Today on Blogcritics
Home » Gaming » Tiger Woods PGA Tour 10 Goes Out of Bounds

Tiger Woods PGA Tour 10 Goes Out of Bounds

Please Share...Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

Now, I'm all for tough scoring in golf.  I've never been one of those people willing to kick a ball out of the rough or improve my lie.  Consequently, my golf scores have never been very good – I've always wanted to break 100, I've come quite close to breaking 100, but I've never actually gotten there.  It vexes me, but one day I'm convinced that I'll get there, it's going to take some work, but I'll get there.

One place where my golf game does excel (and has for years) is in videogames.  Okay, so it's not real, but it's still pretty thrilling to put up a 59 at St. Andrews (take that, Old Course!).  As with just about any fan of computer- or console-based golf, I like my Tiger Woods, and having a Wii, Tiger is just about essential.  This year, as has been widely reported and reviewed, Tiger Woods PGA Tour 10 for Wii added a cute little device called WiiMotion Plus to the mix.  WiiMotion Plus gives an added sense of "touch" to the game by enabling the controller to better mimic a player's actions.  For me, it made buying the new version of Tiger, even though I had one from a couple years ago, absolutely necessary.

It was a great purchase, I'm thrilled with the game.  This new version of Tiger is as close to actually playing golf as I've ever come on a computer or console.  However, it's not perfect.  I've noticed a preponderance of lip-outs – that annoying moment where the ball circles the hole or dips into the hole only to come back out again.  Oh sure, that should happen from time to time, but they do seem to occur with a little too much frequency in the game. 

While distressing, that is the sort of thing I can learn to live with, the sort of thing that I can accept.  After all, I'm still shooting in the low-60s, just about 40 strokes better than my real-life scoring average. Today though I encountered a completely new facet of the game, one that makes it much harder to love the program.  I like to think of this new problem as ultra-tough scoring, and unfortunately, it's not a difficulty setting that can be altered.  Having perfect touch one won't help this one, it's just the sort of thing you have to suffer through.  Here, have a look at exactly what occurred:

To be clear, I hit the ball from the fairway, landed it just beyond the hole, and the ball trickled back oh-so-beautifully into the cup.  Normally, that's just the sort of thing you hope to happen.  In this case, Tiger informed me that I'd hit the ball out of bounds.  Since when is in the cup out of bounds?

In the past, EA was able to beautifully mock an error in the game which allowed golfers walk on water, literally.  There was a specific moment in the game where, a ball hit into the water would float, and a golfer could go out and hit there next shot (the Jesus Shot, if you will).  For the Tiger edition the following year, EA went out and made this video as a response:

That error probably allowed for easier scoring (what with no penalty for puting the ball into the hazard), and too easy scoring has been one of the criticisms of the series.  This error however seems to overcorrect the problem.

Maybe they'll work it out next year…

Powered by

About Josh Lasser

Josh has deftly segued from a life of being pre-med to film school to television production to writing about the media in general. And by 'deftly' he means with agonizing second thoughts and the formation of an ulcer.
  • http://www.whalertly.com/wordpress barga

    obviously, the hole really is a black hole…

    anyways, is that a glitch just on that hole, and did you report it?

  • http://tvandfilmguy.blogspot.com Josh Lasser

    I didn’t report it, but I did “magically” repeat it on a different hole on a different course.

  • duffer36

    I had the same thing occur when I chipped in from the fringe.

  • http://breakingwindows.com Ken Edwards

    They even go as far as putting the Jesus Shot in the bonus challenges once you complete Tournament Challenge. I have not seen a glitch this big in TW 10 on the Wii, but I have not put in as many hours as I have on the 360.

    However, I have seen on more than one instance this year is a short iron shot lands in the rough close to the green, then the next shot is a put, from on the green. I have also seen it work the other way, too. I clearly hit it on the green, then the next shot is taken from the rough.

    Never got a hole in one out of bounds though. Must be a geometry glitch. I have seen the game load with no textures a few times this year, too. But those only happened with online games.

    The 360 version also does not lip out much, unless you just hit it too hard.

  • Kevin

    I also had the same thing happen with mine on the fringe. I thought it was just a one-time thing. It hasn’t happened again. Sounds like it’s a problem across the board. It’s a fun game to play.
    Nothing like playing out in the real world, though.