Bizarre. Fascinating. Flawed. Out of control. Definitely not ordinary. I can use all those expressions to show what I feel about Holy Smoke, but they are not enough to express all my mixed feelings about it. This is not an easy film to watch and even more difficult to review, but I can say that its qualities overcome the majority of its flaws.

At the centre of Holy Smoke is Ruth, a young Australian woman who travels to India and there starts to take part in a cult, getting fascinated with it. Her family contracts PJ Waters to make Ruth forget her new beliefs and return to a normal life. They will spend some very unusual days in a hut on the desert, during which time we don't know who is in charge.

Jane Campion writes and directs this weird and tense story with a wonderful passion. She tries to escape from all the clichés and succeeds in doing so. There are some other stories of Ruth's weird family: her gay brother, her nymphomaniac sister-in-law, her ingenuous mother. This is the humorous part of the film, where you'll see even a sheep serving as a table at Ruth's house. But, strangely, Holy Smoke didn't feel as a dramatic comedy. It's one of those pictures that you can't define the genre with clarity.

All the qualities and flaws of Holy Smoke come from the directing and the writing. There are some slow moments, exaggerated situations, some out of places scenes that could have been easily deleted. These are the main reasons why I didn't enjoy Jane Campion's earlier works: the overrated The Piano and the tasteless The Portrait of a Lady. But here the flaws sometimes can be forgotten because Campion explains the story better than in her other works and succeeds in captivating the audience, discussing subjects as sex and religion with the right tone.

The actor who really shines here is Kate Winslet. Harvey Keitel is great as always, but Ms. Winslet gives us an Oscar-caliber performance. She doesn't have problem in appearing naked, singing, dressing Keitel in a red dress and saying what she thinks. I'm sure that her performance won't disappear in smoke, at least for me.

Holy Smoke was very criticized and very snubbed, but it deserves a second chance. I agree it is obviously not for everyone. But watch it with patience, pay attention at the subliminal messages, have some fun and think a little. It is worth the price of the ticket.

Article Author: Casey Lunkley

Casey is a blogger from New York, NY who's interested in a wide array from subjects, from music, movies, politics, the Supreme Court, and more.

Visit Casey Lunkley's author page — Casey Lunkley's Blog