I soon learned that many of the best fanfiction authors were writers who, like me, also wrote original fiction; or were aspiring screenwriters or novelists; even a journalist or two. A couple of these authors eventually landed real gigs on television shows like Millennium (a spin-off of X-Files). Stories were shared on Usenet groups (remember those?) like alt.television.x-files.creative, then archived on speciality sites with creative names like “Muldertorure Anonymous” and on the mega-X-Files fanfiction site called “The Gossamer Project.”By the time I became disenchanted with X-Files (after season six), I had written at least 35 stories. My last X-Files fanfiction story was written in 1999, quite sure that I had been cured of the fanfiction bug. Then came along House, MD. Damn.
Complex, flawed, intelligent characters, unexplored subtext, intriguingly unspoken sexuality, snappy dialogue all dangled themselves in front of me like catnip (if I had been a cat). Resisting for months, I found that I couldn’t help myself. Starting out as a reader, I soon was drawn to delve into the characters (especially House) myself, penning my first story sometime toward the end of season one.
House fanfiction writers range in age from pre-teen to grandmother; they are often highly educated, mostly female (but not exclusively), and many are in demanding careers, including professors, journalists, domestic engineers, librarians, editors, lawyers, and even doctors. In other words, there is no “type” who picks up a pen (virtual pen, anyway) and spends hours writing fiction that they can never hope to publish for profit. (The characters do not belong to them, but to David Shore and his company). Readers are equally diverse, since writers tend to be readers as well.
More mature readers often tend to look for true-to-the series characterization. The relationships explored and the tone of the piece is often less important than the writing itself.
Fanfiction writer Tidewell explains: “(As a reader,) I like House stories that have a certain uniqueness about them." If the characters don’t ring true, however, that’s a huge turnoff for a lot of readers. Blacktop, another writer, likes to read “a bracing story with strong dialogue between House and Cuddy (tingling with the eroticism that is definitely canon between them) with a delicious side of Wilson.” Jair likes "introspective pieces that explore House's internal landscape — his demons and his hopes. “But if I can't picture the characters behaving the way they do in the story, I'm not interested,” she says. “I'm very picky and don't read a lot, because not a lot of stories meet my criteria.”
Article comments
1 - Susanne
Brilliant as always Barbara!
I have thought about everything that you have said in your reviews and went back to my english literature teachings in University and I have come to realise that I agree with you and I am enjoying this season but I hope to see more reflective and angst moments.
Wonderful.
2 - Barbara Barnett
Thanks Susanne,
Like you, I'm hoping for more reflective moments to come.
3 - Tall Writer
Outstanding article. I'm a big House fan and can't get enough of it. Thanks for the references near the end. Hugh Laurie is amazing.
4 - Barbara Barnett
Thanks, Tall Writer. I completely agree that Hugh Laurie is indeed amazing.
barbara
5 - sgr11
Great article!! It encompassed so much!! And so many of the reasons why we love House and fanfiction, our motivations for writing it and our reasons for reading it! Well done!
6 - Orange450
I loved your article! I'd never heard of fanfiction before I became addicted to House. After reading a few stories on the Fox forum, I was impressed by the dedication of the very prolific authors there. But it wasn't until seeing "Need to Know" three times that I felt compelled to write one of my own (and I'd never written any multi-chapter fiction before)! So I wanted to add a reason to your list, above.
One very important reason to write fanfiction is to ensure that the storyline goes the way you want it to :) Since the House production staff had decided that Stacy had to leave, I took matters into my own hands last year, and wrote my own version of a series finale in which House and Stacy end up together (my action takes place some years out, allowing for a few more seasons). Now I can rest easy, knowing that whatever may happen in canon - I've provided myself with the ending that I want to see!
7 - Jet in Columbus
It's nice to see fan fiction put in a good light. We're not actually plagarizing as much as trying to bring closure to a story that for whatever reason wasn't closed. In my case I wrote a fanfiction closing to Brokeback Mountain giving my version on how Ennis DelMar went on after Jack's death. Now that Heath has gone, it was the only way to feel closure to a story that touched me so deeply.
I also expanded Annie's original very short story in the New Yorker, and the loose ends left by the movie by fleshing out the characters and their motives and inner thoughts before presenting my own end to the story at Ennis' death in 2006. Including his daugher's wedding, Ennis is accused of Jack's murder, etc.
Any and all interested are welcome to click here
8 - Barbara Barnett
Thanks, all (except, I think OMGSTFU). Jet, you're right that we're not really plagiarizing so much as lovingly borrowing the objects our affection. My favorite type of fanfiction to write (and read, I suppose) is the sort that explores the deeper thoughts and motivations of my character(s). I love to get into their heads and allow them to express emotions they might not otherwise be able to express.
barbara
9 - hl_lover
Did a troll leave you a comment, Barbara? Glad to see whatever trash he/she had to say was removed.
Thanks for this look into the psyche of what makes fanfiction writers tick. It's important, I think, for people to realize that it's a broad crosscut through the fandom who writes...not just starstruck teenagers, and that the writing can be phenomenally good, exceeding the quality of some of the novels thrown out yearly by published 'popular' authors who routinely make the bestseller lists.
Good job! :)
10 - Barbara Barnett
Thanks HL_L. I agree that some fanfiction is better written than a lot of published work. It's surprising (or maybe not so much) that many House fanfiction writers are mature adults, and their writing shows it.
11 - Alice Jester
Thanks for trying to tackle this complex fan phenomenon. You made many great points about the time and commitment it takes to create these stories, and why we love our characters. I like how you got comments from actual writers, and I loved you sharing your tales of writing in the X-Files days.
I do have a constructive nitpick, for this article did have a slant. As someone who has been very active in the House fanfic community for a few years, it’s a splintered fandom. Your examples used quotes from writers that like to explore primarily House/Wilson or House/Cuddy. There is also a huge contingent out there that long for well written stories featuring the secondary characters of Chase, Cameron, and Foreman. Many of those stories aren’t ship oriented either, but are gen fics that raise genuine issues these characters must face. Those stories are in pretty high demand (I know from experience).
A huge part of the fandom loves these characters, and feels slighted by the way the show has discarded them this season. The media also seems to have slighted these characters, even though they were singing their praises for three seasons. New stories also are emerging all the time about the new team as well, and they weren’t mentioned at all here. Also, I noticed the member counts that you used were on livejournal, which are communities geared toward shippers (the Chase/Cameron site BTW has 531 members). Another accurate count is story searches by character on ff.net.
Anyway, nitpicks aside, I did like the article. Thanks again for writing it, and add IT Professional to the career list!
12 - Barbara Barnett
Hi Alice. Thanks for your insightful comments. You are quite correct that there are several camps of House fanfic fans and writers--and not all of them "ship." I've even written a couple of "general" fanfiction stories (although I'm a confessed Cuddy/House shipper). I used the Live Journal stats as examples. And I would not want to diminish the other parts of the fandom at all.
I will add IT pro to that ever-growing list of professional folk who write fanfic.