Tuesday night's American Idol show was all about the number three: three contestants and three songs performed by each. The first song was the Judge's Choice, the second was the Contestant's Choice, and the third was the Producers' Choice. Getting the show started was David Archuleta:
David Archuleta – "And So It Goes"
Paula chose Billy Joel's "And So It Goes" for David A's first performance. I wasn't blown away, to be honest. While there was nothing wrong with David's performance, and in fact, he sang it quite well, somehow it was still a little boring and a little lackluster for me. Randy said, "Check it out, baby! You're in it to win it!" Paula said, "It was a pure and stunning performance." Simon said, "It was very good. No surprises, but predictable."
Syesha Mercado – "If I Ain't Got You"
Randy chose Alicia Keys' "If I Ain't Go You" for Syesha's first performance. Her vocal was strong, and she seemed to have fun with the song. My only complaint is, having heard the original of this song so many times, Syesha's performance wasn't as powerful as it might have been with a lesser-known song. Randy said, "You did an amazing job." Paula said, "It's difficult to do a song that's so identifiable with the original artist." Simon said, "It was good."
David Cook – "The First Time I Ever Saw Your Face"
Simon chose Roberta Flack's "The First Time I Ever Saw Your Face" for David C's first performance. I thought it was an odd choice, honestly, and David C didn't appear to be in the comfort zone. That being said, his vocals were strong. Randy said, "Love the high note at the end." Paula said, "That is one of my favorite songs and you are my second favorite person to sing it." Simon said, "I think this is one of your strongest performances to date."
Next we moved on to…Contestant's Choice:
David Archuleta – "With You"
I wondered what David A was thinking when he chose Chris Brown's "With You." Maybe that he wanted to show another side – a younger side? Unfortunately, I wasn't overly impressed. I think it's great he tried something different, though. Randy said, "I'm not sure it was the right song." Paula said, "I think you did a great job." Simon said, "I applaud that you didn't do a ballad, which I thought you would. It just wasn't you."
Syesha Mercado – "Fever"
Syesha's choice of Peggy Lee's "Fever" made sense to me, and while I really enjoyed her performance, it wasn't quite right – at least for American Idol. The great thing was her vocals were pretty much perfect! Randy said, "You sang it amazingly well." Paula said, "I'm surprised you picked this song. I'm not sure it shows me Syesha." Simon said, "I think you will probably regret that performance tomorrow."
David Cook – "Dare You To Move"
David C's performance of Switchfoot's "Dare You To Move" was a decent performance. I didn't really like the arrangement, and it wasn't his best vocal by far, but it was still entertaining. Randy said, "Perfect song choice. I love that band. A little pitchy." Paula said, "I wanted more." Simon said, "I thought all three of you had an okay middle round. It was what I expected – not a very melodic song."
Next we moved on to…Producers' Choice:
David Archuleta – "Longer"
I thought the producers' choice of Dan Fogelberg's "Longer" resulted in David A's best performance in the night. Yes, it was another ballad, but he sang it well, and was very much in his comfort zone. Randy said, "It was another hot one from you." Paula said, "Very lovely. I expect nothing more." Simon said, "I thought you sang it well. However, I thought the song and lyrics were horrible."
Syesha Mercado – "Hit Me Up"
The producers' choice for Syesha of Gia Farrell's "Hit Me Up" seemed a little odd to me. Granted, the front end of the performance was lively and fun, but it deteriorated toward the end. Randy said, "It was just okay for me." Paula said, "I don't know if it's going to be good enough to get you into the finals." Simon said, "It was better than the second song. I don't think anything this week has topped your performance last week."
David Cook – "I Don't Want To Miss A Thing"
Ah! The producers' choice of Aerosmith's "I Don't Want To Miss A Thing" for David C was a great one! I think this was the top performance of the night. I loved it, even though the beginning was a little on the rough side. Randy said, "It was okay for me." Paula said, "David – see you in the finals!" Simon said, "David Cook wins the night."!"
So, that wraps up the top three show. Next week is the finale! I'm fairly sure we're going to see a David vs. David showdown – what do you think? My ranking follows:
Here's my personal ranking for the week:
1. David Cook
2. David Archuleta
3. Syesha Mercado