Movie Review: The Proposal

Whenever I have a meeting to attend, I carry with me a little card called “B.S. Bingo.” On it is a grid of empty, meaningless, overused phrases in business-speak. I've found it very handy in getting through many a seminar in which speakers blather on about “thinking outside the box,” “paradigm shifts,” “synergy,” and “at the end of the day.”

With that in mind, I am now going to carry with me the Rom-Com Bingo™ card. On it, I will scatter about a number of tired tropes on which the genre relies so heavily. It would have made suffering through The Proposal much easier. (And yes, all of these below are contained in said film.)

The successful business woman as shrew: In The Proposal, Sandra Bullock plays Margaret Tate, a successful editor for a Boston publishing company. How do we know she's a success? She treats everyone beneath her like dirt and is often mocked for having no social skills whatsoever.

The sassy senior: Apparently, there is nothing more amusing than to see an elderly person talk dirty. Here, Betty White playing a sex-centric grandmother does the honors.

Ornery family pets: Whether it's cats going potty or dogs humping legs, the furry family members are often tossed into the mix to generate a guffaw or two. A little yippy powder-puff pooch is in danger of becoming eagle food here. The only time this musty gimmick has worked is the Irish setter in Funny Farm which takes off and never comes back.

You can take the girl (boy) out of the city...: Oh, the hilarity that ensues when introducing uptight city folk to good, old-fashioned, country-livin' stereotypes. And while Ryan Reynolds' character, Andrew Paxton, comes from deep in the heart of Alaska, it's a shock The Proposal does not bring Margaret out on a moose hunt.

Opposites attract: One's the pent-up aggressor, the other the more laid back, rational sort, but wouldn't you know it, they can find common ground... at least in about 8,237 romantic movies, including this one, they can. Bullock's Tate is tense enough to bounce quarters off of, whereas Reynolds' Paxton is loved by all, is sensible, and is guilty only of loving too much.

Continued on the next page Page 1 — Page 2
Spread the word
Bookmark and Share
Profile image for rob-rector

Article Author: Rob Rector

Rob actually gets paid to see film, and has for the past 15 years. He is very appreciative that he has the coolest job on the planet. He also teaches film in college and started an independent film festival in his hometown.

Visit Rob Rector's author pageRob Rector's Blog

Read comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own
  • Made of Honor Made of Honor

    Tom loves his life. Until he realizes he also loves his best friend hannah. But when hannah gets engaged to a dashing scotsman & asks him to be her maid of honor tom faces hostile bridesmaids bridal ...

  • New In Town (Widescreen Edition) New In Town (Widescreen Edition)
  • Two Weeks Notice (Widescreen Edition) (Snap Case) Two Weeks Notice (Widescreen Edition) (Snap Case)
  • 27 Dresses (Widescreen Edition) 27 Dresses (Widescreen Edition)

Article comments

Add your comment, speak your mind

Personal attacks are NOT allowed.
Please read our comment policy.
Please preview your comment.

blogcritics lists for Nov 07, 2009

fresh articles Most recent articles site-wide

fresh comments Most recent comments site-wide

most comments Most comments in 24hrs

top writers Most prolific Blogcritics for October

top commenters Most prolific Commenters in 24 hrs