Home / The Sound of One Wing Flapping

The Sound of One Wing Flapping

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on TwitterShare on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on Tumblr0Share on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone


George W. Bush gave his third State of the Union address for the umpteenth time on PBS, and it only gets more surreal with each screening — like a dream where something is missing … but what?

Maybe the surreality came from the fact that half the house sat on its hands. Maybe it was curious absence of Osama bin Laden. Maybe we were peering through the 15,000 souls who have left the planet in acts of war since the morning of Sept. 11, 2001.

Maybe it was the contrast between red and blue realities, or the image of a well-rehearsed president coached to play to standing O’s, but untrained in how to adjust for smattered claps. Maybe that was it. Because it was weird. The president, in full makeup, freshly dusted with Texas dirt, confident, commanding — gosh, he even had a new twinkle, did you see that? a new kind of wink he kept shooting to the big shots down front. Code for: palm of my hand.

By contrast, his crew looked beat to crap. Colin Powell was ashen; Condi Rice in total lockdown; Tom Ridge’s face has shrunk to the size of a tennis ball; Ashcroft was pink, puffy, awestruck and teary, thinking about eagles again; Rumsfeld should have just come in a hospital gown with a totable IV.

Making his special once a year appearance over the president’s right shoulder was VP Dick Cheney, great white wall of seething intelligence whose soul remains unrested until returned again to hiding. The backup props looked equally doleful. Three soldiers representing the armed forces barely applauded, undazzled; one of them actually yawned and another rolled her eyes. Even the military brass were slow to rise.

But the award for Most Unenthusiastic goes to the Democrats, who, time after time, remained silent and seated. What better illustration of the state of the union than one side clapping and one side not? At one point there were boos.

The wide shot showed the Republican majority spilling into the left chamber, rendering the Democrats essentially moot. In other words, many of the programs the president is selling are likely to be passed. Maybe that’s what he’s twinkling about. Makes one yearn for gridlock. Someday someone will point out to the Republocrats that more laws equal bigger government.

Of course, the State of the Union address is not a political speech — it’s a business report and a primary responsibility of the president — but it’s also the last such speech before the election. So it’s an enormous political speech.

George Bush talked about two things: the War on Terror, and what the Congress needs to do to reelect him, in terms of giveaways, promotions, gimmicks and so forth — like that No Child Left Behind Thing that we’re all so proud of.

He became solemn as he pictured that one poor kid who falls behind in his math, but, somehow, we’re there for that child, and that child will learn his math, through testing and retesting and reretesting, because if that child doesn’t make it, the school won’t eithe — and there are economic penalties for failure and these will be reflected in local taxes.

Nobody wants to leave a child behind. As a sentiment, it’s irresistible. But the NCLB Act has nothing to do with children or learning. It has to do with havoc which is currently wreaking its way through every school in America. Ask your local schools what they think.

Regarding the War on Terror, we have beaten back the Taliban, restored peace and harmony in Afghanistan, built schools, blew town. In Iraq, we found Saddam Hussein in a hole! We have occupied a sovereign state and overthrown their leader; we have earned the enmity of the majority of nations, but won the full support of a constellation of small, shuddering client states.

Somehow the morass in Iraq has become the “War on Terror.” Yet the war on terror began with a different mission entirely: find the man who masterminded and sponsored the events of Sept. 11.

Somewhere, long forgotten, sits a man on the floor of a cave, wondering if he’ll ever be found. His name is Osama bin Laden. He is so deep in hiding he didn’t even make it into the speech!

George, FOCUS. Osama bin Laden is slipping away, not just from the military and CIA, but slipping away from the national psyche.

Meanwhile Bush has planted his priorities on reelection, cynically throwing rubber chickens into our pots — as if 9/11 were some municipal problem! Come on! This isn’t the anthrax investigation, this is serious! This is a national security issue! Will you pay attention please?

Despite my resistance, I’m turning into a Demolican. I got tingles seeing Ted Kennedy rise from his slumber to shake his lavender head.

This fight isn’t over. It’s just getting good.

Powered by

About CW Fisher

  • Excellent post, CW. The Right Wingers are gonna spit nails as soon as they can tear themselves away from being glued to watching the Super Bowl. There are people here who worship the chimp in the White House.

  • Thanks, Mac. It’s probably never wise to worship people who are still alive, or still dead for that matter, but generally the longer people are dead, the better they are to worship — to a point, after which it all starts caving in. For example, Abraham’s forerunners were acknowledged jerks, tracing all the way back to the monkey house at Brookfield Zoo, look it up, and chimps should never be worshipped under any circumstances, whether they’re president or not. I’m against it. CW