Sunday , April 14 2024
How did five men come to be trapped 420 feet under Boston Harbor at the end of a 9.5 mile long tunnel with failing breathing equipment?

Book Review: ‘Trapped Under the Sea’ by Neil Swidey

The phrase “Imagine your worst nightmare” is just what the first word indicates, hypothetical. So try this one on for size. You’re near more than nine miles into a tunnel that dead ends for some reason. The only light is what you brought. There’s so little oxygen that without breathing equipment you’ll lose consciousness in seconds and die within minutes. Suddenly, that equipment fails. To make it even more harrowing, imagine that tunnel is some 400 feet under (yes, under) Boston Harbor. Yet the fact is that is exactly what happened to five men in July 1999.

Neil Swidey examines what led to the men being in that situation, the variety of people involved and the ramifications in the plainly told but engrossing Trapped Under the Sea: One Engineering Marvel, Five Men, and a Disaster Ten Miles Into the Darkness. In doing so, he looks at almost every aspect of the event, often through the eyes and thoughts of one of the trapped men, D.J. Gillis. And while some of the contributing factors are rather complex, the reporter for The Bowston Globe Magazine renders it all in coherent detail.

trappedThe background may be as outside the norm as the event itself. For decades, Boston Harbor had been the end point for human waste from Boston and nearly 50 other cities and towns. Half a billion gallons of sewer water and some 140,000 pounds of lightly treated sludge were being discharged into the Harbor daily. By the 1980s, the sludge had decayed and settled to the ocean floor, creating a disgusting mud known as “black mayonnaise.” A lawsuit led to a multi-billion dollar project was planned to try to clean up the harbor, including a massive sewage treatment plant on Deer Island that would be “the destination for every toilet flush in the eastern half of Massachusetts.” The project, overseen throughout by a federal judge, also included the world’s longest dead-end tunnel. Extending nearly 10 miles under Boston Harbor, it would carry treated sewer water away from Boston Harbor to discharge it deep into Massachusetts Bay.

Akin to another Boston megaproject, the Big Dig, the tunnel alone took twice as long as planned, almost a decade, and cost millions of additional dollars. One last step remained for the tunnel to be complete, removing 65-pound plugs that had been placed in each of 55 30-inch wide pipes leading from the side of the tunnel to risers that would actually discharge the water to protect the miners. Not only were the plugs in an area where the tunnel itself was only five feet high, they were to be removed only after taking out the extensive ventilation, electrical and transportation systems used by the miners. That meant the area also would not have enough oxygen to breathe. The solution? Use commercial deep sea divers, although they would not be able to wear the equipment they normally use.

A reader is struck not only by how jerry-rigged the solution was but how relatively harebrained it seemed. An untested breathing system was designed for the task by an engineer with a small Spokane, Wash., commercial diving firm, a system an investigator would later describe as “like an eighth-grade science project gone horribly wrong.” The system was placed in one of two Humvees connected back to back. Because the tunnel was too small for them to turn around, they neeed to be connected with each permanently facing the opposite. Hoses would run from the breathing system to allow the men to walk to the side tunnels and crawl into them to remove the plugs.

Swidey takes the interesting approach of placing the moment of disaster in the book’s prologue. From that point, he traces the stories of the men and companies involved, how the plug problem arose and this particular solution was chosen, and takes the reader inside the disaster and ensuing investigation and aftermath. Thus, Trapped Under the Sea tells not only the personal aspects of the story but the institutional ones, including how not wanting to take ownership of the problem or its solution seems to have led inexorably to disaster. He makes both interesting.

The book shows the payoff of Swidey’s hundreds of hours of interviews with those involved and years of study of the project. It allows us to understand both the men and the processes. It also provides some unique insight into the men involved. In fact, weeks after reading the book I am still struck by the incident that, despite all the horror, sticks in the mind of one of the survivors, one that involves a 2½ inch strip of skin.

Given how extraordinary the event was, many readers may wonder why they never seem to have heard of it. It seems to have been swallowed up by the “important” news dominating local and national media — the effort to recover the body of John F. Kennedy, Jr., after the plane he was piloting crashed in the Atlantic Ocean off Martha’s Vineyard. As Swidey observes in his extensive notes, six columns of the front page of the next day’s Boston Globe dealt with Kennedy. The story of death and nail-biting survival involving five men trapped 400 feet under Boston Harbor was relegated to an item in the local news section.

About Tim Gebhart

After 30 years of practicing law to provide shelter for his family, books and dogs. Tim Gebhart is now perfecting the art of doing little more than reading, writing and sleeping.

Check Also

Interview: Thu Vo, Author of ‘Daddy, Am I Beautiful?’

Author Thu Vo recently answered our questions about the new book 'Daddy, Am I Beautiful?', the first book in the Apple Tart book series, where young girl name Annabelle who is teased at school for expressing herself in a princess costume then discusses her emotions with her father. 'Daddy, Am I Beautiful?' is now available on as an eBook for Kindle, Kindle Fire, and Kindle App.