Today on Blogcritics
Home » Music » Reviews music » Music Review: Neil Young – Live at Massey Hall

Music Review: Neil Young – Live at Massey Hall

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

There's just something about Neil Young. His present day persona along with his musical past form a sort of rolling time capsule in my head. Very strange, much like the man himself. This particular album, recorded 1971 at Toronto's Massey Hall, showcases Young and his songwriting at an early career peak. Played on acoustic guitar and sometimes piano, Young definitely had that audience in full control. Many of the songs, new at the time, went on to become part of his classic Harvest LP.

But that's getting a little ahead of things.

I have a weird mental association with the song "Heart Of Gold." That song was being played right around the time that I was learning how to play the guitar. In fact, that little opening two chord riff was the first thing I ever forced my poor little fingers to play. Not so strange, I know, but then there's Angel the Chihuahua. That was my cousin Bobby's dog. I woke up one morning after a sleepover and there's Angel at the foot of the bed. Like most dogs of that breed, Angel was more than a little nervous. Unfortunately, this made Angel shake. A lot. Also, she seemed to let out a continuous growl, complete with raised lip dog-type sneer. So I sit up, Angel launches into the symphony of Mexican dog fear, and my blood runs cold. Of course, it's early in the morning and I've got to pee pretty badly. Great.

I'd like to finish that story, but there are no details at my disposal. If I back up twelve hours though, there's the entire evening spent teaching myself Neil Young's "Heart Of Gold." Back to that morning instant of terror, the last fragment I can recall was thinking that, man, my fingers were sore. That acoustic guitar lived on for nearly another decade, dying a pathetic death against the basement wall one hormone-raged night as the 1970's drew to a close (Let's just say that I had a temper).

Now we take a time rocket to the year that The Band's The Last Waltz came out. At that point, I'd be willing to wager that I still didn't own any Neil Young records. What opened my eyes was seeing Young sing "Helpless" (with Joni Mitchel on high harmony). My goodness, what the hell was that?! Maybe further investigation is warranted? Yes.

There are a pile more of these anecdotes, from the timeless Rust Never Sleeps (nestled between memories of learning how to drive a stick shift in my sister's Volkswagen and the horror of a family member's alcoholism) to my friend Steve doing a hilarious Neil Young-meets-Johnny Mathis version of "Sugar Mountain," to giggly and drunken listens through the Trans and The Shocking Pinks records to the beautiful singularity of Harvest Moon to the earthy crunch of seeing Greendale performed live, to witnessing the Internet bluster surrounding Living With War.

What I like about Young is his artistic honestly. Folks used to love bashing Trans until they discovered the connection to Young's handicapped son. Say what you want about the music, Young's intent has always been pure.

So all of these years later the Massey Hall record, long a Young fan bootleg, has finally been released. It's a fine album. The content of the songs is cranked up quite a bit with this intimate setting. There may be no Crazy Horse sonic heaviness on "Cowgirl In The Sand," but the emotional directness of the setting more than makes up for it. Honestly, this is not a fan-only release.

So there's your rolling time capsule. Maybe the only series of stories involving both a smashed guitar, an alcoholic, and a Chihuahua. It just shows you the power of all music, not just this particular record.

Powered by

About Mark Saleski

  • Glen Boyd

    Nicely done Mark. I was a little disapointed in this simply because my expectations were raised pretty high by the notion of getting something actually new here (I didn’t get the version with the DVD). But taken on it’s merits, it’s definitely a great accoustic Neil Young live record. As usual with your stuff though, I really enjoyed the personal annecdotes associated with Neil. Just don’t get me started on the “the Internet bluster surrounding Living With War…”


  • JC Mosquito

    Sure, get into it!

    I played it only once – the best description I could give it on one play is that Neil’s turned to writing formla Neil Young songs – the buzzy guitar, the cranky artist as an old man stance, the really, really good song lurking about under the messy production. I dunno – I’d like to hear one more killer album from him in his dotage – I’m sure it’s still in there.

  • Mark Saleski

    oh ya, i didn’t mean to imply that your disappointment was somehow invalid. i can see how if a person was waiting for something all of those years and then there was no “kaboom”…well sure, completely understandable.

    and yes, let’s skip the bluster. there’s enough of that around here already.

  • C. Michael Bailey

    A very thoughtful review. “Heart of Gold” was the first song I was to learn to play on guitar (with the same sore fingers). Years later, I frequently tore up “Powderfinger,” which I thought the greatest Country song ever written,

    I await a full-blown, bone crushing electric release, circa “Live at the Fillmore East” with twice the music.

  • Connie Phillips

    Congrats! This article has been forwarded to the websites and (going live soon).