean: In you. I mean, I don’t know if it’s going to be demon blood, or some other demon chick, or what but, I do know they’re going to find a way to turn you.
Sam: So you’re saying I’m not strong enough.
Dean: You’re angry. You’re self-righteous. Lucifer’s going to wear you to the prom man, it’s just a matter of time.
Sam [teary]: Don’t say that to me. Not you. Of all people.
Dean: I don’t want to, but it’s the truth. And when Satan takes you over, there’s gotta be somebody there to fight him, and it ain’t gonna be that kid. So it’s gotta be me.

Ouch. At first I thought it was Dean trying to push Sam away but one of my frequent readers came up with a better analysis. Dean isn’t saying that just to hurt Sam, he really believes it. He’d seen that Sam had said yes to Lucifer in “The End” and has seen Sam cave into weakness before, as recently as their run in with Famine in “My Bloody Valentine.” Angels know weaknesses, just like when Michael got John to say yes in “The Song Remains the Same.” Just like they could with Adam right now. It’s a dire situation that he must end now.

In the middle of this Sam and Dean drama is the troubled Castiel, who also is experiencing a crisis of faith. He’s very angry over Dean’s behavior and is now following Sam’s lead. After Dean tricks him in the panic room and escapes, Castiel tracks him down and beats the crap out of him, letting all his resentment out. “I rebelled for this? So you could surrender to them? I gave everything for you and this is what you give to me?” He returns a battered Dean back to Sam, his faith in Dean now completely gone.


Despite Sam’s efforts, the angels do get to Adam and take him away. If Sam shows any signs of cracking, its right after he finds out Adam is gone. Castiel knows where they have taken him though, so now Sam must pull it together and make some tough decisions. So, if you only have an unstable angel and a handicapped guy as your backup, how do you plan an offensive against a squad of angels? By admitting the truth. Sam can’t do this alone. He takes a huge gamble and throws every he has on the one thing he’s always counted on his entire life, his big brother.

In the second gut-wrenching panic room scene, Dean comes to and Sam calmly delivers the plan. Sam uncuffs Dean and tells him he’s going with him to get Adam. Dean points out what a bad idea this is, but even though Bobby and Cas think so, Sam’s not so sure. Dean thinks they’re right, for it’s a trap to get him there to make him say yes or it’s not and he’s going to say yes anyway which he warns he will. Sam says he won’t, taking a huge leap of faith in the one person who’s never let him down. Dean tries again with the brutal honesty. “You know if tables were turned, I’d let you rot in here. Hell, I have let you rot in here.” Sam tries to not let the comment get the better of him, even though his big sigh shows how much it stings. “Yeah, well, I guess I’m not that smart.” Why is he doing this? “Because, you’re still my big brother.” The brotherly drama by this point has ripped a loyal fan’s heart to shreds and there’s more to come!

Yes, it’s funny that the Green Room from “Lucifer Rising” is really in an abandoned muffler factory in Van Nuys. This is after all the Wal-Mart apocalypse. What’s not so funny though is Castiel, who has nothing left to lose. He’s going to take on five angels on his own, even though it’s suicide. He bitterly explains to Dean, “But then I won’t have to watch you fail. Sorry Dean, I don’t have the same faith in you that Sam does.” There are two big fist-pumping parts of this episode, the first coming when Castiel executes his brilliant (yet sacrificial) plan. He carves the angel-banishing sigil onto his chest, waits until the angels are close enough, and zaps them and himself away. There’s the badass Castiel that’s been missing most of this season!

Dean goes to rescue Adam and once he’s floored by the family loyalty, he warns Dean it’s a trap. Dean knows. Sam tries to take out Zachariah, but he’s not fast enough and gets tossed across the room, injured in the process. Adam and Sam both begin coughing up blood and a fragile Dean can’t stand to see those he loves in pain anymore. He says the dreaded yes and this next sequence is brilliant. Hats off to director Phil Sgriccia as well as Jared and Jensen.


While Zachariah turns with malevolent smile, summoning the almighty Michael, Dean and Sam unfold the next part of the story with just glances. This isn’t the first time Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecki have sold an entire sequence with only nonverbal exchanges and once again it’s incredible. In the first glance Dean is apologetic and Sam is crushed with betrayal. Next Dean goes back to Sam with the same look of remorse and Sam looks away in agony. Sam looks at him again with soul-crushing disappointment and right there Dean’s expression falls, hinting he’s changed his mind. Sam sees it and knows something is up. Dean cracks a tiny smile and then winks. He’s back!


While Zachariah thinks he’s beaten Dean with his weakness of family, Dean turns the tables on Zachariah’s weakness, his huge ego. He will say yes to Michael as long as some conditions are met; one is Michael gets to obliterate Zachariah. He’s appalled, claiming Michael would never do that to him. Dean cleverly points out who’s more important. While Zachariah goes off on Dean in rage, that’s enough for Dean to grab the angel-killing sword without notice. He plunges the sword through Zachariah’s chin, and watches him flame out. There’s the other fist-pumping “hell yeah!” moment, the kind that makes fans fall in love with this show all over again.

But wait, how could Dean do that? Didn’t Uriel point out last season that the only thing that can kill an angel is another angel? Just like with the Whore of Babylon in the previous episode, there’s a mystery looming over why Dean can suddenly kill these beings. The close-up of his glowing eyes instead of them burning out is a clue, leaving so much more to that twist we need to know.

Now for the final brotherly scene, and it’s the most satisfying one in a long time, maybe in the entire series. They’re riding back in a pickup truck and Sam asks what we all want to know. Why did Dean change his mind? “Honestly, the damndest thing. I mean the world’s ending, the walls are coming down on us, I look over at you and all I can think about is, ‘this stupid son of a bitch brought me here.’ I just didn’t want to let you down.” Aww! There’s the overprotective big brother we all know and love. Sam says he didn’t let him down. Dean has indeed found his faith again and in the best place, for his little brother isn’t the “snot-nosed kid” anymore that he’s had to keep on the “straight and narrow.” “Hell, if you’re grown up enough to find faith in me, least I can do is return the favor.” It’s time to fight their way. Sam agrees with a smile. A happy ending! It’s about time!

The Analysis

This episode has some significant character development, particularly Sam Winchester’s coming of age. We’ve waited so long to see him step up, to redeem himself from his past misjudgments, and he does it by sticking with the one thing he’s always believed in, his big brother. His faith never wavers and that is all that’s needed to get through. It’s inspiring to see him mature like this after everything that’s happened. Dean is pulled from his lowest of lows by the one person he never believed could save him. Now he does believe and the brotherly bond is stronger than ever. Strong enough to take on the end of the world. It’s awesome.

What about Castiel’s sacrifice? Since we know he’ll be back, will he be able to mend things with Dean? Will their relationship go back to what it was, or even stronger? I’m curious from what source Castiel will find strength and hope again. Maybe he’ll rely more on both brothers? Is it possible now that Zachariah’s dead he’ll get some help from other angels? Nah, that’s a little too optimistic.

Another theme that seems to be repeated here is how angels (and demons too) underestimate the power of the human spirit. This is none more true than Zachariah’s “second” chance. His downfall comes from his short sightedness. He didn’t come back wiser or with a new respect for humanity. His continued hatred and manipulation is worse than ever, and he is blinded trying to fight the one thing that has held him back all this time. These two brothers are not about to let each other down. They’ve already learned what happens when they do.

It’s funny how Dean jokes with Adam that “We’re working on the power of love,” and that in the end is exactly what ends up saving them! That might end up being the answer after all.

There’s no Impala in this episode? In the 100th? How could that be? That’s my only nitpick of this episode though.

Memorable Quotes

“Maybe they wrongly assumed that Dean would be strong enough to withstand them.”

“You know what, blow me Cas.”

“That's the round I mean to put through my skull. Every morning, I look at it. I think, ‘Maybe today is the day I'll flip the lights out.’ But I don't do it. I never do it. You know why? Because I promised you I wouldn't give up!”

“You know, you pitch the whole dewy-eyed bromance thing, but the truth is I’m on lockdown, aren’t I?”

“What, we gonna to hop into the Family Truckster? Pop on down to Wally World?”

“Cas, not for nothing, but the last person who looked at me like that…I got laid.”

“You know Sam and Dean Winchester are psychotically, irrationally, erotically, co-dependent on each other, right?”

“I’m Dean Winchester, do you know how I am?” “Dear God.” “I’ll take that as a yes.”

“Word to the wise. Don’t piss off the nerd angels.”

“I don’t know. Jupiter, a blade of grass, not Van Nuys.”

“Before Michael gets one piece of this sweet ass, he has to turn you into a piece of charcoal.”

Overall grade, an A+. You know I’ve given a few of those lately, but the writing has just gotten so good and that’s where I tend to give the higher marks. The episode is well paced, well directed, has great drama, acting, tension, is quote-worthy, and for once has a satisfying conclusion. Who wouldn’t rave about that? Next week, I really have no idea what it’s all about. We’ll find out.

Powered by

About Alice Jester

  • Tiecg1

    I really liked this ep. Great recap as always Alice. You really have a great enthusiasm.

    You know, about the smile/wink from Dean to Sam in the Green Room — I seriously had like a freakin’ shallow moment seeing Dean do that; it flashed me back to the pilot because he looked ten years younger in that moment (both men normally look so worn out these days). It totally caught me off guard cause I was so into the tense storyline and wondering if we were finally going to see Michael or the brothers were going to actually die… then “that”, and it was like seeing blood splatter on the camera lens (like “Dead Men Don’t Wear Plaid”/Children of Men… totally jarred me right out of the scene). In one moment Dean turned from some jerk who I was thrilled to see get beat up by Castiel (who rocked in this ep) to a younger, confident adorable Dean who I had been missing for quite a while now (possibly two seasons?) Brilliant acting by Jensen on his part.

    The glue of the ep was Sammy though, who also reminded me of a season 2 Sam with all the emotional sensitivity but with a new brand of calmness under severe pressure. I still believe that Dean was trying to hurt Sam by telling him how he felt whether Dean meant it or not, just to push Sam away so he could have less guilt about accepting Michael. If Sam was demon-blood high, that would have pushed him over the edge, but Sam held it together. Yea for Sammy! (and kudos to Jared for his brilliant protrayal of lovable Sam).

  • carlotspeak

    I seem to remember this quote from somewhere: “If you can’t live without me, why aren’t you dead already?” LOL My viewing of Supernatural are no longer complete until I get to read your review ^_^ And the patience is paying off this week as usual. There were so many reviews for the 100 episodes, but I think your perspective about the episode and the family theme etc. was the best and most complete! Your own quote of Wal-Mart apocalypse is priceless too! I have a few questions of my own, may be because I am still a bit confused.

    1) In the Song when Michael was expounding ‘random acts of chance all lead back to the same (planned) destiny’ – would not that include Zachariah’s acts of mismanaging his own scheme over and over?

    2) This is not a question but my personal tiny bitty disappointment at many kills the brothers did comparing to Castiel that I noticed. The way of old when heroes go into battle they challenge openly and kill each others. I can see the brothers must use deceptive ways a lot to kill monsters, and evils and so on, but it was the first time I witnessed Dean slaughtered an angel. It disconcerted me only a little bit. I know that it was the only way. And I was hoping (foolishly) that he would pushed his brother out of the room and stayed behind to explained his act to Michael instead of running away. I am glad to read your detailed review because it put things in a bit more perspective. No matter how malicious Zachariah was, it is hard to put aside the idea that he was not the angel of ‘the Lord’ ^_^ To see him did his surprise attack plus the way he stab Zack which I thought reserve for only bad things was not that easy.

    3) =SPOILER Guessing= I think it looked like Adam had a visit with Michael back in the room. We should see development from it.

    4) Last question: The end episode that you refer to in this review; would it be possible that that future vision is no longer valid? The colt? Sam and Dean not seeing each other for 5 years? Zachariah still alive? etc. None of these are no longer irrelevant.

    I love the episode! Every quotes were great. Agree with the score. Thank you very much for your review!

  • Huppy

    Alice, I loved this 100th episode!

    Sam was wonderful, keeping it together, dealing with two unhappy and difficult brothers, and providing the leadership in the episode. He never let his anger get the best of him, although his exasperation did show when Adam disappeared.

    I think Dean really did mean what he told Sam in the panic room–that he didn’t trust him to say no to Lucifer. Seeing Sam as Lucifer in “The End” really shook up Dean, even though we now know that “The End” will never happen, since Sam and Dean are together and they already know the Colt won’t work against Lucifer. And Sam had hurt Dean last year, with his dishonesty and following Ruby’s advice. But mostly, Dean didn’t have any faith in Sam because Dean didn’t have any faith in himself.

    But Sam, with his renewed strength, did have faith in Dean, and showed that faith and love. Dean, in not wanting to let Sam down, found the faith in himself he had been lacking.

    Zach was a great character and Kurt Fuller portrayed him wonderfully, but it was so satisfying to see Dean kill Zach. Loved it!

    I was really glad to see Adam back. Once they introduced a third brother in JTS, I was on-board with the idea–it made sense that John could have another child. So I was sorry that Adam died before he ever met Sam and Dean. I think Jake did a good job with the character, and I hope we see Adam again, even on a recurring basis.

    The one who needs to find his faith now is Castiel. We have seen him disillusioned (DSOTM and 99 Probs), and in PONR, Castiel went from angry to without hope. I look forward to his return from the outfield and his learning what happened in the green room. Faith is contagious, and if Sam and Dean have it, then Castiel should also find it.

  • Baronius

    This episode really bothered me. I just feel like every possible sentence with the words “trust”, “doubt”, “mistakes”, and “family” has already been uttered, and this episode didn’t add anything. If anything, it set us back a few episodes by wiping out the whole “Dean has doubts” storyline. I dunno, I’m probably just still ticked off that the show is going to have a sixth season, which kind of makes the remainder of this season pointless.

  • carlotspeak

    Haha: Can’t help imagine Baronius as ‘the Hookman’ in The Real Ghostbusters, and me as Becky yelling at him from the back row of the room. Sorry, dear friend. Just kidding you. LOL

  • Baronius

    Carlot – Sigh. I never planned on becoming an internet troll! Every time I see someone complaining about a show they watch, I think “just stop watching it”. I think I’m done with the show at the end of this season. It’s had some great moments, though.

  • maguie

    Hi Alice your review excellent as always.
    I loved the entire episode. but I have a quesion I don’t know if you could answer me, you said that the letter that Dean wrote was for Sam, are you sure? cause in other site someone said that the letter was for Bobby, that he or she read that Dean wrote: “for me that makes you a winchester” or something like that, but I tried to read the letter and I couldn’t understand anything.

  • http://www.thewinchesterfamilybusiness.com Alice Jester

    Thanks everyone for the comments! I’ll answer the questions to the best of my ability! Warning, SPOILERS!!

    Carlotspeak – Wow great point. I wonder if Michael knew that Zachariah was doomed to fail. He had to have known about Zachariah’s short sightedness. I’m still hoping we hear more from Michael before the season is out. I know (SPOILER) Gabriel will be back, so maybe he’ll say something.

    There must be something more to Dean being able to kill Zachariah. I’m still holding judgment there. Another SPOILER – I heard Adam will be back by the end of the season too. Only because Jake Abel was listed as a guest star. So yes, Adam’s story probably isn’t done either.

    Is the events of “The End” still valid. Oh yes. Very much so. Dean had no idea what led up to those developments. As far as we know, Dean said no, Sam said yes and that’s all that needs to happen. Of course Sam and Dean didn’t part ways and Dean killed Zachariah, but remember the angels still believe “all roads lead to the same destination.” Freewill vs. destiny. There’s still much more of that to play out!

    Baronius – Sorry for your disappointment. I’ve had that happen to me with other shows. Sadly, I have had to walk away. I’m sure it can’t be that much worse sticking around to see how this all plays out this season. After all, you’ve put in this much time! The sixth season is a restart. This apocalypse arc will end this season.

    Maguie – Supernatural wiki has parts of the letter on their breakdown of the episode (supernatural wiki is the best fandom resource out there). Since I wrote the review, more has come out about it. The letter is definitely for Castiel, Bobby, and Sam. Each paragraph is for each one of them.

  • Marianne

    i agree with all the comments and your review. I think that Dean was so broken inside that he was being cruel with Sam to send him away, to not have to feel any more guilt for saying yes to michael. if Sam would hate him then yes wouldn’t be such a difficult answer. I loved how Dean smirked at Sam it reminded me of playful badboy Dean and how he killed Zachariah (by the way why is Dean killing everyone? Zachariah, yellow-eyed demon, the whore? and Sam only killed Lilith which lead to Lucifer rising. Sam needs to kill a bad guy, Dean had killed too many already). I still don’t get how can Dean kill angels if only angels can kill angels and why his eyes become so white (which was awesome). By the way did anyone notice that when Michael was about to come and everything started shaking and that noise came, SAM AND DEAN COVERED THEIR EYES BECAUSE THE NOISE OF MICHAEL COMING DOWN HURT THEIR EARS, BUT ADAM DIDN’T EVEN FLINCH? HE JUST LOOKED UPWORDS, HE DIDN’T EVEN COVER HIS EARS. REMEMBER WHEN JIMMY COULD HEAR CASTIEL’S TRUE VOICE? MAYBE ADAM COULD HEAR MICHAEL too