TV Review: 3 LBS

Stanley Tucci plays a moody brain surgeon who sees the world as his enemy and the co-workers he deals with as chess pieces in a game they don't know he's playing on them. While that sort of character is done with House, Tucci's take on that kind of a character is given a more relaxed approach. The problem with 3 LBS is that what looks like a laid-back performance really comes off as utter boredom.

I would think prime-time television would be tired of cop shows, lawyer shows and medical dramas by now. Sure you can liven up the cast, bring in bigger stars and give shocking cliff-hangers at the end of the season, but the setting is still the same. Why not create a drama about caregivers and how they have to put up with the personal drama of someone they deal with on a limited basis? More people are dealing with that issue as their parents become much older.

But alas, this won't happen — and so, I return to the show.

Basically the show is set up of two minds — Dr. Doug Hanson (Tucci) loves the brain, but not the human carrying it, while Dr. Jonathan Seger (Mark Feuerstein) cares about both. Okay, cool. Now what? Well, they add a bit of Ron Howard's A Beautiful Mind with surrealist scenes of the brain activity of some of their patients (particularly in the debut episode where a girl develops weird seizures due to a tumor, which is somehow connected to the events of her dead sister who died at the operating table).

Once that's over, then it's time for drama with the co-workers.

Of course Hanson and Seger don't get along, completely due to their personal beliefs — that doesn't stop the latter from hitting on a possible ex-love of the former (Indira Varma). There's also a bit of tension between Griffin Dunne (who plays a rival brain surgeon) and Tucci's characters about who can perform the best surgery the best way.

Okay...what's next after that?

The problem I had with this series was the same problem I had with Smith — it's just there. Tucci is there, the plot is there, and the sexual tension is there. It's like a waitress handing you the plate with nothing else to offer besides the main course — which in 3 LBS's case doesn't seem enough to carry on past a season.

 

Article tags

Spread the word
Bookmark and Share
Profile image for matthew-milam

Article Author: Matthew Milam

Matthew Milam lives in Chicago, IL. Visit him at his personal blog at http://matthewmilam.com

Visit Matthew Milam's author pageMatthew Milam's Blog

Read comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own
  • The Impostors The Impostors

    Meet Authur (Stanley Tucci) and Maurice (Oliver Platt), two out-of-work actors who escape from the police by stowing away aboard a luxury liner. But soon the ship hits the fan, and the impostors must ...

  • ER - The Complete Sixth Season ER - The Complete Sixth Season
  • ER - The Complete First Six Seasons ER - The Complete First Six Seasons

Article comments

Add your comment, speak your mind

Personal attacks are NOT allowed.
Please read our comment policy.
Please preview your comment.

blogcritics lists for Nov 30, 2009

fresh articles Most recent articles site-wide

fresh comments Most recent comments site-wide

most comments Most comments in 24hrs

top writers Most prolific Blogcritics for October

top commenters Most prolific Commenters in 24 hrs