Brokeback Mountain tells the tale of two men in love. While some people are still put off by the concept, the only shocking aspect in the film is how universal the story is, no different than any other love forbidden by society whether interracial, interfaith or familial rivals.
The story begins in 1963 when Ennis Del Mar and Jack Twist meet while herding sheep in Wyoming. Unfortunately, they fall in love at a time and place that literally could cost them their lives. Jack is willing to risk it. He has ideas of them getting a ranch together, but Ennis refuses because as a young child he was shown the body of a man killed for being gay. Instead, they assume their expected societal roles by getting married and starting families. However, they continue to see each other over the years, going on secluded camp-outs, away from prying eyes. Each reunion becomes tougher; they happen with less frequency and the men fight due to their frustration of not being able to be together.
Brokeback Mountain excels on many levels. It’s a beautiful, heartbreaking love story filled with realistic characters. Heath Ledger as Ennis delivers a stellar performance. He rarely speaks, but is able to convey the character’s thoughts and emotion. Jake Gyllenhaal as Jack does a good job, but I didn’t find his character completely authentic for the early ‘60s. He seemed too modern, and more city than rural, but that may have come from his travels on the rodeo circuit. Michelle Williams and Anne Hathaway play their respective wives. The range of their performances illustrates what talented actresses they both are.
The story presents an intriguing contrast between the main characters. Jack is comfortable with his identity, which must stem form his involvement in other homosexual relationships, while this is the first and only relationship in which Ennis has had feelings for a man. I most appreciated seeing Ennis and Jack no different from straight men. Instead of the stereotypical homosexual caricatures that saturate the media of men lilting, lisping, and flitting about, they drive trucks, ride bulls, and fish. They act no different from “regular” Western cowboys because they aren't.
Article comments
1 - handyguy
Too bad there's still no commentary. Maybe they are saving that for the third DVD version, which we'll all feel we have to buy also. Shades of The Lord of the Rings' multiple DVD releases.
I highly recommend seeing the film in HD on HBO if you can. It looks magnificent - far superior to the first DVD, not that the disc is badly done. Not sure if they have further enhanced the picture for this new release.
2 - El Bicho
I don't know, handy. So far, Sense and Sensibility is the only film he has provided a commentary track. It might not be his thing.
3 - daryl d
Seems like a poorly written "fanboy" review. Let us know what kind of lube you were using while watching this movie.
4 - Samuel Cole
I really want them to release the collectors edition in region 2. Anyone know when that will be?