TV Review: One Tree Hill Season Four Premiere

After last season ended with the possibility of not one, not two, but three deaths, fans of One Tree Hill have been on pins and needles wondering what happened. Would Nathan die, leaving Haley a widow at 17? Would Cooper and Rachel die as a result of her obsessive feelings for the older man? Would anyone live or were the writers trying to change up the show in a dramatic way?

The start to season four overlaps a few brief moments with the finale of season three. You relive the traumatic experience of the limo driving over the side of the bridge and Nathan diving in the river to save Rachel and Cooper. Haley is on the bridge, screaming in her wedding dress. Luckily Lucas and Karen aren’t far behind.

Peyton is unaware of these events because she is reliving, in her head, all the problems that have happened the last few years making Brooke no longer want to be friends with her. As if discovering she was adopted, meeting her birth mother months before she dies, and having her heart broken isn’t enough, Peyton apparently needs more drama in her life. I used to really enjoy Peyton until things became too soap opera-ish. She was the cool girl everyone liked but was still an individualist. She loved music and art and had a certain coolness to her. Now it is all “oh woe is Peyton” to the degree I no longer care what new devastating thing comes her way. It also leaves me neutral to the discovery that she has a brother from her biological father.

Someone has discovered Dan’s secret about killing Keith. He came home to find “MURDERER” painted in huge red letters on his wall. Keith’s ghost taunts Dan with idea that someone knows about this skeleton in his closet. The police show up, but much to Dan’s relief it is merely to inform him about Nathan’s accident.

I never know what to think about Dan though. He fluctuates between being the guy you love to hate and the villain you hate so much you cannot wait until he leaves the show. But since he killed his brother Keith, he has been meandering further down the spectrum of hoping something horrible happens to him, something so hideous you wouldn’t wish it on anyone but the worst of the worst and it is only ok to wish it on Dan because you know it isn’t real.

As is typical in dramatic shows, everyone shows up at the hospital to wait out fate for our three friends. Nathan is ok, but obviously doesn’t remember what happened. Rachel is ok and admits to Brooke that she lied to Cooper about being pregnant. But we also learn that Brooke isn’t pregnant, or at least that is what she wants Lucas to think. With the show being only an hour long, they had to answer a lot of questions in a short amount of time. It makes things a little less realistic, but that’s the nature of the beast.

Continued on the next page Page 1 — Page 2

Article tags

Spread the word
Bookmark and Share
Profile image for cara-de-pescado

Article Author: Cara de Pescado

In real life she's Erin McMaster, but Cara de Pescado is one of the fortunate ones to be considered a Masked Movie Snob. She puts her fins to work and writes Reviews From A Fishbowl.

Visit Cara de Pescado's author pageCara de Pescado's Blog

Read comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own

Article comments

— go to most recent comments
  • 1 - carissa

    Oct 09, 2006 at 12:16 pm

    i love oth

  • 2 - Lyn

    Oct 22, 2006 at 11:25 am

    his is gonna be an awsome season one tree hill rocks!!!

  • 3 - morgan

    Dec 31, 2006 at 6:13 pm

    i love one tree hill and this far it has been awsome i cant wait 4 the next show and i love lucas

  • 4 - Rachel C.

    Jan 08, 2007 at 5:13 pm

    I love one tree hill! James Lafferty is so hot, he is the best. Bethany Joy Galeotti is so awesome and so are Sophia Bush, Hilarie Burton, chad Michael Murray, and Danneel Harris. I love the show one tree hill and i would really like to meet the whole cast one day. I love your show.

  • 5 - sofia

    Jan 21, 2007 at 8:27 pm

    i love one tree hill. it is like the best show eva. i love every character and i hope the show never ends. i love everything that happends and i love how each week it just get even more jucia. i so want to meet the cast. i can just seat down the whole day and watch every episode because it is my fav show.

  • 6 - Sadee

    Jan 27, 2007 at 9:21 am

    oth is like the best serie ever made

  • 7 - lara

    Jan 28, 2007 at 8:32 am

    I love one tree hill- It is the best show ever! I live in the UK and its so great to have the show broadcast there, have all 3 series on DVD and cant wait for season 4- do you know when it will air in the UK?!! Im on the edge of my seat!!! Keep up the great work OTH. Lara xxx

  • 8 - TAITUHMM

    Feb 05, 2007 at 4:09 pm

    what song was sang by ray L?

  • 9 - Emily

    Feb 21, 2007 at 9:56 am

    Season 4 is reportedly coming to the uk early in May.

  • 10 - Shekima

    Mar 23, 2007 at 5:51 pm

    I love one tree hill!! Please keep the show and make. I need OTH to come back before may2. But if it come back may2, this will be my B-Day gift

  • 11 - Shekima

    Mar 23, 2007 at 5:54 pm

    I want to meet the cast of One Tree Hill so bad. I belive this is a good show because everyone can relate to one of the conflicts faced by the characters!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • 12 - jackielovesothandchad

    Mar 29, 2007 at 12:40 am

    ok so im a HUGE fan of oth its been a month since i seen an episode since "fake derek" came back punched peyton...it was supposed to air tonight march 28 but it didnt the pussy cat show aired again so does anyone know when oth is comming back cause i heard march 28 then may 2nd,but for episode 416 it says 2 weeks from tonight not 2 months AHHHHH!!!!!!!!! I<3chad!!

  • 13 - debbie

    Apr 02, 2007 at 8:19 am

    hey love ur show.m from uganda.thats in africa.we think o.t.h rocks....live on.

  • 14 - faye

    Apr 08, 2007 at 2:37 pm

    one tree hill premiered in the uk on E4, 5.00pm sunday 8th of april 2007. today! i only found it through skiping through sky channels, and only watched the last ten mins. it will be on every Sunday 5.00pm on E4. hope this was helpfull
    (ps it's repeated tonight on e4 1.20am)

  • 15 - shiqoe

    Apr 26, 2007 at 4:56 am

    I love chad and Sophia although I think Hillarie's life is just too full of drama I don't like her that much.For one she's ever crying.I love Lee too OTH is the best Tv can offer and I'm all the way in Africa in a country called Kenya and I love OTH

  • 16 - Jennifer

    May 10, 2007 at 8:10 pm

    I live in Michigan and I have watched ever episode of one tree hill all three seasons. I heard that it was coming to WB channel on May 2 and I thought it was going to be the fourth season but it wasnt it was the fifth. So could anyone tell me where I can buy the fourth season. I really need to watch it I am so confused watching the fifth season and not being able to see the fourth one...

  • 17 - natasha

    May 23, 2007 at 9:06 am

    if enyone knows want is going to happen in season 4 episode 19 please tell me xxthanksxx

  • 18 - natasha

    May 23, 2007 at 9:09 am

    jennifer the season that came on to mthe wc channel on may 2 was season 4 season five is no evrn one tv yet xx

  • 19 - Lucy

    Jun 10, 2007 at 10:16 am

    OMG i luv OTH have all seasons all awsum xXx

  • 20 - devane

    Jun 21, 2007 at 5:50 am

    i love this show it is amazin chad is hot but think pedon n lookus do not suit eachother i looove the show

  • 21 - devane n lois

    Jun 21, 2007 at 5:53 am

    we love the show n think chad n james are so hot all the cast are amazin and hope they keep makeing shows we love it xoxox

  • 22 - Shannon M.

    Jul 13, 2007 at 3:20 pm

    I personally thought Mark did a horrible job with the break up of Brooke and Lucas.He was there.He only went away for about a week.They made Brooke seem too needy.And Brooke isnt.Shes independant and while she dated Lucas in the second half of the third season she depended less on him...which was how theyre relationship grew stronger.

    The fantasy of Leyton was totally destroyed.And the way that Brooke just told Lucas to "Go ahead" was really unrealistic.

    The brucas/leyton triangle sucked.They gave no perspective.

    as for Naley...they did a wonderful job just like last season.

    Over all this season was by far the worst...sorry.I am in love with OTH but it over all sucked =/

  • 23 - rylea

    Sep 16, 2007 at 9:03 pm

    i am absolutely in love with oth. its my favorite show, and i could watch it every minute of every day. i love every episode..and season. i love all the cast, but my favorite oth actors are haley(bethany joy) and nathan(james lafferty).
    they do a great job. i cant wait till season 4!! when does it show on air and when does it come out on dvd? i heard that it was going to air sometime in october, and come out on dvd in january. but who knows. i am soo obsessed with oth. sometimes i get mad at my self for loving it soo much!!!! i cant wait till season 4!!!!! i hope on day ill get to meet the cast in north carolina!

  • 24 - RUBY

    Nov 05, 2007 at 4:17 pm

    I LOVEE ONE TREE HILL!!!!!!
    AND I LOVE SOPHIA BUSH!!!!<3<3<3

  • 25 - OTH is rad! = ]]

    Jan 12, 2008 at 12:06 am

    ahhhhh, !!

    OTH is one of my favourite shows i've loved it ever since the first time it came out on tv every friday night it was on at 7:30 but then the times got changed to 8:30 instead and then it got axed it just annoys me because it wasnt on long enough for ppl to watch it..

    not many ppl new about it nd then now that its off everybody loves it because they have seen it from friends or decided to grab it from the shops or movie store and watch it.

    chad michael murray is hot!!

    or other words lucas scott!!

    ahhh,

    i love one tree hill and im a HUGE fan,

    !!!


    brooke i love also

    but peyton has to be my fav!

    i could watch one tree hill all year if i had to because i love it so muchly and i relized also that oth has its own languages like they say im hurting..??

    isnt it ur hurting me..

    or it really hurts.

    ive been watching season 4 and 5 on youtube.. because its not out in australia yet..

Add your comment, speak your mind

Personal attacks are NOT allowed.
Please read our comment policy.
Please preview your comment.

blogcritics lists for Feb 09, 2010

fresh articles Most recent articles site-wide

fresh comments Most recent comments site-wide

most comments Most comments in 24hrs

top writers Most prolific Blogcritics for January

top commenters Most prolific Commenters in 24 hrs

Upcoming Stories from Blogcritics
  •