Racism and Diplomatic Disputes: The Reality of Reality TV

So now we all know what should have been abundantly clear from the start. Jade Goody really is as ugly on the inside as she is on the outside.

Goody was the winner of the first British Big Brother series in 2000. After being accused of racist bullying of an Indian housemate during the newest series, in which she returned to the reality show, Goody faces a public backlash and her "career" is in jeopardy. Public-relations guru Max Clifford summed it up neatly: "Ironically, the programme that made her could be the programme that breaks her."

"I'm not racist, but I can see why it has had the impact it's had," Goody said in her weak defense. "I look like one of those people I don't like." Actually, Jade, funny you should say that, because you look like one of those people I don't like either. It literally hurts to look at you. Please save your crocodile tears.

Quite apart from the utter ridiculousness of marketing a perfume named after her — Goody is not exactly the symbol of haute coiture, is she? — and her own workout video, which was a total cheat, the larger question that deserves to be asked is why did she become a celebrity in the first place?

To paraphrase Oscar Wilde, it must be that reality TV — Big Brother in particular — is the curse of the moronic class. Then again, to a population who live on fried chicken, McDonald's, and kebabs every night after drinking twenty pints, and think sentences shuld b speld like ths, a television program in which a bunch of nobodies with nothing profound to contribute to society and with nothing useful to say was bound to be a hit.

Hardly a surprise that the partly state-funded Channel 4, on which Big Brother airs and which appeals to young people with a permanent expression of "duh" on their eczema-encrusted faces, would assert that there was no racism in the latest series of BB, despite a record 21,000 complaints and the testimony of the bullied contestant Shilpa Shetty. Indeed, Channel 4 has been perfectly happy to cash in on the whole ugly spectacle.

Shetty is a Bollywood actress and is popular in her native India. Three white female contestants — Jade Goody, Danielle Lloyd and Jo O'Meara — have called Shetty names, including the inaccurate slur "Paki," mocked her accent and, in Lloyds' case, refused to eat a chicken that Shetty fixed for dinner because she "didn't know where her fingers had been."

Continued on the next page Page 1 — Page 2

Article tags

Spread the word
Bookmark and Share
Profile image for mark-edward-manning

Article Author: Mark Edward Manning

Mark Edward Manning grew up in Boston, MA and now lives in London, England. He wrote commentaries for The Boston Herald in the mid 1990s.

Visit Mark Edward Manning's author pageMark Edward Manning's Blog

Read comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own
  • No image found
  • No image found
  • No image found

Article comments

  • 1 - Literaltruth

    Jan 22, 2007 at 1:41 pm

    This article is littered with factual inaccuracies.

    Firstly, Jade Goody was in the third season Big Brother, not the first. Even in that series she didn't win (she came 4th). At the time she was pretty much universally disliked by the public.

    Although a public broadcaster, Channel 4 is funded entirely by its commercial activities and has never been state funded (partly or otherwise).

    In the show, Shilpa Shetty wondered aloud briefly if there might be a racial motivation to the bullying she was enduring. However, the next day - and in the only statement she has given on the subject that could be regarded as a "testimony" - she categorically denied that she seriously thought that there was racist sentiment behind Jade's behaviour. She was also adamant that this statement should be presented to the public as her definitive view on the issue. Before Jade left, she and Shilpa had made up and she stated numerous times that in her view Jade was not a racist.

    In the interest of balance, though, it should be noted that Shilpa's views may be influenced by the fact that many of the racist comments were made when she was out of the room. However she was fully aware of the extent of Jade’s non-PC comments (which consist solely of referring to her as “Shilpa Popadom” when she couldn’t think of her surname). Most of what could be considered racist was not uttered by Jade - but rather Jo (who was the one who made the comment that Indians were all thin because they got sick from eating with their hands) and Danielle (who was the one who said that Shilpa should "Fuck off back home").

    Additionally, it was Jack, Jade's boyfriend who is also in the house, not any of the three females that you mention that was claimed to have called Jade a "Paki". However, this claim seems to have been purely wild internet speculation and entirely based on the fact that his comment was bleeped while other swear-words were not. Channel 4 have stated that what he actually called her was "a cunt", and this would be consistent since this word is routinely bleeped on the show.

    The fact that Danielle refused to eat the chicken that you mention was not because "she didn't know where Shilpa's fingers had been" as you state, but rather that the chicken was undercooked and bloody when carved. The entire house refused to eat the chicken for fear of food poisoning (as it turned out, Shilpa had cooked the whole roast chicken with the oven set to "grill", meaning that the bottom was left uncooked).

    Other more minor points are: Jade Goody's perfume was not named after her - it was called "Shh..."; the effigies that were shown being burned in India were Big Brother producers (not contestants); categorising Jade as a primate is hardly an insult since all humans are primates.

    Finally, I would question where you came up with you characterisation of the viewership of Big Brother. Is it based on anything other than your own supposition? I myself have been an avid viewer since the first season - feeling it is a great bit of soap at worst and a fascinating social experiment (whether the producers know it or not) at best. In exposing the subtle nature that racism can take I would argue that this current series has perhaps been the most successful at that aspect. I myself am university educated, over 25 and an English teacher to boot (and I most certainly don't think that sentences should be “splt lke ths”, although I do think that you need to use considerably fewer commas). Remember that this year will mark the 8th year of BB and a lot of fans have watched since the start, these fans are quite likely to be in their 20s or above and I believe that BB has quite a broad spectrum of age groups and backgrounds for viewers. Remember that such a significant number of viewers were savvy and literate enough to complain to the broadcast regulator when they perceived racism in the house.

    Also, quite why you seem to be using facial eczema as a impingement on the character of those who watch I can't imagine.

  • 2 - winter

    Jan 23, 2007 at 9:14 am

    I enjoyed reading this article and the above comment. Though, I don't know if that is just how British people write, but, Literaltruth, run-on sentences are not corrent grammar either. You'd need more commas. Perhaps more full-stops would be better though.

  • 3 - Paul

    Jan 23, 2007 at 10:36 am

    Dear Literal Truth

    Thank you for your comments, good response to a heavily loaded and typically tabloid article.

  • 4 - Cat

    Apr 27, 2007 at 2:26 am

    You're aware of course that Ms. Goody is of West Indian descent? You must also be aware since journalists are naturally omniscient that in the British Colonial hierarchy West Indians were not regarded very favourably. Why? Because many of their ancestors were taken there by the bountiful British as slaves. Sick, huh?

Add your comment, speak your mind

Personal attacks are NOT allowed.
Please read our comment policy.
Please preview your comment.