TV Review: Lie To Me - "Secret Santa" - Page 3

Part of: Lie To Me's Hot Spot!

Lightman spots the new player in the room and quickly deduces Komisky must be the handler who abandoned Franco in Afghanistan. Franco is actually Glen Welsh, recruited to special ops while serving time in the brig for manslaughter. Franco/Welsh gives up any hope for rescue and instead asks Lightman and Parks for his story to be told. Parks shows his loyalty to the chain of command as he replies, “It’s above my pay grade, pal.” Cal has a different system of loyalty, and he promises, “It’s right at my pay grade, if your story’s true.”

Franco’s trustworthiness is soon successfully put to the test as the marines use his directions to rescue the missing men. Unfortunately, while doing so, the marine hideout comes under attack. Adding to the misfortune, Emily walks in the room with the Lightman team just as a bomb severs communication to the marines and Cal. Not only is she horrified at what might have happened to her father, she has to accept he lied to her about his plans.

Lightman and his daughter, Emily  ©2009 Fox Broadcasting Co. CR: Isabella VosmikovaI liked the way Cal’s personal relationships were tied into the main theme, and Hayley McFarland is a delight as Emily. But I was a bit bothered by the logic of this story thread. If the situation is so top secret, never mind so possibly fatal, why would Emily have access to that room? I would think Foster would know to keep a sixteen year old out of that situation by locking the door. It certainly would have saved her from having to ask this teenager why she doesn’t break the news of Cal’s predicament to her mother, as if this is a reasonable thing to ask of her.

In Afghanistan, the stakes are now very high indeed and Cal cuts Franco open with a knife to see if his special ops story is true. Sure enough, the man has a transmitter implanted in his back. However, Franco’s own betrayal does not balance out his breach of loyalty to the military and Cal tells Franco he can either die by a bullet from Parks or he can fight the Taliban when they storm the cave and allow the rest of the men to escape. It’s the ultimate test of where Franco’s loyalty lies. He chooses his American special ops identity as his final identity and dies shooting his former Taliban comrades. Cal is thankful to have helped rescue the missing marines, but he’s honest enough to know he again played executioner, and though Franco was not exactly innocent, he was himself betrayed and put in a situation most people never face.

Continued on the next page Page 1Page 2 — Page 3 — Page 4

Article tags

Spread the word
Bookmark and Share
Profile image for gerry-weaver

Article Author: Gerry Weaver

Gerry loves film, books, a few television shows(True Blood and Supernatural come to mind), and writing about them.

Visit Gerry Weaver's author pageGerry Weaver's Blog

Read comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own
  • No image found
  • No image found
  • No image found

Article comments

  • 1 - Kristine from Kalifornia

    Nov 28, 2009 at 11:31 am

    Great review, I just have one nit to pick with it:

    The door was locked they even had the scene when Emily was following the group, they go in and you can see Foster reach the key pad and hear the beeps as she locks it and then Emily tried to open it. She gets in because another woman (not a regular) leaves the room and does not wait until the door closes before she walked off. That is how Emily gets into the lab.

    Sorry for rambling.

    Kristine from Kalifornia

  • 2 - Gerry

    Nov 28, 2009 at 12:48 pm

    Hi! Yes, you're right--I know Foster locked the door when they went in right in front of her. I was just surprised they didn't have more stringent measures on keeping the door locked, considering it was so top secret and Emily was in the building. It's a small point, though, in a very good episode.

Add your comment, speak your mind

Personal attacks are NOT allowed.
Please read our comment policy.
Please preview your comment.

blogcritics lists for May 19, 2013

fresh articles Most recent articles site-wide

fresh comments Most recent comments site-wide

most comments Most comments in 24hrs

top writers Most prolific Blogcritics for April

top commenters Most prolific Commenters in 24 hrs