Today on Blogcritics
Home » Culture and Society » Science and Technology » Weekly BlogScan: Potter and Anti-Potter

Weekly BlogScan: Potter and Anti-Potter

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

Midnight is the witching hour. But midnight on July 16th is the wizarding hour, when the next Harry Potter novel is officially released amidst magic and media fury. So is this a literary event? A celebrity circus? A serious landmark in the chronicles of 2005? For answer, I turned to the blogosphere, to see what’s the buzz on the boy wizard.

This is truly a world-wide phenomenon, folks. There are Harry Potter blogs in Spanish, German, and French, of course&#8212but bloggers also focus on the young wizard from Thailand and in Persian.

J.K. Rowling, the series’ author, is the world’s only billionaire author, and the second-richest woman in Britain (after the Queen), according to the Mirror online. The linked story looks at several other celebrities who’ve grown from the Potter phenomenon, Daniel Radcliff, Emma Watson and Rupert Grint; and it tracks the actors’ growth as the movie versions of Harry Potter novels progress.

Diana Sprinkles uses Harry and his friends as inspiration for her original art. Her images are sometimes reminiscent of animé, sometimes of old drawings in Edgar Rice Burroughs’ paperbacks. (You’ll know I have permission to use an image from her catalog if it appears in this post.) And dua also borrows creative power to breathe life into Rowling’s wand-vendor, Ollivander, with an original story at her Lumos blog.

Ron and Hermoine seem to be linked more and more strongly as the books progress, so it’s no surprise there is a blog devoted to them as a couple. These bloggers seem to have Emma confused with her movie role as Hermoine, and likewise with Rupert Grint and Ron. The Magical Three website concentrates on Emma and Rupert as well. A trademarked image shows Emma sporting braces, which leads one blogger to gasp, “Is Hermoine changing her looks?”

To read Hermoine Grainger‘s dairy, check out The Firebolt, a realistic (if rather breathless) journal with pictures gleaned mostly from the first movie. The blogger does a good job of reproducing the slightly-snotty tone of Hermoine’s approach to life.

Draco Malfoy” also keeps a blog (at a page called potterstinks, naturally), in which he muses about Malfoy Manor, his sisters and his future. For Harry Potter fans, there’s not much here, and for their parents, the site uses language J.K. Rowling wouldn’t allow to foul her pen&#8212although it seems natural enough from such a nasty wizard as Draco. Don’t miss the Comment threads, where Harry and Draco’s mother both put in an appearance.

Speaking of people who hate Potter, there is a world-wide anti-Potter mirror to Pottermania. One group names itself TOOPAP, The Organization of People Against Potter. The emotion here is so total, it appears to have overwhelmed the blogger, who can only say “This page is temporarily down due to how much Harry Potter sucks. Please check back in a few days and it will most likely be back up again.” In German, the Anti-Potter Clan hosts modified versions of the German book covers, one of which (Harry Potter und der Feuerkelch (Goblet of Fire)) shows Harry’s hair on fire.

There’s even an Anti-Potter Yahoo Group!

Some bloggers inveigh against all things Potter for religious reasons. Geocities blogger godluvsusoshea is a typical example:

But there are things people just don’t know about Harry Potter. Starting with magic and magic is wrong. So is sorcery and people who do sorcery. Wizards and Witches are bad too. They cast spells and think the power and magic they use is their own. Wrong. There is only two people who can give out power. God is one of them. And since God hates sorcery, he isn’t giving it out. The other person giving it out is the devil. Yes, he can do that too.

Despite all this anti-Potter activity, Los Angeles Times op-ed writer Joel Stein reaped the whirl-wind when he criticized Rowling’s readers as “stupid, stupid, stupid” and worried that “a culture that simplifies its entertainment down to fairy tales is doomed to simplify the world down to good and evil.” Blogger Orac responded in kind from Respectful Insolence, with “Joel Stein is a moron.” Orac takes issue with Stein’s opinion directly:

…the very statement shows the utter depths of his idiocy and vacuousness, particularly since he dismisses the first Harry Potter in essence only because it was intended as a children’s book and in spite of his recognition that it is “witty, imaginative, and fast-paced”!… There may be many reasons to disparage the Baby Boom generation (and they’ve probably all been used at one time or another), but the popularity of the Harry Potter books is not among them.

Safely back amongst Pottermaniacs, there’s a Myers-Briggs-based Harry Potter Personality Quiz at Pirate Monkey that’s fun to do. DrPat’s results:

Pirate Monkey's Harry Potter Personality Quiz

For LiveJournal bloggers, there’s a Meme Quiz that lets you define yourself as a witch or wizard in the Potterverse, and a rich source of character pictures for you to use, whether or not you pick Harry as your non de plume. That last link also will lead you to wallpaper and AIM icons with a Potter theme.

But what about Harry Potter himself? It seems no one wants He Who Must Not Be Named after them via the Internet&#8212despite tons of blogs about the young wizard, I found none purporting to be written by Harry Potter. Perhaps that’s okay&#8212something is sacred after all. Even if the Pope would not agree.

Powered by

About DrPat

  • http://paperfrigate.blogspot.com DrPat

    My spouse, alas, turns out to be “Sirus Black” in the Pirate Monkey’s quiz: ENTP.

  • http://gratefuldread.net Natalie Davis

    [POSSIBLE SPOILER ALERT: Stop reading here if you have yet to read HP and the Prisoner of Azkaban!]

    I love Sirius Black! His death was a terrible tragedy…

    Interesting twist on the Meyers-Briggs quiz; previous results have shown me to be a 50/50 split between INFP and INTP. This time the score showed INFP — Professor Lupin.

    Guess that explains my affinity for full moons.

  • http://victorplenty.blogspot.com Victor Plenty

    He died?!? NOOOOOOOO!!!!

  • http://gratefuldread.net Natalie Davis

    Oh, shit. I am so sorry. I should’ve put a spoiler alert before that sentence too. Please, please accept my apology.

  • http://victorplenty.blogspot.com Victor Plenty

    No worries on my account. I just thought it was funny how you put the big spoiler warning before the full moon quip, when you’d just blithely dropping a much bigger spoiler (IMHO) right at the opening of your comment.

  • http://paperfrigate.blogspot.com DrPat

    The funny thing was how many (how very many) blogs I uncovered pledging undying love for the greasy Professor Snape. I was a little taken aback when I discovered that I was he! [he he]

    I suppose it is holdover from the dangerous character Rickman played in Die Hard (or perhaps the lovable snot-satire of Spock he portrayed in Galaxy Quest).

    Or maybe they know something about his snake we haven’t heard…

  • http://victorplenty.blogspot.com Victor Plenty

    While the extra effort put into the spoiler warning on this thread is appreciated, it’s sort of a lost cause when people are blurting out huge spoilers everywhere else across the web, including every other topic on Blogcritics.

    I had hoped to avoid the major spoilers by staying out of the Half-Blood Prince threads. Sadly it turned out to be futile, since everybody’s so eager to talk about who’s been killed off, they do it right in the first sentence and it gets paraded down the right-hand margin of every page on the entire site.

    The big surprise in Order of the Phoenix got ruined for me because some clueless twit just had to put a dedication, “in loving memory of” the character who died in that one, into their email signature, of all things.

    Nowadays the only way to avoid major spoilers from a Harry Potter book is moving to a cave in Afghanistan until it becomes available in paperback. And I suspect even that wouldn’t be enough, as Osama bin Laden would take evil delight in telling you all about who died.

  • http://paperfrigate.blogspot.com DrPat

    “Moving to a cave in Afghanistan” to avoid HP6 spoilers is overkill, Victor. You could always just move to the Vatican!

  • http://victorplenty.blogspot.com Victor Plenty

    Not so sure about that, DrPat. I suspect the Pope secretly is a fan of Harry Potter, and allowed the “leaks” of his alleged disapproval to occur as a subtly brilliant bit of marketing and publicity.

  • http://paperfrigate.blogspot.com DrPat

    Fans hunting for Potter-forums should check here in the BlogScan – the pro-Potter blogs are linked to all kinds of Potter-focused sites.