Friday , July 19 2024

P2P Solution?

Fred von Lohmann on possible solution to P2P copyright infringement issue:

    Here’s the only grand solution for P2P that I can imagine (other than
    compulsory licensing) — copyright owners grant blanket licenses to
    end-users thru P2P vendors. Like this:

    Copyright owner appoints any and all P2P vendors as “licensing agents”,
    authorized to pass blanket licenses (or, more realistically, covenants not
    to sue, since most labels don’t know what digital rights they actually
    possess) to end-users, in exchange for a royalty (flat fee, maybe monthly
    maybe one-time, paid thru P2P vendor to copyright owner).

    In this arrangement, P2P vendors do not admit that they are liable (in other
    words, they don’t need the license, the end-users do), but the issue of
    secondary liability is diminished (since if the end-users are licensed,
    there’s no direct infringement on which to base secondary liability).

    The end-user, by paying for the application + license, is relieved from
    uncertainties regarding their ISP cutting them off (under 512i) or fingering
    them for a bust (under 512h). Assuming enough of the majors offer this, the
    end-users wouldn’t have to worry about what to share (just like DJs don’t
    much worry about what to play on a radio station with BMI+ASCAP+SESAC
    licenses). Let’s imagine the apps are limited to sharing audio formats, to
    assuage the movie guys (of course, this will be circumvented by some
    minority of users, but I’m betting it could be lived with).

    Owners get paid, P2P tech flourishes (since the license is available to all
    comers on identical terms, you can imagine rapid and cut-throat innovation
    and competition among tech vendors), and end-users get what they want.

    Presumably, there would always be a few copyright owners who could hold out
    and try to break the system. But once the checks start rolling in, I think
    the emphasis would shift to getting in on the $$, rather than suing end
    users and P2P tech companies. See PROs and radio (you don’t see many smaller
    copyright owners staying out of the PROs, and then lying in wait to spring
    on radio that plays their stuff).

    Also, there would likely remain P2P apps that don’t pay the fees (see LAME
    in the mp3 encoding world), but they would likely diminish in importance
    against the value-added that the royalty-paid apps will provide.

    Of course, a compulsory license could accomplish much the same thing with
    less complexity, but everyone should prefer a “market” solution like this
    one, right? 🙂

About Eric Olsen

Career media professional and serial entrepreneur Eric Olsen flung himself into the paranormal world in 2012, creating the America's Most Haunted brand and co-authoring the award-winning America's Most Haunted book, published by Berkley/Penguin in Sept, 2014. Olsen is co-host of the nationally syndicated broadcast and Internet radio talk show After Hours AM; his entertaining and informative America's Most Haunted website and social media outlets are must-reads: Twitter@amhaunted,, Pinterest America's Most Haunted. Olsen is also guitarist/singer for popular and wildly eclectic Cleveland cover band The Props.

Check Also

Sandra Oh, the company, 'The Welkin'

Theater Review: ‘The Welkin’

When a woman kills the young daughter of a rich landowner, she is found guilty. But her hanging may be suspended because she is pregnant. A group of women are called in to judge whether she is lying.