Today on Blogcritics
Home » Tom Brady: Greatest Playoff QB Ever?

Tom Brady: Greatest Playoff QB Ever?

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

As I watched Tom Brady and the Patriots overcome an 11-point deficit in less than seven minutes, I couldn’t help but wonder if Brady could be the best postseason quarterback in history.

Statistically, not so. He is far behind Brett Favre, Dan Marino, and Joe Montana in passing yards and touchdowns. But stats haven’t made Brady famous. Rather, he’s earned his reputation with his knack for getting the job done when his team needs it most.

Just look at the 2002 Super Bowl. Starting on the 17-yard line with 1:21 left on the clock, Brady dissected the Rams defense and drove them 51 yards down field, close enough for Adam Vinatieri to kick a game winner. Final score: New England 20, St. Louis 17.

The 2004 Super Bowl was deja vu for Brady and the New England Patriots. With the game tied at 29 and only 68 seconds to go, Brady completed four of five passes for 47 yards and set up Vinatieri for another game winning field goal to beat a heavily favored Panthers team. The Patriots won the Super Bowl the next year too, and Brady joined an elite group of quarterbacks who have won three Super Bowls.

Tom Brady has a record of 12-1 in postseason games, and has never lost a Super Bowl. He holds the record for the longest postseason win streak (10), a record held by Bart Starr for over 40 years.

On Sunday night, Brady pulled off another last minute drive to beat the Chargers and brought New England one game away from their fourth Super Bowl appearance in six years. First they have to get through a red hot Colts team led by Peyton Manning. But if we know anything about Tom Brady, it’s that he performs best under pressure.

If Tom Brady wins the Super Bowl this year, next year, or any other year, everyone on earth will be able to agree on at least three things: that the day is light, that night is dark, and Tom Brady is the greatest postseason quarterback in history.

Powered by

About Josh Mandell

  • Rob

    Until he wins five NFL titles, ala Bart Starr, he won’t be the greatest playoff QB ever…

  • Arch Conservative

    So it’s only about numbers?

    So who is better? A QB who makes it to five super bowls and only wins 3 or one who makes it to 2 but wins them both?

    ALso what about the teams they go to the dance with?

    Trying to figure out who is the greatest team, rb, qb etc is stupid because it is extremely subjective.

  • http://www.futonreport.net/ Matthew T. Sussman

    Indeed, we should simply cease any and all discussion about best players, for no one else will ever see the other person’s side.

    Unlike some sections.

  • MCH

    I’d put Brady somwhere in the top-7, along with:

    Otto Graham
    Terry Bradshaw
    Joe Montana
    Troy Aikman
    Bart Starr
    Roger Staubach

    (not necessarily in order)

  • JP

    He may be one of the best playoff QBs, but he is also one of the luckiest. Case and point, SD stopped him not once but twice on 4th down in the closing minutes. It was only the stupidity of the defense after the stops that allowed Brady to continue both drives about 15 yards closer to the endzone. Remember the Raiders and the tuck rule. Oh yeah, don’t forget about having a clutch kicker behind him to close out the close games.

  • Arch Conservative

    JP……..based on the argument you just made you could claim that a number of playoff/superbowl winning teams “got lucky” due to a questionable call, missed field goal by the other team, fumble etc…..

    I think there is always an element of randomness or luck if you will in any game with any two given teams. But the Patriots in the past five years have consistently beaten the the NFL’s best teams during the season and post-season. SO I think it’s a little unfair to attribute all of their success to luck.

  • g8R TE

    Otto Graham is hands down the greatest playoff QB ever. 10 seasons…10 super bowls(championship game back then) and won 7 of 10… thats a record that will never be beaten!

%d bloggers like this: