Also, the Hell's Angels were pretty heavy-handed, but they were not just completely going nuts. For starters, they came riding their motorcycles right through the crowd to park under the stage — but even with that kind of display, the Angels weren't carrying guns. Their tool of choice was the sawed-off pool cue. That's perhaps got a more intimidating idea behind it, but it's basically equivalent to a cop carrying a nightstick. Depending on training and use, that would not be an entirely unreasonable tool for major crowd control.Some of that thuggish Hell's Angels behavior earlier in the day during the Jefferson Airplane set might have been considered largely gratuitous. They seemed to be knocking people around to some extent just because they could. Even at that though, one could not entirely unreasonably judge it a public service to give a deserving dirty hippie a good beat down. (Sorry — I was channeling Cartman again there for a minute.) By the time the Stones hit the stage that night though, the Angels were pretty clearly in a combat survival mode. Looking at the footage, they seemed quite anxious simply to avoid some kind of serious massacre, which this many heavily doped-up people could easily have done even just accidentally. They've got an easily accessible three foot or so high stage. What would have stopped them?
Specifically though, the famous climactic killing of Meredith Hunter was absolutely clean as regards the Hell's Angels. There are witnesses claiming that Hunter pulled out a gun, and took a shot in the direction of the stage, supposedly grazing an Angel. I don't know about all of that, but here's the money shot of the whole film where you can unmistakably see Meredith Hunter with a gun in his hand.
So this fool kid absolutely pulled out a gun in the middle of hundreds of thousands of people, maybe 20 yards from the Stones on stage, and with a bunch of Hell's Angels standing there. Folks, Meredith Hunter committed suicide. Crazy sumbitch whips out a gun in a crowd like that, they're asking to be terminated with extreme prejudice. The Hell's Angels were simply obliging him.
Specifically, from the film, Hell's Angel Alan Passaro is seen bringing down the knife. He was stabbed repeatedly and stomped to death immediately. He was long dead when paramedics got there. Three years later in 1972, Passaro eventually faced a murder charge, but was acquitted by a jury. I'd figure they'd have to have acquitted just on the basis of the picture of Hunter with the gun in his hand alone, besides any other testimony.Naturally there was a great deal of controversy after the event regarding the role of the film crew. How much of this chaos came from them doing this whole event as a climax for their movie? The correct answer there seems to be NONE. Watching the whole movie of the tour up to and including the Altamont concert, there's no sign of anything being particularly staged for the camera crews. They had no special access to the Stones personally at any time in the tour, and no sign that I could see of getting any accommodation at all.
Article comments
— go to most recent comments1 - Sue
We were such idiots back then!
2 - Martin Lav
The end of an era this was not. Comparisons to this event and that of Woodstock are just not in the same realm. The Stones organized and arranged this debacle and the only thing that dwarfed their massive ego was the crowd itself. This crowd was highly dosed on alcohol along with the so-called security and this brought out their worst. Add in allegedly bad acid, which I believe the only difference between good acid and bad acid is where you're at (emotionally) when you take it, and you have a lethal violent mixture. Had it not been the Stones-esque brand of rebel rock, combined with boozed and drugged out Bikers, then this could have been an entirely different scene. However, considering the mood and elements, the fact that there wasn't a flat out riot with Hells Angels being stomped to death is truly the most remarkable thing that happened that day, besides the fact the Grateful Dead saying "we're outta here".
Seems like none of these elements were present either when Woodstock II broke out in a riot.
So, judging from the numbers it looks like the hippies are still the winners in this one.
3 - Charlie
Al, you need to see the movie again. You spun a whole lot of the details to arrange your version of an impotent Mick. Mick never threatened to stop playing. And not just details, some obvious things are misrepresented here too. Marty of The Airplane jumped into the fracas below the stage; the Angels did not "rush" the stage to beat him as you write.
All in all, it is plain that you've gone to great lengths to deride the Stones.
For anyone who wants the depth behind the tour, concert, and the movie, check out Stanley Booths incisive "True Adventures with the Rolling Stones".
4 - Al Barger
Charlie, I'm certainly not at pains to deride the Stones. They're great heroes to me, all in all - but this certainly was not their finest hour. Also, the Stones very clearly threatened to quit playing a time or two. You're just wrong there.
Now, I'm a little fuzzy on the Marty Balin incident. It could have been that he was beat up at the foot of the stage rather than on it, I'm not 100% clear. But hippie Balin surely was not trying to take a swing at a biker, so knocking him out with a pool cue seems pretty gratuitous.
You're certainly right that you could study some more sources to get a fuller idea of all that was going on there. It was major chaos from all directions. This story is specifically focused on what can be understood just from the Maysles video, which seems like the most direct and editorially neutral accounting of events - at least the ones that happened to go on where the cameras were.
5 - Aaron E.
Im currently reading this and using it as a one of many sources for a paper im doing on the event. The fact is no one can tell us for sure what happend here. Some things are of course obvious from footage...but some things well just have to wonder on. It was the saddest event in hippie history no doubt(John Lennon's death being up there though). No one can argue that any one group or person is responsible. This was just a BAD...BBBAADDD situation, and NO ONE wanted things to turn out the way they did. Personally, I really dig your views Al, great work..im going to quote you in my paper.=)
peace and love
~Aaron (a.k.a trippyhippie)
6 - jerry
you dont fuck with a mans motorcycle especially the hells angels are you crazy lucky things were not worse
7 - Eddy
Drugs and alcohol is to blame.
8 - Vicky
I was at Altamonte Music concert 1969.I was 18 years old and sober but most people were not. I saw a young woman pass out, and her boyfriend tried to carry her, then he pleaded for help. Another guy helped him carry her. I do not know what happened to her. I was too busy watching the people around me to notice the concert. I sat on a hill and the people on the stage looked small. I do recall seeing The Hell's Angels bouncing around and Mick kept saying over and over, "BE COOL PEOPLE." But no one was.
9 - Alain
Well, i,ve downloaded the show and it's quite obvious that the angels and the crow were on drugs and alcohol, take that ,plus the music and you get what happened that day , i also heard that the show was supposed to be in the afternoon but for i don't know what reason it was reported late in the evening and people who was waiting there for like 12 or 15 hrs , didn't help for what happened, and i can't blame the angels for killing this guy , he had a gun and could have killed 1 or more persons , ordinary people , Angels and the Stones too
10 - Mike Smolik
gee wiz it really could have been WAYYYYYYY worse. No doubt there was self defense with respect to Passaro pulling out his knife, but it's STILL Manslaughter, regardless. Sure, what could have possibly happened if that kid Meredith Hunter had pulled the trigger or even aimed at the stage...dear ggawd I'd hate to imagine. I feel bad he had to die, but what can U do. Who knows what ANY OF US would have done in the same situation. Im not judging anyone but I feel that despite that incident, it could have been horrific considering drugs, alcohol and thousands of people literally on top of ea other.
11 - Robert Larsen
I wasn't at the altamont concert,but,heard and read both sides of the account. First comment: Rock Promoter, Bill Graham, layed the blame on the Rolling Stones for intentionally making the crowd wait to hear them play in a very hostile and agitated situation. Second, if someone pulls out a gun, it is either you or them: you cannot wait for even a moment, otherwise you'll be the one SHOT DEAD. Third, whatever one's opinion abou the Hells Angels, they were there for SECURITY PURPOSES and just to have a good time with EVERYONE at that concert. It is easy to point the finger at the Hells Angels, considering their "BAD ASS" reputation, but I always find it interesting how the very same people obsolve themselves ,or others who are guilty as hell, of any wrongdoing-especially the Rolling Stones, who, in my opinion, should not of been allowed to play any more concerts after Altamont. WHAT THE HELL DID THE STONES,OR THE CROWD, EXPECT???
12 - Steve
One thing I want to know, what became of the girl he was with. I assume it was his girlfriend of some sort. The only thing I have been able to find is that her name is Patty Bredahoff, other than that...she is a mystery. It would be interesting to read an account of hers depicting the events that lead up to, and after the incident.
13 - Bob
It's amazing more lives weren't lost that night, considering all the circumstances. It was definitely a recipe for disaster.
14 - Susan
I was there, all of 13 yrs. old. I look back & it scares the heck out of me! There were fights breaking out all over the place. People were handing out acid like candy. There were way too many people crammed into a small area. The whole thing was so poorly planned. We left when the Stones started to play. It was too scary to stay!
15 - Andrew
It's all water under the bridge really. As for the effectiveness or no of Mick Jagger it's not really the point. Jagger never set himself up as an "authority" figure - and he wasn't gonna be able to control a mass of people that large. Besides most of the people actually attending the "concert" would not have accepted any kind of authority. Jagger did say he expected things to be cool as it was the West coast !!! Keith did warn that "either these cats cool it or we don't play" ... but the band played on ... and how!
The film sums up the chaos of the sixties and, dare I say it, the utter stupidity of young people thinking they can change the world with music... !
This is a very good read ... good to get this kind of a perspective after all the intervening years.
16 - Super Amanda
Excellent article on Altamont but ultimately no one is to blame, it was uncharted waters for everyone, except for Bill Graham who made such an intelligent assessment..
I'm surprised that The Stones listened to The grateful Dead for advice (to many hardcore Bay Area hippies the latter took the blame) but seeing as all of them were about 21 to 27 years old it's not too inconceivable that my friends and I, had we been famous back then, would have made the same tragic mistakes.
Alan Passaro who killed Meredith Hunter was found dead in a reservoir in rural Nor cal in 1985 with about 10Kin his pocket. Hunter is buried in an unmarked grave in Vallejo, California.
May they both rest in peace.
17 - George Fotis
I've read on other sites that the Angels weren't pleased Hunter was with a blonde girl & were giving him a hard time. I really can believe this ! Hunter had to be stopped somehow but did he have to be stabbed ? Then chased by a pack of them like wolves . Couldn't he have been tackled and wrestled to the ground. It's about time more footage of this concert was released , two Stones songs isn't enough.
18 - Al Barger
Mr Fotis- I had not heard such a thing, but I could well imagine these redneck bikers not digging on Hunter being there with a white girl. Still, Hunter brought a big ol' gun in with him, and clearly whipped it out in the middle of this crowd. Even if you assume for the sake of argument that the Angels were harassing him some, they didn't have guns and there's no indication that anyone had attacked him.
He does not appear to have been at any point "chased." Once he drew the gun, Passaro stabbed him, he went down and looks to have been stomped to death within a few seconds. This is unfortunate, but once he whipped out a gun it was on Hunter himself.
Somebody whips out a gun in a crowd and starts waving it around, they're enthusiastically volunteering to be killed. At that point, you really can't fault folks for obliging him - even if they're scuzzy biker types.
19 - Alexander of Hollywood
Excellent essay on a fascinating subject. I'm a Stones fan from way back, and I enjoyed the article a lot. Tanx for posting, Al.
I make and sell Altamont T-shirts -- only with the word Altamont written in the Woodstock logo. And the familiar Woodstock peace-bird has a knife stuck in its back. You can see them at my site.
If you tell me your shirt size, I'll be happy to send you some FREE ones in gratitude for your entertaining and informative writing.
But the main reason I'm writing to you is that I'm interested in advertising my shirts on your site. But I couldn't find any way to contact you except this here Comments box. So please contact me and maybe we can do some biznis...
Best regards,
Alexander of Hollywood
20 - Heather Anne Peel
Whatever else, this was the darkest and most intense moment in Rock's history. The Rolling Stones, with new guitarist Mick Taylor, were at the peak of their powers. The greatest Rock and Roll ever was made on their '69 tour. The '72 tour was close, but nowhere near as intense, by design.
21 - Leonardo L. Santos
This whole thing was a mess from the start. Everybody knows that LSD mixed with booze and other drugs makes people do crazy things. I've seen the film of the show lots of times and you can see people acting really strange from the beginning. This show would have to be scheduled for during day time for obvious reasons, what kind of security can you provide for people in this situation during the night? Not much. LSD is a drug that stays in your system and too much of it fucks up your brain...what seemed like magic turned into bad trips and madness/agressiveness. The hippy scene died because of the drugs...in my modest opinoin thats the only reason why it died out. This concert was the end of it...the drugs idn't have the effect it was having in the start, no one was prepared to deal with it
22 - Jim
I was there. It was out of control. I was one of the cops and there were very few cops there. People parked on the freeway, walking as far as 2-3 miles and bringing their kids.
23 - Harold Adler
At one point the Hells Angels were throwing people off the stage like pieces of meat. The good news was that the stage was so low to the ground they did not have far to fall. The problem was that Altamont rock festival was planned to be in Golden Gate Park and the city officials pulled the permits at the last minute so the concert was put together in a few DAYS instead of a few WEEKS. I can't blame the "Angels" for doing what they did. They probably saved Mick Jaggers Life. Harold Adler
24 - Olga
I was there also, all of sweet 16. By the time the Stones played, the huge mass of drugged out young people started pushing forward, there was no place to move. It was dusk and bonfires lit up around the hills like a scene out of hell when they began Sympathy for the Devil. Mick Jagger even said weird things happen when they play that song. Well DUH! Don Mclean was right when he wrote in Bye Bye Miss American Pie, "I saw Satan laughing with delight the day the music died". Most of us were churched kids back then, not realizing we were switching worship songs from Jesus to Lucifer and yes there was a blood sacrifice. After that California life got darker and people got more perverse, deeper into drugs, abuse and despair. Hunters blood flowed during the song, "Under my Thumb" and if you believe in Satan, that's exactly where he's had California's youth after that day when so many of us stopped believing in God.
25 - Pat Howes
I was there, 16 years old, armed with a pentax spotmatic and my brother's old press ID (from a community college paper). I walked right thru the backstage area so I could get right in front of the stage. We were standing there packed in shoulder to shoulder and then at the urging of someone on stage we all sat down, literally in each others laps. During Airplane's set a fat naked guy started dancing around about 20 feet from the stage. Unfortunately he was dancing on top of people so three bikers waded thru the crowd to subdue him with pool cues. Marty Balin yelled at them to stop the violence and when they didn't, he threw his tamborine at them. The biker who was hit by the tamborine turned, walked to the stage and decked Balin. One punch as I recall. The beer was in a school bus that always had at least 2 guys on top guarding it. I also remember bikers policing the lines for the portapotties, making guys go in 2 at a time to keep the lines moving. I left before dark so I could find my ride and the other people I came with.