Today on Blogcritics
Home » The African Queen

The African Queen

Please Share...Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

The fact that it took me over 2 months to read the mere 136 pages that make up C.S. Forester’s The African Queen tells a great deal about the quality of the writing. Classic film buffs will note that this is no fault of the story, for it made a brilliant motion picture starring the likes of Humphrey Bogart and Katherine Hepburn. The problem, then, lies in the telling.

In Creative Writing 101 writers learn the importance of showing and not telling. Forester must have been sick that day, for he spends his entire novel telling the reader exactly how the characters feel, think and are. He never allows his character’s actions or words to give the reader an emotional response, he spends his pages telling us how to feel.

There is no chance to gain insight into a character through what they do, for Forester is much too busy telling all the pertinent details. There is no subtlety in the text. If we don’t get something the first time, rest assured, he will repeat himself two or three times.

What will keep the reader reading is the power of the story itself. For many years Rose has been assisting her missionary brother in the heart of the African Jungle. When he dies suddenly, she enlists Charlie, a gin-swigging rough-and-tumble river-boat captain, to ship her back to civilization. Along the way they must traverse deadly rapids, disease-infected hoards of mosquitoes, German soldiers, and a river that is not meant for the sturdiest of boats, never mind the old, rickety African Queen.

Forester fills his tale with plenty of chills and spills. There is enough action to keep the pages turning, and an old- fashioned romance to keep the ladies interested. Truth be told, there is almost too much action. In nearly every paragraph, some new obstacle presents itself that must be overcome. Each obstacle is overcome, of course, and that a bit too quickly. For though the obstacles are fretted over and stressed about, Charlie and Rose seem to overcome them within a few sentences; only to find another one waiting around the corner. It would have served the novel better to have had fewer problems, and more struggle to overcome them.

Forester has a keen eye for mechanical detail. He gives good exposition over the mechanics of making an old steamer like the African Queen keep going. He paints a detailed picture of the African landscape, as seen from a riverboat. The physical details of the boat and its surroundings are all apt, and true. It is the abilities of the humans that bring an air of falseness.

Rose, though having never piloted a boat before, in a very short time somehow manages to master the intricacies of sailing a difficult steamer through dangerous rapids. Likewise, she sheds her moral inhibitions like a heavy coat in the sultry African climate. We are led to believe that an innocent, sheltered missionary can suddenly give up all of her beliefs and morals to a dirty, foul-mouthed, drunk, all in a matter of days.

Ultimately I would have been better off having just watched the movie again, and left the novel on the bookshelf. The movie retains all of the excitement and grandeur of the story, and elevates the storytelling to the level of classic. The book seems flat in comparison.

Powered by

About Mat Brewster

  • http://tinkertytonk.blogspot.com Rachel

    I haven’t read this book, but I know what you mean. This is the overexplaining phenomenon, in which the author gets so bogged down explaining–or sometimes describing–something that he gets in the way of his own story.

  • http://www.lovenotfear.blogspot.com Marc Moss

    I also have not read the book, but it was in my queue. Thaks for the review. I’ve now removed it from my queue. I have a difficult time reading “telling” books. I loved the movie, and, for me, for once, it sounds as if the book would be less than the film.

  • http://www.midnitcafe.blogspot.com Mat Brewster

    I’d definitely just watch the movie again. The book isn’t terribly by a long shot. But there are so many other books out there that are better, why waste your time with, OK?

  • http://paperfrigate.blogspot.com DrPat

    Forester is better encountered in the brilliant Hornblower Saga. There, his knowledge of, and ability to convey the detail of, ship-board life is a solid plus. He also doesn’t have a prim missionary-marm mind to try to get into.

    The first book in the Hornblower series is Mr. Midshipman Hornblower, ASIN 0316289124 on Amazon. I can recommend these books highly.

  • http://www.midnitcafe.blogspot.com Mat Brewster

    Thanks, Dr. Pat. I’ve heard very little about the Hornblower saga except that Forester wrote it, and that it was quite popular. Glad to hear its actually pretty good.

  • http://n/a Lucinda S.

    Do you know if the DVD release of the African Queen is only available in two or three (?) versions or packagings from China? Are they bootlegs? I have been madly searching for a legit release, but can only find these Chinese versions and am a bit uneasy about their legitimacy.
    Whazzup? LS

  • http://www.themidnightcafe.org Mat Brewster

    I’m a little confused about your question. Are you currently in China and looking for the DVD? Or are you elsewhere and can only find Chinese copies of the DVD?

    From a little searching the movie is not available on DVD region 1 (which covers the USA. There are region 2 versions (which cover Europe) and Amazon is selling those at a price, but from what I hear the quality is rotten.

    As for Chinese copies, well they are probably bootleg as most DVDs you find in China are bootlegged.

  • http://www.maskedmoviesnobs.com El Bicho

    careful, i think she’s a narc

  • http://www.themidnightcafe.org Mat Brewster

    Yikes. What I meant to say is that my name I Bob George and I don’t know anything.