Today on Blogcritics
Home » Film » You All Everybody on Lost

You All Everybody on Lost

Please Share...Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

We're talking about last night's Lost episode today, so if you haven't seen it you probably don't want to read anymore because there'll be information given out here that will be spoiler-ish. While that ought to be obvious with my saying that we're talking about last night's Lost, perhaps, like the series itself, nothing is ever truly obvious.

One of my great sadnesses with the series is the ever-evolving cast. The cast changes may be necessary for whatever story the producers are telling, and there are whole bunch of characters that I don't mind not ever seeing again – Boone, Ana Lucia, Boone's sister whom I hated so much I've decided to never mention her name again – but then there are other characters that I greatly miss. Topping the list of this latter group is Charlie Pace.

Is it that Dominic Monaghan is a great actor? Well, I have really enjoyed him in the various movies and television shows in which I've seen him. I think he's one of the best parts (maybe the best part) of FlashForward.

I miss Charlie on Lost. As other characters appear, disappear, come back, move around, etc., I have tended to forget about them. Oh, they're in the back of my mind somewhere – when the show asks us to remember them I absolutely can recall what their story was, but I don't think about them and what they would do if they were on the show that week. Charlie, however, I do think about. Charlie I wonder about constantly. Even when I can barely remember Claire, I hear the way she says his name, and when we do see Claire I hope that she speaks of him again. Charlie had a great transformation story on the show, and Monaghan was able to be alternatively funny and serious as the role demanded. He was a drug addict one minute, a loving, would-be parent the next.

I miss Charlie regularly and hope against hope on a weekly basis that he'll be back. I know he won't, but I hope for it anyway. "Not Penny's boat," how great was that moment (the first time we saw it, I mean, not Desmond's flashing to it last night)? That might be the best moment the show has ever had, but it was Charlie's last (sort of, kind of, almost).

Speaking of that sort of, kind of, almost, I know what you're thinking – are we going to talk about the fact that in the alternate reality Widmore and Faraday's mom are married in the present? That George Minkowski is a limo driver for Widmore? No. No we're not. I'm not touching it, not touching it in any way, shape, manner, or form. Why? Because I would be completely guessing as to what the alternate reality is all about.

Last night the show implied that the alternate reality is the result of the nuclear bomb, that it's the "what would have happened if the bomb had woPhoto Credit:  ABC/Mario Perezrked" reality, and that back on the island is the "what would have happened if the bomb didn't work" reality. But I'm not sure if both are currently taking place, if one or the other is a hypothetical, or if neither is actually going on at this moment.

I'd like to think that both are happening – I really have no proof whatsoever that's the case, but I have a thought or two on it. What if Widmore needs Desmond because he's unstuck in time, because – as we saw after the experiment – Desmond has the ability to live in both realities? Really, he has the ability to exist in both universes in this theory, as it would seem to suggest that the realities split into two separate and distinct ones due to the nuclear blast. I don't know why Widmore wants or needs that, but it is what I think is currently going on. But, that's just one way the puzzle might fit together.

There are totally answers out there that I can't wait to get, but I don't feel as though I have enough pieces of the puzzle yet to answer all the questions. Seriously, do you? But, are you happy we kind of talked a little bit about it, didn't we?

Powered by

About Josh Lasser

Josh has deftly segued from a life of being pre-med to film school to television production to writing about the media in general. And by 'deftly' he means with agonizing second thoughts and the formation of an ulcer.
  • http://viclana.blogspot.com/ Victor Lana

    Great article, Josh.

    Karen, I think we’ll get something about the polar bears being used for experiments. We’ll have to see. The children went missing (in reality) because it would have been awfully hard to have kids as regulars on this series.

    Finally, I think we’re dealing with a parallel time scenario here, folks. Things are happening in two different ways. One is the wish fulfillment world (Desmond, you have everything you ever wanted thing); the other is a world (as Josh mentions) where the bomb didn’t go off.

    I think both worlds are valid. In the world where the bomb went off, flight 815 lands in LA and the giant statue is at the bottom of the ocean. Still, Jack bears an appendix scar and Desmond sees flashes of Penny.

    I think the worlds will ultimately crash into one another, and in the finale there will be resolution for some and doom for others. When the island is done with you, you just might be done.

  • http://blogcritics.org Eric Olsen

    very thoughtful Josh and Vic! I had about given up on the confusion of this season until inklings of explanation started showing up the last few weeks. I too see the two worlds coming together via “love”

  • http://adamarbour.com Adam Arbout

    I just finished the episode on Hulu and I have to say, it is starting to get very interesting. However, I have to say that I feel like I am coming up with more questions than answers.

    I do miss Charlie but when he came back into this episode I could not get the association from FlashForward out of my head. Same with Penny.

    But I am excited to see what will happen next. I think that these two realities are starting to converge. But where does this leave the island?

  • http://www.maskedmoviesnobs.com El Bicho

    Everybody? Not until Mr. Eko shows up. And it’s odd that you barely remember Claire when she is so tied into Charlie’s story and transformation.

    “Last night the show implied that the alternate reality is the result of the nuclear bomb”

    Didn’t we already know that from the beginning of the season with what Faraday talked about last season?

    You might as well guess away. The writers don’t appear to know what they are doing. Am I the only one who found it fascinating that in the flash-sideway world, Desmond had no access to the brakes in the car.

  • http://drdreadful.blogspot.com Dr Dreadful

    There are still literally hundreds of unanswered questions and loose ends, and I can’t see how, in the remaining – what? – eight episodes, the writers are going to be able to tie every last one of them up.

    I’ll be impressed if they even get close.

  • http://viclana.blogspot.com/ Victor Lana

    Just a few more thoughts. If Desmond is heading to Smokey’s camp, and if Desmond can bridge the two worlds, he may just be the one who can tell if Jacob or Smokey is evil.

    I have a feeling that Mr. Eko will show up. Since anyone who was dead can be alive, anything is possible.

    If we try to dissect things too much (and I am becoming guilty of this), we could end up missing all the fun.

  • http://drdreadful.blogspot.com Dr Dreadful

    I’m thinking of the note Faraday put in his notebook a couple of seasons back: “Desmond Hume is my constant”. Yes, somehow, Desmond is going to be the one to bridge or unify the two realities.

  • http://tvandfilmguy.blogspot.com Josh Lasser

    I’m with you Dreadful, and Stepehn think you also may be right about the possibility of Desmond combatting the smoke monster. Time will tell… and there’s not much time left.

  • http://upvcconservatory.net Dan M.

    Yeah I’m with you guys too Josh and Dreadful. Side note: I have to say I personally have grown fond of Dominic’s acting talents, but I’m tired of being told I look like him! He’s a talented actor, but not a pretty man. Ok, a little venting there, sorry. :)

  • http://misspedia.com Eddy K

    I haven`t seen this episode and I am so curious what happens with Charlie. After I will see the movie I will return and read the full article.
    Can`t wait to see the episode
    Eddy

  • http://irishstagenyc.blogspot.com/ Kate

    Hi Josh:

    Greetings from sunny Florida. Almost as warm as New York. Didn’t get to watch Lost in a timely manner but glad to see you did! I agree that Dominic M. is a great actor. When he is on screen, there is never the thought that he once had been a hobbit. An iconic one, at that. A lot of actors (Orlando Bloom) cannot get from underneath the LOTR. Cheers.

  • http://www.maskedmoviesnobs.com El Bicho

    I have a question for you people hawking goods with your name/url all over this site. How much are you getting paid? I am leaving comments for free but if I can make a buck or two doing what you people do, I am all for it