Today on Blogcritics
Home » Music » Reviews music » Concert Reviews » Simon & Garfunkel – Old Friends (Live On Stage) DVD Review

Simon & Garfunkel – Old Friends (Live On Stage) DVD Review

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

Growing up in the seventies, I was usually drawn more to the classic-rock and heavy-metal side of the tracks, than I was to the folk-rock movement of the times.

At a very early age I was introduced, by my older brother, to an amazing variety of music from The Beatles, Steely Dan, Stevie Wonder, Santana and many others. Although I was never really exposed to the music of Simon & Garfunkel, early on, I did develop a love for many of the folk-rock artists of the time, such as James Taylor and Crosby, Stills & Nash, so naturally I eventually came to appreciate their wonderful music as well. Paul Simon went on to become one of the most prolific song writers in history, matched by only a handful of others.

Although he maintained a large and dedicated following of his own, it was always his collaboration with Art Garfunkel that the fans were willing to fill stadiums (and giant parks) for.

Old Friends is a document of Simon & Garfunkel‘s 2003 reunion tour, which was their first concert tour in over two decades. The performances are seamlessly pieced together from five sold-out shows at New York’s Madison Square Garden, and New Jersey’s Continental Airlines Arena (better known as The Meadowlands) between December 2-8, 2003. The
concert begins with a video montage that featured clips of American cultural
icons, interspersed with video of Paul and Art from their childhood up until
present day. This was all backed by a beautiful instrumental version of “America.”

The first song of the show is a soft performance of "Old Friends",
which is accompanied only by Simon’s acoustic guitar. The pace changes dramatically with the next song, a rocking version of "A Hazy Shade Of Winter", which had my wife saying "hey, I know that song." At her tender young age of 29, I’m pretty sure it was The Bangles’ version she was referring to though.

This was followed by "I Am A Rock", and then continued with 23 more of their best-known songs, which, unless a person has actually been a rock for the last 40 years, they should be fairly familiar with.

Less than halfway into this concert, it hit me what a fantastic acoustic guitarist Paul Simon is. His virtuosity has simply been overshadowed by his brilliant songwriting. Joining them on stage are an outstanding group of musicians featuring Jim Keltner on drums, and Pino Palladino on bass (who has been touring with The Who, since the untimely death of John Entwistle).

About nine songs into the show, Paul introduces the Everly Brothers who come out and perform three of their hit songs. "Wake Up Little Suzie" and "All I Have To Do Is Dream" featured just the two of them, unaccompanied, which I though was kind of a weird thing to do right in the middle of the concert.

For "Bye Bye Love", Paul, Art and the rest of the band came out to join them. Paul and Art’s voices still sound wonderful and their harmonies are like no others. Many of the classic songs are given slightly updated arrangements, but never to the detriment of the original. "Mrs. Robinson", which began the second set, and was preceded by some timeless clips from The Graduate, received an especially lively arrangement.

The production quality of this DVD is appropriately superb for a concert recording of this significance. The widescreen video presentation was vibrant, and the camera production outstanding. The Dolby 5.1 surround mix was dynamic and produced some excellent instrument separation and clarity. It sounded like Simon was sitting playing unplugged in my living room. The rear surround speakers were used extensively to enhance the live sound, and the crowd received a loud, but not overly offensive, mix.

The disc’s extra features merited the price of the DVD alone. Included, were rare clips from the 1970 television special Songs Of America, which shows some wonderful behind-the-scenes dialog between Paul and Art, as well as seven live song performances. Also included is a photo gallery of pictures from this tour, and an audio version of “Citizen Of The Planet”, their first new studio recording since 1975.

You don’t have to be a lifelong fan of Simon & Garfunkel to appreciate this wonderful DVD. This may be the last time these old friends ever tour again, so I, for one, am grateful that this special tour was captured so brilliantly on DVD.

Set List
Old Friends/Bookends
A Hazy Shade Of Winter
I Am A Rock
America
At The Zoo
Baby Driver

Kathy’s Song
Hey, Schoolgirl
Wake Up Little Suzie (The Everly Brothers)
All I Have To Do Is Dream (The Everly Brothers)
Bye Bye Love (featuring The Everly Brothers)
Scarborough Fair
Homeward Bound
The Sound Of Silence
Mrs. Robinson
Slip Slidin’ Away
El Condor Pasa
Keep The Customer Satisfied
The Only Living Boy In New York
American Tune
My Little Town
Bridge Over Troubled Water
Cecilia
The Boxer
Leaves That Are Green
The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin’ Groovy)

Performance 8/10
Production 9/10

Read all of my DVD concert reviews at Roy’s Reviews

Powered by

About Paul Roy

  • Hugo Oropeza

    Excelent descripciòn de la presentación de Paul and Art. Soy fan de ellos desde los 60s. Voy a encargar que envìen el los Cds and DVD.
    Bye Bye
    Hugo Oropeza
    Lima Perú

  • young fan

    This is certainly a great DVD, especially the extra clips from 1970. When I first watched it, I wasn’t so impressed, as I had recently seen the Simon and Garfunkel Live in Central Park concert (which is also available on DVD), and I thought Old Friends rather too flashy and overpowering. However, on returning to it, there’s a lot of fantastic musicianship and really cool stuff in the concert. You can watch it again and again.

  • John Rogers

    In the DVD extras segment, Art is singing Bridge Over Troubled Water in what looks like a studio rehearsal. Off to the side of him is a young man with dark hair (not dissimilar in appearance to Paul Simon) who yawns at one point and walks around the studio to talk to a musician. Who is this guy who also appears behind Paul Simon at a press conference in another clip?
    John Rogers
    [personal contact info deleted]