Home / TV Review: American Idol 6 – Bee Gees Week

TV Review: American Idol 6 – Bee Gees Week

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on TwitterShare on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on Tumblr0Share on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

With four more contestants left in the competition, the clock is ticking down until we crown our next! American! Idol!

(cue theme music)

First of all, apologies for not putting out posts last week. I had a lot of things on my plate. But I'm back this week, here to provide you all with my brilliant reviews. Okay, maybe they're not so brilliant. But they're at least somewhat witty at times.

This week was Bee Gees Week, and Barry Gibb was the group's mentor. I had no idea that Barry's speaking voice sounds like Sean Connery's. Since he usually sings with a falsetto, I've always been curious as to what he really sounds like. Not surprisingly, Barry will be performing tonight – most likely promoting some new album or tour. Since there are only four singers left, each person got to perform twice. Hey, the producers have got to fill up that hour somehow, right?

Let's get started.

Most of the contestants crashed and burned during the first half of the show, some more than others. Let's take a look.

Performance I


I like Blake. I really do. I think it's great that he often puts a spin on a song, making it his own. However, sometimes he overdoes it. Blake took "You Should Be Dancing" and beatboxed the living hell out of it. I thought he murdered Bon Jovi's "You Give Love a Bad Name" last week, and he did it again with this song. I wish that Blake would quit picking classic songs and drastically altering them beyond recognition. None of the judges liked it. Paula said that he was off pitch, while Simon said that it was horrible.


How odd for LaKisha to take what's arguably the ultimate disco song and R & B-ify it. I applaud her for taking a risk, but this was a bit much. Indeed, contrary to what he normally says, Randy didn't like that she made it her own. Paula thought that taking the tempo down brought the audience's mood down.


Yes, even Melinda doesn't get a good grade this time. Vocally it was stellar as usual, but I thought that the performance was meh, and the song didn't really work for her. The judges pretty much said the same thing — great vocals, but weren't really wowed.


Out of the four first performances, only Jordin's really stood out. She sang "To Love Somebody," which I thought was excellent. The girl is on her way to the finale. All three judges said it had the best vocals and was the best performance so far.

Performance II

Thankfully, most of the contestants upped their game during the second half of the show. However, two were still relatively weak.


Blake sang some obscure Bee Gees song called "This is Where I Came In." Even Barry was surprised that he picked this song and admitted that it was never a hit. You know things are bad when someone doesn't like his own song. Although it was better than the first performance, it still wasn't good enough. Randy said what I'm sure most people in the audience were thinking: Blake, you don't have to beatbox every song. I forsee Blake leaving tonight.

Like Blake, LaKisha's second song was an improvement, but not a big one. She sang "Run to Me" and the first half actually wasn't bad. However, it got screechy midway through, and in fact she pretty much croaked out the last note. Yowch. Simon said that he feels she and Blake are the most vulnerable contestants this week, and I agree with him.


Thank goodness that Melinda's second song was infinitely better than the first. She sang "How Do You Mend a Broken Heart."  It was great, especially the second half of the song. In fact, Simon said that the second half may have put her in the finale. No, it's the fact that she's been consistently excellent during the whole competition that will put her in the finale.


Jordin received a very high compliment from Barry when he heard her rehearse "Woman in Love." He said that he's heard about a hundred versions of the song (including Barbra Streisand's) but that Jordin's was the best ever. Wow. I thought she sounded great, but the judges weren't as impressed. Randy said it was pitchy and Paula said it wasn't her best. Simon said she sounded old-fashioned and the performance was "pageanty," right down to the ultra formal dress.

My thoughts:

I'm pretty damn sure that Blake is leaving tonight. He's had a good run and is definitely one of the most unique Idol contestants ever, but the beatboxing got old really fast. Even Randy got fed up with it.

Who should be leaving: Blake

Who will be leaving: Blake

Powered by

About Toni Schwartz

  • Judge Judi

    Kaonashi –
    Thanks for the review – we missed you last week! I agree with most of your review, and although I am a HUGE Jordin fan, I loved her first song, but hated her second song. I think she even looked kinda scared when she was singing it, like maybe she wouldn’t be able to hit the high notes and stay on key. I didn’t like her dress either – looked too matronly. At any rate, I’m still guessing she’ll win the title of A.I., and I would be very glad for that.

    I’m definitely ready for Blake to go, although I kinda liked last week’s song. It worked for me, but this week’s songs? YUCK

    But I’m a little nervous that maybe Blake has more of a fan base than LaKisha?? But one of them will most likely go.

    As an overall season, this year just doesn’t compare to any of the other seasons. Maybe I’m getting burned out on one of my favorite shows??!!

    Go Jordin!!

  • Randy is amazingly inconsistent. Blake probably has gone as far as he can go, but think about this: Randy has said several times that Blake should do more of the beatboxing the judges first fell in love with. So Blake finally did last week, and the judges — including Randy — fell all over themselves in praise. I agreed, for that matter.

    And now, suddenly, an about-face. To say that the songs didn’t work is one thing, but to say “you don’t need to do the beatbox thing all the time” is incredibly inconsistent. Do it! Do it! Do it! Ah, you shouldn’t have done it. Wha—?

    When Blake doesn’t beatbox, we realize that his vocals are outclassed by the other competitors still in the competition. Only by beatboxing does he have a chance. And a slim one at that.

  • Judge Judi- Aww, thanks! I actually liked Jordin’s second song as well, but I do agree with Simon in that it was rather old-fashioned. I’m surprised he didn’t criticize her for singing “Woman in Love” when she’s just a kid and most likely hasn’t been in love yet. Simon usually doesn’t like it when a teen sings about subject matter that’s beyond their comprehension. As for Blake, I do think that he’s got a bigger fan base than LaKisha, but I wonder if it’s big enough to save him. Besides, the Vote for the Worst people are backing her up now, so their support just might give her that little edge she needs.

    Phillip- Randy has always been inconsistent. For example, one week he’s complaining about song choice, the next week he says it has nothing to do with the song. Even Ryan has called him on this. This is why Randy drives me nuts and sucks as a judge. But this time, I think it was a case of Randy growing tired of Blake’s beat boxing since he actually has a point.

  • Grandpa Idol

    Blake will be hanging around at least one more week and LaKisha will be out. I believe it will be Jordin and Melinda in the finals and although I don’t care which of those two win I would like to see Jordin take it as the youngest winner to date. I do agree with your Blake assessment in that he over beat boxed his selections but do think last week’s Bon Jovi selection was a big hit.

  • I thought Blake did really well with Bon Jovi’s song last week. And I loved what he did with ‘This Is Where I Came In’ this week. So what if Barry Gibb said it wasn’t a hit? Not all hit songs become hits from the original singers, and Blake definitely did a better version of it than the original.

    I honestly don’t know why people think Lakisha is any good. Sure, she’s got a big voice, and it seems a lot of people equate big voices with good singers, but I keep saying, big voices doesn’t automatically equal good singers. Lakisha has a big voice, that’s all she has. With some training, she could be really great, but now, she’s the weakest in this group.

    Melinda and Jordin are my favourites. In terms of skill, Melinda wins hands down, but you never know how the votes are going to go. Jordin has the most potential, she’s so young, and with some more years of experience, she could get waaaayyy better than Melinda.

  • Grandpa – I also think that Jordin will win this year. Melinda is a fantastic singer, but to be honest she doesn’t appeal to the young audience that American Idol wants.

    Betty – My boyfriend and I must be the only ones who cringed at Blake’s performance of “You Give Love a Bad Name” last week. It wasn’t bad per se, but that song is a classic and I don’t think he should mess too much with the classics. You are right in that big voices don’t equal good singers, which is why Melinda is better than LaKisha. Her control is so much better. She knows when to reel that voice in and keep it steady, but she also knows when to just let it all out. LaKisha even admitted that she’s had no formal vocal training outside of singing in church. She just knows to sing big.

  • sean Paul Mahoney

    First off, welcome back Kaonashi! I missed your funny AI blog and yes it is brilliant. Unlike last nights show. The Bee Gees have a wealth of amazing material and each contestant picked very safe material. Where was “If I can’t Have you”, “You stepped into my life”,or even “Heartbreaker”(which they penned for Dionne Warwick)? I thought Jordin, Blake, and Lakisha all picked the wrong songs. Sorry.
    Blake is nice eye candy and is radio friendly but the best? Hardly.
    I’ve also tired of Lakisha not moving or having any energy. Yeah she can sing but she’s BORING. It’s like watching a dinosaur impersonate Whitney Houston or every other Idol.
    So that leaves Jordin and Melinda. Jordin is the whole package even when she makes mistakes. Melinda is amazing but would I buy her album? Not so much.
    Judge Judi- I loved the cameo last night by your namesake! Very funny.

  • Grandpa Idol

    Told you so.

  • Sean Paul- Thanks! Yes, most of the songs they picked were relatively safe, though I think that “Stayin’ Alive” could have been more daring if LaKisha pushed herself.

    Grandpa – Yep, you called it. I think most people thought LaKisha was going home, but Blake was just so bad last night that I figured an upset might occur.

  • Grandpa Idol

    I agree that Blake overstepped his beat boxing bounds this week and therefore will probably refrain from excesses in the future. At this point it’s all about fan base because all three could be stars. I think Blake will go next week unless he really knocks it out of the park and one of the others totally flop. Unless that happens, Melinda and Jordin will be in the finals.