Monday , February 26 2024
The Foo Fighters rhythm guitarist largely shines on his side project's sophomore release, Harmony And Dissidence.

Music Review: Jackson United – Harmony And Dissidence

Like ex-Nirvana drummer-turned-singer/guitarist extraordinaire Dave Grohl of the Foo Fighters, bandmate and rhythm guitarist Chris Shiflett (also of Me First and the Gimme Gimmes) has looked to make a name for himself in a side project in recent years. While Grohl formed the impressive star-studded heavy metal side project Probot – featuring Lemmy from Motorhead, Max Cavalera and Kim Thayil among others – in 2003, Shiflett quietly put together Jackson United around that same period with his bass-playing brother Scott Shiflett (of Face To Face) and other punk rock veterans.

Jackson United’s 2004 debut LP Western Ballads had a healthy mix of influences, but not all of the material was memorable. Hard-rocking tracks like the Weezer-esque “All The Way,” the airy, twangy “That Curse” and the 1950’s-backbeat-backed “Ok Alright” were among the highlights.

On JU’s latest release, Harmony And Dissidence (Acetate Records), Dave Grohl picks up the drum sticks again (as he did for Queens of the Stone Age several years back) and splits those duties with current Foos drummer Taylor Hawkins, since Shiflett’s group didn’t have a permanent drummer at the time of the recording – now confirmed to be Joe Sirois from Mighty Mighty Bosstones. But its sound is more Face To Face than Foo Fighters, more punk than pop, and puts the POWER in power pop for sure, among other notable attributes.

On lead-off single, the political call-to-arms “21st Century Fight Song,” Shiflett plays the part of the flashy guitar hero for a short solo, and together with the Clash-like reggae-inflected rocker “Undertow” and the California skate-punk of “Black Regrets,” those three tracks get the album off to a promising start. Shiflett’s further demonstration of his versatile guitar chops and genre-shifting tendencies include the punk-ish and ska-inflected “Land Without Law,” one of the best tracks on Harmony And Dissidence and the respectable “The Day That No One Smiled,” which hints of The Edge-like soloing. It’s a song that could’ve been even better if its lyrics weren’t so vague.

Elsewhere, veteran rock keyboardist Rami Jaffee (Wallflowers, Pearl Jam, Foo Fighters) guests and shines with his hovering organ work and outro piano solo on “Stitches,” and Grohl adds some seriously slick grooves throughout half the record, including the multi-rhythmic, self-assured power pop of “White Flag Burning.”

With Jackson United, Chris Shiflett, in true punk rock spirit isn’t afraid to say what he wants to say, with or without violent themes and images (see “Trigger Happy” and the backbeat-propelled “Like A Bomb”) or foul language, as on “Land Without Law,” “Damn You” and others. And while Dave Grohl’s Foos may hold his guitar skills back a little, it’s clear from “21st Century” and elsewhere that he is technically the best guitarist in both bands (Foo Fighters and JU), though has a ways too to catch up to Grohl in the memorable songwriting department.

In this regard, Harmony is large on tightly structured and well-executed performances and definitely has more catchy material than its predecessor. If Western Ballads was a good introduction to the JU sound, this new record is even better, but not quite an instant classic. My review copy comes with two bonus tracks, but only one of them really catches one’s attention, the group’s short but excellent full band electric cover of the mid-‘80s Billy Bragg classic “Help Save The Youth of America.”

Vocally, Chris Shiflett doesn’t have that loud, brash punk rock voice that usually comes with expressing anger at society, government or someone in particular. And while his natural singing style works for several songs, it just doesn’t sound all that convincing on some tracks, including the revenge-themed “Damn You.” Maybe if he sang those types of tracks with the raspy style that stands out on his band’s Billy Bragg cover, songs like “Damn You” would be fully authentic.

So while Shiflett has some room to improve as a frontman, musically, nearly all of the fourteen songs on Harmony And Dissidence are first-rate rock tracks and should win over Foo Fighters, Face To Face and conventional punk rock fans alike without much hesitation. It’s a strong record, indeed. The more you listen to it, the better it gets.
Key tracks: “Like A Bomb,” “Land Without Law,” “21st Century Fight Song,” “Undertow”

For more info on Jackson United and to listen to some of its music, visit the band's Myspace page.

About Charlie Doherty

Senior Music Editor and Culture & Society (Sports) Editor at Blogcritics Magazine; Prior writing/freelancing ventures: copy editor/content writer for Penn Multimedia; Boston Examiner, EMSI, Demand Media, Brookline TAB, Suite 101 and; Media Nation independent newspaper staff writer, printed/published by the Boston Globe at 2004 DNC (Boston, MA); Featured in Guitar World May 2014. Keep up with me on

Check Also

The Muslims

Music Review: ‘Fuck These Fuckin’ Fascists’ The Muslims

Listen to 'Fuck These Fuckin' Fascists' by The Muslims and join the good fight while enjoying some great music and righteous anger.