Today on Blogcritics
Home » Culture and Society » Terrelle Pryor and the Terrible Twos

Terrelle Pryor and the Terrible Twos

Please Share...Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

Last Saturday, the Purdue Boilermakers (2-5) embarrassed the Ohio State Buckeyes (5-2) during a 26-16 upset. Ohio State, who had been relying on their strong defense all season, just were out played, and plain beaten up, by the meek, and little, Boilermakers. This was not only an embarrassment to the team, but an embarrassment to all Ohio State fans. The reason for this embarrassment is one player, a guy who turned the ball over four times, though he tried to twice more, #2, Terrelle Pryor.

2007
After being manhandled in the BCS National Championship for the second year in a row, this time by LSU (which I attended, much to my disgust), OSU was on the search for a good backup quarterback. Troy Smith, winner of the 2006 Heisman Trophy, had left and their current starter, Todd Boeckman, who was a first team Big-Ten player, was starting his final year. The Buckeyes needed a good backup, and somebody who would be amazing when he started.

Looking to the east, Coach Jim Tressel found his backup in a young athlete from Pennsylvania. Terrelle Pryor was playing for Jeannette Senior High School, and was considered the best nationwide recruit of his class. The kid could run, pass, and score. It looked like Pryor would be a Godsend, and that all of OSU’s troubles would soon be over. With Pryor at the reigns, there would be Heismans, National Championships, and everything that a true OSU fan would desire. #11 signed with the Buckeyes, became #2, and the new era was upon us.

2008
Fast-forward a year, when OSU is playing USC out in California. The Buckeyes are decimated, and leave the state with a 35-3 loss hanging over their heads. Boeckman had been sacked countless times, and the offense just stagnated. A week later, the Buckeyes took to the field, and #2 was leading the offense (apparently, I was one of the few students opposed to this idea). The new era had started, and Pryor was holding the reins.

With Pryor at the helm, the Buckeyes were looking decent. Well, the team was looking decent; Pryor was somewhat struggling. The kid fumbled the ball, threw many picks, and had bad judgment. He simply didn’t seem to understand the game at this level, and it was clearly a problem for him. Of course, he was a freshman, so we Buckeye fans were able to forgive him.

2009
Fast-forward again, to 2009. Terrelle Pryor was named Big-Ten Player of the Year before the season started (can we say overrated?), and the highly ranked Buckeyes were ready to dominate during the season. The superstar would get revenge on USC for what they did the year before, and he would become the second sophomore to win the Heisman (Bradford was a redshirt, and doesn't count). Clearly, the Buckeyes would make it to Pasadena and play in the National Championship, and they would beat whomever (hopefully Florida) they found there.

Of course, this didn’t pan out like it was planned. Instead, the Buckeyes lost a close one to USC, and they almost lost to Navy. The season started to look better, as the Buckeyes shut out Toledo and Illinois, back-to-back. Pryor looked to be gaining some composure, though he was still making mistakes. Purdue, however, decided that it was time to show the Buckeyes that their winning ways were over.

Now
Now that the Buckeyes lost a game to Purdue, and have debuted at #19 on the BCS initial standings, what is next for Ohio State. If you look at the fan blogs, as well as the comments on the site of the local paper, it is clear that the fans want Jim Tressel to be fired. Never mind that has the highest win percentage of any OSU coach (well, any that has coached for more than a year), or that he keeps on beating Michigan, or that he has five Big Ten Titles – nope, he must go.

Me, on the other hand, I wonder why we don’t just let Pryor go. I mean, face it, Tressel is a great coach, and the kid just plain sucks.

Pryor is clearly one of those quarterbacks who were overrated when he came into college. He has talent, and lots of it, but he just can not use it. The kid doesn’t run at the right time, doesn’t throw well, and he looks down his receiver. That might have worked back in high school, when he was playing against a bunch of tiny towns and small programs, but it doesn’t work at college, especially not at a nationally ranked school. He also has a lack of judgment, which the Michael Vick incident clearly exemplifies. To make it worse, he has fumbled the ball 12 times (5 for turnovers) and thrown eight interceptions (on only 10 touchdown passes). Clearly, this kid is not that great.


Of course, many fans blame Tressel for this. They think that it is the anemic play calling, the lack of a spread offense, and other folly. They want an offensive coordinator, a quarterback coach, and anything else that might make Mr. Pryor play better. Most importantly, they want Pryor moved to a spot that better suits him, either a different offensive type (read, spread or wildcat), as a wide out, or even as a running back. The fans can not believe that this person they placed so high on a pedestal sucks so badly, and they need to find something else to blame.

Maybe they should blame Pryor, as he clearly has caused these problems himself. He wanted to go to OSU so he could learn to pass, and that is what he is trying. His recruiting agreement probably was worded to let him pass when he wants, the number of snaps he gets, and what position he plays, all of which limits Tressel’s ability to coach. Basically, Pryor screwed himself, and all of the Buckeyes, when he decided that he should be something that he is not. Now that he has realized it, he is acting out (talking back to Tressel, the eye black, turning his back to the coach while be talked to, etc.) and acting like, well, a toddler. Maybe it is time to change this.

I suggest that Jim Tressel puts Joe Bauserman (the current backup) into the game on Saturday. While Minnesota is a tough opponent, I believe that Bauserman can throw the ball well enough to win the game (something that Pryor can not do). This punishment to Pryor should calm him down, teach him a lesson, and make him work for his spot. It shows that he has lost favor, is no longer guaranteed anything, and that he has to work for it. Maybe a little competition could help drive this wild toddler towards puberty, and make him the player that he was meant to be.


If Todd Boeckman and his family were less classy, they would be holding their bellies and laughing right now.

Powered by

About Robert M. Barga

  • http://www.futonreport.net/ Matthew T. Sussman

    Good points across the board, but Terrelle Pryor is an amazing player in the wrong system. The only reason I saw him going to OSU is they wanted to ensure Michigan didn’t get him. (Tate Forcier thanks Tressel in advance.)

    Bench him, and he’ll probably transfer to another top school and shine. If he transfers within the Big Ten (like Illinois or Penn State), well, then that’s just trouble.

    Jim Tressel’s defenses are traditionally (and still are) first-rate. It’s his slightly outdated offensive scheme that can’t match up against the greatest teams. It’s why his teams are on a three-game BCS losing streak.

  • http://www.whalertly.com/wordpress Robert M. Barga

    The thing is, Pryor picked OSU to make him a NFL quarterback. From what i understand, he has clauses indicating that he needs to drop back and pass often, which is what he wanted. This is crap, but how it is. Pryor will not leave because he wants to be good, but, he can’t, as he isn’t letting himself.

    also, he was verbal to UM before Rod went over…

    It is the big ten, defense is what they live on

  • http://www.etierphotography.blogspot.com/ Chip Etier

    Agreed, Pryor is probably in the wrong system. How amazing he could be at this level of competition remains to be seen. He certainly did not have the impact on OSU that Tebow did in FLA.
    I liked your use of verifiable facts in your article even with your obvious bias! LOL I’m a loyal LSU fan and was also a Buckeye fan back in the days of Archie Griffin, Rex Kern, and Woddy Hayes.
    Good article!

  • http://www.whalertly.com/wordpress Robert M. Barga

    I am a student and devout OSU fan, which i am quite sure was clear. I did my best to ignore my hatred of the spread to show why Pryor wasnt using it

  • gulfportcarl

    Nice article, You get to see everything first hand. I only know what I read and see and what my years of football tell me.
    I hope Tress does something to stimulate the Quarterback postion. I don’t know much about Joe Bauserman. If he’s good enough to be signed by Ohio State he’s good enough to play. Can’t do any worse than TP has done. I would have put him in at have time of the purdur game. Nice blog.

  • http://www.whalertly.com/wordpress Robert M. Barga

    Morning Carl, how are you doing?

    Thanks for the comment about the site, but we are a magazine, not a blog (petpeeve of mine)

    anyways, I believe that Tres will do something next week if need be, but odds are that he won’t have to. Pryor is simply going to stop trying to pass and run instead, I am sure of it. If he doesn’t, I will be leading the “Pull Him” chants from the student secton

  • http://www.whalertly.com/wordpress Robert M. Barga

    what other term would you use?

  • Zanesville

    The other term I would use is “he has his moments” as defined by Tressel.

    It is more suttle for the word suck even though it has the same meaning.

    Anyway, what is Tressel going to do?Bauserman looks to green to start with some big games coming up.

    Do you ever see Terrelle and if so, does he walk around campus like he’s the greatest thing since Mike Vick….lets not go there..

    How does Mr. Pryor carry himself on campus?

    I see on T.V. he has tattoos now, he reminds me of someone trying to be Mr. Cool Hip Hop.

    The look on face reminds me of someone that looks clue less. Would say this is a fair assessment?

    A Clue Less Mr. Cool Hip Hop who is way in over his head.

  • http://www.whalertly.com/wordpress Robert M. Barga

    Okay, he has moments of glory, but normally sucks. Does that work?

    The fact of the matter is that Terrelle is playing far below his caliber, and he just isn’t performing. In any thing else, we would say ‘suck’

    I have seen him on campus, and he looks like he isn’t pompus, but he still has that swagger

  • Advisor

    I do have to give Terrelle credit for his big game in the Rose Bowl.

    He did play very well and he showed he is clutch and a big play maker.

    The running game was stopped in the 2nd half and if it wasn’t for T.P., we would have lost the game.