Home / Why Disparage the Monkees After Davy Jones’ Death?

Why Disparage the Monkees After Davy Jones’ Death?

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on TwitterShare on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on Tumblr0Share on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

The death of Monkees lead singer Davy Jones at 66 is another sad loss for those of us who love music. In recent years we have lost Whitney Houston, Michael Jackson, George Harrison, Amy Winehouse, and many others. I tend to look at all this starting with the death of Elvis Presley – all this referring to not only a loss of innocence but perhaps the loss of what defined our youthful days. Certainly the murder of John Lennon turned the page in a way that many of us never saw coming, and since then things have changed the world in ways (many of them not good) that Lennon could never have imagined (yes, I know).

Thinking back to the Monkees and their brief and soaring brush with fame, they were for many of us a poor cousin to the Beatles, but any relation to the Fab Four would be welcome in our homes. When the TV show came out in 1966, the Monkees were a fabricated band (perhaps truly the first boy band) that threw together Peter Tork, Mickey Dolenz, Mike Nesmith, and Davy Jones. The Beatles had started to leave the mop-top look behind, but the show was meant to capitalize on the band and the good natured fun of their films A Hard Day’s Night and Help.

The Pre-Fab Four (as the jokes were made back then) had to have a British lead singer, so enter Jones. The TV show was what could be called a zany, Marx Brothers type of musical comedy, with the four guys getting caught up with spies, assorted other bad guys, and pretty girls. The show shrewdly featured videos of their songs, beating all those lip-synching videos one would see on MTV by fourteen years. Songs like “Last Train to Clarksville,” “I’m a Believer,” and “Pleasant Valley Sunday” became great big hits, and to this day they always bring a smile to my face when I hear them on the radio.

For two years the show was on and then, like many fads, the thrill was gone and the show went off the air. For kids like me, it was gone way too soon as was Batman, Planet of the Apes, and Star Trek, but those shows helped define a generation and pave the way for new incarnations in the years to come.

The last few days I have heard so many people on TV and the radio disparaging the Monkees and their TV show. Surely, they have no legacy as do the Beatles, Rolling Stones, and the like, but The Monkees was a children’s show that was entertaining, and we kids pushed our parents to buy the lunch boxes, the singles, and other paraphernalia associated with the group. They may have been a joke to some but to us we were in on the joke, or at least we thought as much, and that was all that mattered.

Once the show was gone and the group disbanded, Davy Jones went on to have a decent career and the Monkees would eventually reunite and tour (minus Mike Nesmith). I know my sister and countless other girls still had Davy’s picture up on their bedroom walls next to ones of David Cassidy, Bobby Sherman, and Donny Osmond. And who could forget when Jones guest starred on The Brady Bunch, making Marcia (Maureen McCormick) and all the little girls around the country squeal in delight? Of course, The Brady Bunch was on the same time on Friday nights as my beloved Planet of the Apes, dooming it to cancellation after one season, but that’s another story.

Still and all the Monkees and their TV show hold a place in TV and musical history. Yes, they didn’t play the instruments on their recordings (session musicians did); they didn’t write their songs (but people like Neil Diamond and Carole King did), and their fame didn’t last long. They were prefabricated and no Beatles (not even Herman’s Hermits) to be sure, but they did have a memorable presence in our lives for a time and remain beloved by those who watched the show all those years ago, so I just wish people would stop knocking them and let their fans enjoy their memories.

Rest in peace, Davy Jones!  

Photo Credits – The Monkees/NY Times; Davy Jones – FOX News.com

Powered by

About Victor Lana

Victor Lana's stories, articles, and poems have been published in literary magazines and online. His books 'A Death in Prague' (2002), 'Move' (2003), 'The Savage Quiet September Sun: A Collection of 9/11 Stories' (2005), and 'Like a Passing Shadow' (2009) are available in print, online, and as e-books. His latest books 'If the Fates Allow: New York Christmas Stories,' 'Garden of Ghosts,' and 'Flashes in the Pan' are available exclusively on Amazon. He has won the National Arts Club Award for Poetry, but has concentrated on writing mostly fiction and non-fiction prose in recent years. He has worked as a faculty advisor to school literary magazines and enjoys the creative process as a writer, editor, and collaborator. He has been with 'Blogcritics Magazine' since July 2005 and has written well over 500 articles; previously co-head sports editor, he now is a Culture and Society editor. Having traveled extensively, Victor has visited six continents and intends to get to Antarctica someday where he figures a few ideas for new stories await him.
  • beachmom52

    The Monkees bring back a simple time in life. and I still catch a few of the reruns when i want to reflect back to childhood.

  • Only a fool would disparage a Monkee. That is what I think.

  • “they didn’t play the instruments on their recordings (session musicians did); they didn’t write their songs (but people like Neil Diamond and Carole King did), and their fame didn’t last long.”

    Their very first album has two songs written by Mike. He produced the sessions, which included Peter on guitar. They became more involved with creating the music as time went on, driving Don Kirschner out and becoming more involved in creating their music. Since Jones death was such big news, I’d question how long their fame lasted.

  • Stella Osborne

    The Monkees were part of my childhood. I used to listen to their singing, “We may be coming to your town.” But they never did….my town was too small. When they reunited, I was finally able to see them (many times). They always put on wonderful shows, and I, like all of the fans in the audience, were so happy to revisit their childhood memories. I will miss you, Davy Jones. I was fortunate to see The Monkees one last time in Richmond, Virginia in June.

  • walrus

    The Monkees wrote & played all the instruments on the Justus album.
    They also wrote some of their best songs such as Randy Scouse Git, Goin’ Down, Listen to the Band, Good Clean Fun and many more
    Anyway how many songs did Elvis write and how many instruments did he play? Did it matter, he was still the King.
    Even The Beatles didn’t write many of their earlier hits.
    Micky has one of the best pop voices of the era. Davy and Mike also had great distinctive voices. Peter also sings some great songs such as Shades of Grey and Auntie Grizelda.
    The fact that the untimely death of Davy is news 40 years after the band first broke up shows how popular they were, which is more than can be said about the miserable critics of the group.

  • Mike R

    While I agree with the title of the piece, even the article does just that. The band began as a fiction, grew into a reality and a track record that saw 56 episodes, 200 ‘live dates’, a movie, a tv special and 6 lps as a foursome (4 of them # 1 with sales that topped and rivaled their 60’s competition)- all in a 2 and a half year period is remarkable. And for once and for all- they did play instruments on 4 of the 6 lps, they did write some of their music and they did play live. Try and find any other example of that workload and that output before suggesting a negative. As John Lennon once said ” they have their own scene- you try doing what they’re doing and see if you could do half as good “. ‘Listen to the Band’.

  • trudy4

    At the height of their popularity, the Monkees actually outsold the Beatles in terms of singles at one point. Pre-Fab or not, the Monkees had a real fanbase. I do not get how anyone would be putting them down–that people still remember Davy Jones after all these years shows they did have a legacy and they had some really great classic 60’s songs like “I”m a believer”, “Daydream believer” and of course, “Last train to Clarksville”!
    RIP Davy Jones and to heck with all the haters! The Monkees were great!