In Baby Mama, Fey plays Kate, a successful executive who has never had time for relationships and a family. Now staring at 40 from a not-so-safe distance, Kate wants a baby, but is told by her doctor that she can’t conceive. Left with no other alternative, she decides to hire a surrogate to carry her baby, but she probably didn’t expect white trash Angie (Amy Poehler) to be the solution to her problems… or are her problems just beginning?
Of course, nothing goes smoothly with the pregnancy, and there are a few winning moments that surface, almost exclusively because of Poehler’s do-anything-for-a-laugh moxie, but that same approach can also backfire, and in Baby Mama, without much support to bolster the relatively low amount of good comedy, it often does.
There are a few too many diversions, too – common when a sketch writer tackles the length of a feature film the first few times – like Kate’s weird, earthy boss (Steve Martin) and her rushed-in love interest (Greg Kinnear).
Perhaps most curious, though, is a lack of chemistry across the board. Comedies, even mediocre ones like this, can seem much better if the cast is simply on the same wavelength, but that doesn’t happen in Baby Mama. In fact, the best scenes are probably the handful of exchanges between Poehler and her deadbeat husband (Dax Shepard), which tells you how easy this movie is to hijack.
Even still, Baby Mama struggles to approach double digits in laughs, and that’s not nearly enough to get over the hump. Or the baby bump, in this case.
Baby Mama
Starring Tina Fey and Amy Poehler
Directed by Michael McCullers
Rated PG-13
Article comments
1 - Brad Schader
Tina Fey only stars in it, she did not write it. If she did, it would have been funny =D
2 - El Bicho
There's a great website called IMDB.com that's free to use when writing about film that will help you avoid embarrassingly inaccurate attributions in the future.
3 - Michael Clayton
It does sadden me to hear Fey's recent effort is severely under par; I have been a fan of her and Poehler for quite some time, and outside of Andy Samberg and Bill Hader, have been the only figures from SNL in recent years to draw any of my attention. Hopefully this is just a minor roadblock.
4 - NoLifeKing
I didn't like the ending AT ALL! I was hoping the 2 females got together in a real relationship and that the baby one had did turn out to be both of theirs. That blew the whole movie for me. 2/5