Today on Blogcritics
Home » TV Review: Shark Week Special: Mythbusters

TV Review: Shark Week Special: Mythbusters

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

Mythbusters, for those not in the know, is a show on Discovery Channel with two stars, Adam Savage and Jamie Hyneman, who are Hollywood special effects gurus based in San Francisco. They take their experience (over 30 years worth combined) and use it to test and prove or disprove popular myths. Originally, the series only focused on these two men, but the crew has grown and changed over the years and currently has a second team composed of Kari Byron, Salvatore Belleci, and Grant Imahara.

This year, for the Discovery Channel's ever popular Shark Week, Mythbusters is airing a special episode.  In it, the Mythbusters team travels to the Bahamas to test whether sharks are affected by magnets, attracted to thrashing swimmers, swimming dogs and flashlights at night, repelled by spicy peppers, if hitting a shark in the eye will stop them from chewing on you, as well as working out how hard is it to even aim for an eye while in the jaws of a Great White Shark.

I know that this show is very popular on the Discovery Channel, but I have tried many times to get into it and have failed every time. The subject matter and science is something that appeals to me greatly so I have always been puzzled at why the show does not grip me. Watching this episode, I finally realized why. The dialogue, jokes, and interplay between the cast feels scripted and forced, like watching high school amateur theater. Most of the jokes and silly voices are unfunny and detract from the show. Too much time is spent with “filler” where one of the cast members repeats what they are doing or what they just did for the viewer in case the viewer fell asleep during the last few moments.

Having said that, I love the actual science that happens on the show and each member has a talent for what they do. They are all obviously excited by their jobs and the best parts of the show are when they are putting the myths to the test. While the show glosses over possible problems with some of the experiments, such as the validity of testing shark responses in an area where the sharks are conditioned to be attracted to boats due to the chumming that goes on, there is absolutely nothing wrong in the way they conduct the experiments themselves. They use a control and they test several times to see if they get the same results.

Final verdict: If you like the show, you will love this special episode. If you do not like the show but, like me, look forward to Shark Week every year, you will still like this episode. It premieres Sunday, July 27, 2008.

Powered by

About Russ Evenhuis

I'm a writer with a mid-life crisis. I'm into sports of all kind, a Seattle fan to my bones. A retired rugby player, now I punish myself with triathlons when I'm not hanging out with the family, drinking Guinness and playing PlayStation.
  • jim foley

    jim foley-australia w.a….
    RE:shark attacks dog,well guys im a professional fisherman and you had it spot on except for one crucial element you attracted the WRONG SHARK species,if you have either had Bull shark or Great white and of course the Tiger shark any one of them would have turned that little puppy into shark poop guaranteed!!big call i no. I also only have a left arm my right arm was caught up in my mums ambilical cord at just above the elbow and looks real different let me tell you (another myth for later)any way I’m that confident that those perticular sharks would attack that robot dog that i would bet my good arm on it so i would love for you to prove me wrong which is not gonna happen sorry guys ha ha…and if you wanna take a look at my cool but very weird arm and hand i would love to chat to you about it. im sure you could incorporate it into your show some how you are clever blokes aren’t yas.. [Personal contact info deleted] think about it hay guys it could be one of your best programs hands down ha ha get it i crack me up,see ya or talk soon jimmy.
    P.S i gota be your aussie no 1 fan to i might add.. love the stuff that goes BOOM….smell yas later…