Wednesday , April 17 2024
With a uniformly excellent cast, this bracing version of Gotthold Lessing's German Enlightenment play hits home with its then (and still) controversial view of religion: that no faith has the uniquely true message of God.

Theater Review (NYC): ‘Nathan the Wise’ with F. Murray Abraham and Stark Sands

Stark Sands and F. Murray Abraham in Classic Stage Company's 'Nathan the Wise.' Photograph: © 2016 Richard Termine
Stark Sands and F. Murray Abraham in Classic Stage Company’s ‘Nathan the Wise.’ Photograph: © 2016 Richard Termine

Classic Stage Company‘s bracing, timely new production of Gotthold Ephraim Lessing’s 1779 comedy-drama Nathan the Wise stars F. Murray Abraham in the title role. If this didn’t risk insulting the Oscar-winning actor’s long-running body of fine work on stage and screen, I’d venture to suggest that this fictional Jewish merchant of Crusader-era Jerusalem – said to have been inspired by Lessing’s friend, the philosopher Moses Mendelssohn – was the role Abraham was born to play.

Lessing was a German theatrical innovator and champion of the Enlightenment. In this, his last play, he wrapped a powerful humanistic statement in the robes of a secret-identity storytelling marathon, written in verse and playing out over more than four hours. Directed by Brian Kulick in a sharp and sharply compressed 21st-century translation by Edward Kemp, CSC’s production succeeds brilliantly at, in Kemp’s words, making “Lessing’s arguments immediate and accessible to the audience on one hearing…to make the play’s dialectic more theatrically alive and more actively inhabited by the characters – and to make it a manageable evening in the theatre.”

Over a very manageable two hours and 10 minutes, a uniformly excellent cast hits home with Lessing’s then (and still) controversial view of religion: that no faith has the uniquely true message of God; they are all equally valid paths to goodness, grace, godliness, or whatever you choose to call it.

The year is 1192. The great sultan Saladin (Austin Durant) rules Jerusalem and most of the Holy Land while Frankish Crusaders control a part of the coastline, but peace reigns for a few precious years. Nathan, a wealthy merchant with a marriageable daughter, Rachel (Erin Neufer), returns from a trading trip to learn two pieces of interesting news: his young Muslim friend and chess companion, the dervish Al-Hafi (a crafty, winning performance by George Abud), has joined the sultan’s inner circle as treasurer; and Rachel has been rescued from a fire by a mysterious young Knight Templar (a raw, powerful turn by Stark Sands of Kinky Boots fame).

The Templar was on the scene only because the sentimental sultan had spared his life on spotting a strong resemblance between the young German and Saladin’s long-dead brother. Could this likeness be more than coincidence? The Templar is not the only one who doesn’t know his own true identity.

But before the soap-opera revelations come the ideas. Nathan discovers that both Saladin and the Templar share his (read: Lessing’s) enlightened philosophy, a tolerant, hopeful take on humanity’s potential for working through differences to create a more peaceful world.

Austin Durant and Shiva Kalaiselvan in Classic Stage Company's 'Nathan the Wise.' Photograph: © 2016 Richard Termine
Austin Durant and Shiva Kalaiselvan in Classic Stage Company’s ‘Nathan the Wise.’ Photograph: © 2016 Richard Termine

Yes, these characters seem anachronistically enlightened. But keep in mind that Lessing was avoiding censorship by “hiding” his ideas in a “harmless” work of entertainment.

Textured by strong performances all around, the production smoothly balances the story’s personal and philosophical aspects. Also good are Shiva Kalaiselvan as Saladin’s steely sister Sittah, and Caroline Lagerfelt as Daya, an older Christian woman who has been a companion to Rachel all the girl’s life. (Though that brings me to the one flaw with the production: it’s not clear what Daya’s relationship with Nathan is, or with Rachel for that matter. Reading a synopsis of the original text left me even more confused about what this version intends – here she’s a mother-figure to Rachel and a companion of some sort to Nathan, but what?)

With a scene of Islamic prayer, Arabic writing projected against a backdrop, depiction of casual bigotry toward Jews, and above all, a message of tolerance and the double historical perspective of an ancient setting and 18th century composition, this Nathan the Wise is more than a superb entertainment. It’s a small beacon of light in a dark world, running through May 1 at Classic Stage Company, 136 E. 13 St., NYC. Tickets are available at the website or by calling OvationTix at 866-811-4111.

About Jon Sobel

Jon Sobel is Publisher and Executive Editor of Blogcritics as well as lead editor of the Culture & Society section. As a writer he contributes most often to Music, where he covers classical music (old and new) and other genres, and Culture, where he reviews NYC theater. Through Oren Hope Marketing and Copywriting at you can hire him to write or edit whatever marketing or journalistic materials your heart desires. Jon also writes the blog Park Odyssey at where he is on a mission to visit every park in New York City. He has also been a part-time working musician, including as lead singer, songwriter, and bass player for Whisperado.

Check Also

Rebecca Naomi Jones, Santino Fontana in 'I Can Get it For You Wholesale' at Classic Stage

Theater Review (NYC): ‘I Can Get it For You Wholesale’

'I Can Get it For You Wholesale' reminds us of the toxicity of materialism and the hypocrisy of religious prosperity messages that exclude humanity and neighborly love and decency.