Throughout the film, I couldn’t help but recall Spider-Man 2 and United 93, two infinitely better cinematic experiences. Comparing Superman to Spider-Man, Superman can’t match up as an interesting character; while Superman takes me-time in space and tends to look at humanity with a glint that could be condescending, Spider-Man makes tremendous personal sacrifices in order to put his abilities to good use. United 93 tells the true story of the doomed 9/11 flight where ordinary plane passengers fought their hijackers, likely saving a lot of lives in the process. One film is fantastical, the other factual, but mention the word hero to me, and I’d think of either of those films long before I would Superman Returns. Does the world need Superman? My answer is a resounding ‘no’.
Article comments
1 - Triniman
I pretty much agree with your views here. United 93 is one of the best films that I've seen this year. Superman Returns will be a huge commercial hit, but it just pales in comparison. And Kate Bosworth's Lois Lane has the appeal of soggy kleenex.
2 - James Frazier
Thanks for the feedback! I agree about Kate Bosworth; what the hell were they thinking? She had no spark, no zest or appeal at all. The handling of virtually every character in this film is a total misfire.