Today on Blogcritics
Home » TV » TV Review: The Walking Dead – “Cherokee Rose”

TV Review: The Walking Dead – “Cherokee Rose”

Please Share...Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

AMC’s The Walking Dead finds the group trying to settle into Hershel’s (Scott Wilson, CSI) farm, though Hershel tells Rick (Andrew Lincoln) they are only welcome temporarily, and should not get too comfortable. This isn’t hard, when a zombie is discovered in one of the farm’s wells and contaminates the water. Glenn (Steven Yeun) may be more receptive than most to staying anyway, since he has a sexual encounter with Maggie (Lauren Cohan, Chuck, The Vampire Diaries) that he won’t soon forget, though she says that they won’t be repeating it. But while the survivors (at least temporarily) have a base, they begin looking more thoroughly for still-missing Sophia (Madison Lintz).

How did the zombie get into Hershel’s well? There are no zombies to be seen on the farm, and the residents seem pretty secure, not even worrying about leaving visible lights on at night. This indicates there may be more security present that is immediately apparent. It also is enough to wonder if perhaps someone put the zombie into the well purposely. After all, there are a number of wells on the farm, and the central group is sent specifically to that one. Of course, if the zombie is placed there purposely, not much is done to hide it, so it’s really kind of a situation that doesn’t make much sense when examined too closely.

Even more confusing is Dale (Jeffrey DeMunn) and T-Dog’s (IronE Singleton) plan to get the zombie out of the well alive, so as not to contaminate the water. Since zombies are, essentially, rotting corpses, surely the water is already unfit to drink. Whether it will infect anyone with the zombie virus or not doesn’t matter. There are pieces of flesh coming off, and pus and other liquids dripping into the water supply. Zombies are not clean and hygienic. The entire exercise of removing the zombie is pointless.

Continuing on the weirdness of this scene, Glenn should not be used as bait, nor should a canned ham, for that matter. The survivors know that zombies don’t go for dead things, and surely saving an entire ham when supplies are scarce and not easy to replenish trumps what they are doing. And they are on a farm, so there has to be an animal around that would make better bait than Glenn. Plus, after the rope breaks and Glenn is struggling, it is predictable that when he is pulled up, he has already accomplished the task. Yet, despite the assumption and confirmation that this is what happens, it doesn’t appear realistic in the moment, given what is shown of Glenn’s panicked struggles.

But enough about the one bad scene in an otherwise great episode. Even The Walking Dead is allowed an occasional mistake.

Hershel becomes a bit more mysterious and less friendly in “Cherokee Rose.” While previously offering hospitality, he now wants everyone to move on as soon as they are able. Rick asks him to reconsider, and Hershel agrees, but doesn’t seem too eager to relent, also mentioning that there are things that he will not discuss. Readers of the comic books know something is lurking in Hershel’s barn, which is mentioned, but not in a suspicious way, in “Cherokee Rose.” What might the screen version of Hershel be hiding, and why can’t he share that with Rick?

Despite Hershel’s insistence, Rick looks to be staying. He puts his badge away in a dresser drawer in Hershel’s house, and promises to follow Hershel’s rules, even avoiding questioning their host, as he should. This points to Rick’s willingness to do whatever needs to be done so that they can stay in this comparitively secure location.

One thing that could get the main gang kicked off of the farm is if the truth ever comes out about how Shane (Jon Bernthal) kills Otis (Pruitt Taylor Vince, The Mentalist, Deadwood). Shane gets up and spins a hero’s story about the death of Otis at his wake, but viewers know that Shane murders Otis so that he can escape with the medical equipment needed to heal Carl (Chandler Riggs). Shane’s actions may make sense from a completely intellectual standpoint, but that will not endear him to Otis’s friends in any way.

Shane is having quite a rough time dealing with his actions, and he should be. As he tells Andrea (Laurie Holden), sometimes decisions must be made in a split second, and emotion cannot factor in. The brain shuts down, and instincts rule. This is obviously what Shane believes happens when he shoots Otis, which makes sense, as Shane is not a bad guy, and he shows no sign of leaving Otis prior to that moment. He does what he must do because he values Carl over Otis. In that regard, it’s a simple, justifiable decision.

About JeromeWetzelTV

Jerome writes TV reviews for BlogCritics.org and Seat42F.com, as well as fiction. He is a frequent guest on two podcasts, Let's Talk TV with Barbara Barnett and The Good, the Bad, & the Geeky. All of his work can be found on his website, jeromewetzel.com
  • http://trinimansblog.blogspot.com/ Triniman

    Despite its flaws, I like this show. I like Homeland even better. These serialized shows tend to be more interesting to me. They need to know when to end instead of wearing out their welcome, like 24 and Lost did.