Today on Blogcritics
Home » Books » Book Reviews » Book Review: The Supervision Solution: Manage Performance, Not People by John Roulet

Book Review: The Supervision Solution: Manage Performance, Not People by John Roulet

Please Share...Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

If you’re a manager and are looking for a formula to apply to your team so as to improve their performance, a word to the wise: this is not the book for you.

If you’re a manager and are looking for a great, easy, and fast way to increase your team’s performance and thus hopefully decrease your workload – why are you a manager again? – in any case, if that’s so, the same advice applies: this book is not for you.

Ever heard of the expression: “give a man a fish, feed him for a day, teach a man to fish, feed him for life”? Well this expression could be remodelled thus, summing up this book: “Give a manager a formula, help him manage for a while, help a manager understand management, help him manage for life”.

Hey, I’m a writer, not a poet.

The author of The Supervision Solution: Manage Performance, Not People, John Roulet, tells us early on that the leader who most inspired him is Gandhi. The implications are huge: you, as a manager, are expected to be humble, to work hard, to stay true to your principles and to expect nothing in return. See what I mean about this book not being for the faint of heart?

The fact that the author’s manager of choice is Gandhi bodes quite well. However, I have to admit that I wasn’t ready to believe John Roulet did consider Gandhi as ‘the real deal’ unless, having finished the book, I found that all of it reflected his philosophy.

Then I realised that I didn’t know as much as I thought I did about Gandhi. Oh well. I tried.

In all seriousness, this is a great book for managers and leaders of all sorts to read. For it doesn’t go into complicated diatribes about the philosophy of leadership, nor does it give boring, one-dimensional formulas that are said to work; rather, it accompanies managers to understand how they can become leaders, and bring out the inherent qualities in the individuals forming the teams they manage.

The premise is simple: all people inherently possess the potential to contribute positively to any organisation or team that they belong to. A manager, who is also a leader of sorts, helps bring about the conditions making it possible for the team’s potential – which is higher than the sum of each individual’s potential – to be as high as it can possibly be. It’s about removing obstacles so that people can become who they potentially can be. This is why humility is so important, for a true manager realises that he is a facilitator rather than a creator of greatness.

If used correctly, The Supervision Solution can give any manager the tools required to create winning conditions within the team. As I mentioned earlier, there is no easy formula to apply, and this book certainly isn’t going to help you apply a Band-Aid, if you are looking for one to quickly stop the bleeding that might be happening within your own team. John Roulet’s management style will make you work hard on the short term, but bring forth success in the long term.

There are five sections to the book: a definition of what leadership is (which is important, for, as John Roulet explains it, the predominant definition of leadership in today’s management discourse doesn’t reflect what leadership really is, but rather what it has become); the system in which leadership can function at its best; how to apply leadership; the skills, tools, and methods of supervision; and the road ahead. Each chapter is filled with concrete anecdotes and ends with a concise couple of paragraphs about what needs to be remembered. The writing is concise; the author clearly knows what he is talking about and doesn’t feel the need to fill up the pages with useless chatter, which is very refreshing.

Another interesting note: The Supervision Solution has been printed on thick paper, as if confident enough to be kept for a long time on one’s shelf and not just to make it full, but rather to be consulted. Cute cartoons break the text every couple of pages. The only thing I would have wished for are thicker margins to allow for Post-its and/or handwritten notes. But that’s OK, because I’m probably going to reread this book many times in the upcoming months, as you should. Because as those of you who have been reading my various blog posts know, I’m all about grassroots activities and for them to be successful, it takes a lot of leadership and management skills.

Powered by

About Sahar

  • http://runningbowline.com Chris Bancells

    Interesting review. Sounds like a book worth reading, by both me and those I follow.

  • John Roulet

    Sahar,

    Thank you for the insightful and supportive review. I was so pleased to read that you intend to refer to the text in the months ahead. I hope you’ll contact me if you have any questions or would like to discuss any of the concepts. The same, of course, applies to your readers.

    Best regards,

    John [Personal contact info deleted]

  • http://saharsblog.wordpress.com Sahar

    Chris, this is definitely a great book – and you know what, I think it isn’t only leaders who should read it, but every member of a team.

    John, thank you for reading my review of your book – I’m glad you liked it! Unfortunately your personal information got deleted from the comment, and I couldn’t find your website on Google. Could you please refer us to it?

  • John Roulet

    Sahar,

    Please excuse the time it has taken me to get back to you. Things have been quite hectic and I’m not managing my time nearly as well as I should. Thank you so much for the kind words about my work; it’s very validating. [Personal contact info deleted]

    Have a great day!

    John