Software Review: Roxio's Easy Media Creator Suite 10 - Page 2

Roxio's "Photosuite," which is made for organizing and editing digital photographs is also easy in this updated version of EMC10.  Added to the program for this iteration is the ability to "autofix" one's digital photographs.  Essentially, this means that after selecting a photo to edit one can click the "AutoFix" button and have the exposure, saturation, and sharpness all adjusted automatically based upon what the program perceives to be the best choices (if one doesn't like the result the "reset" button is easy to spot).  "Photosuite" also allows for the look of a photograph to be changed manually, as well as the edition of special effects, the elimination of redeye, and cropping of the photograph. 

While all these features are nice, if multiple photographs are opened and available for editing at a single time, the program will not remember from one picture to the next what crop (or other) settings were used.  Thus, if one is cropping 100 photographs to 4x6 size, it is necessary in the crop tool to change the shape to rectangle, the size to 4x6, and select landscape or portrait (default is portrait) every single time.  This becomes an incredibly tedious process when one is working with multiple photos. 

The suite of audio programs included with Easy Media Creator 10, while generally useful, lacks the panache and ease of iTunes.  It should be noted that the interface for the audio programs, most notably selecting audio files to add to playlists and CDs is far more simple than selecting video files and photographs.  Selecting audio files for CDs does not have the same issue with taking songs from multiple folders that exists for photos and videos (oddly though, the problem resurfaces when having the program "AutoMix" feature).  Having Roxio go through the 5,000 plus songs on my computer (all in mp3 format) took hours between analyzing the songs and then obtaining the track information, far longer than a similar process in iTunes.  One of the more useful audio features present in the suite is the ability to convert songs to a plethora of formats.  However, the "AutoMix" feature, which takes songs inputted by the user and attempts to create a playlist with similar songs, while cute, requires inputting a multitude of songs before a playlist that makes sense can be generated. 

Continued on the next page Page 1 — Page 2 — Page 3

Article tags

Spread the word
Bookmark and Share
Profile image for josh-lasser

Article Author: Josh Lasser

Josh Lasser, formerly known as "TV and Film Guy," and complete with a Masters Degree in Critical Studies in said areas, gives his opinions on TV, Film, and Entertainment in general. All of which he does in a shameless attempt to try to get paid to do the exact same thing. …

Visit Josh Lasser's author pageJosh Lasser's Blog

Read comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own
  • Roxio Easy Media Creator Suite 10 [OLD VERSION] Roxio Easy Media Creator Suite 10 [OLD VERSION]

    Item #: M23236. The new Roxio Easy Media Creator 10 gives you creative inspiration and all the tools you need to enhance your digital lifestyle. Create, share and enjoy your movies, memories and music as only you can. ...

Article comments

— go to most recent comments
  • 1 - Mel

    Nov 15, 2007 at 7:40 pm

    Buyer Beware!! I have EMC 10, and I have found a multitude of problems, especially with the MyDVD program. If you want to edit photos PhotoSuite is actually pretty good, with only one small "bug" that I have found so far. However, in only owing this product for about 3 weeks I have had it crash so many times that I was ready to return it, and the sad thing is that I haven't even used all of it's features. Are there more bugs to come? All I can say is that editing a DVD was a complete headache and not something I would be willing to do again soon. And that's sad because it's specifically what I got it for.

  • 2 - Kara@Roxio

    Nov 15, 2007 at 9:04 pm

    Hi Mel,
    I'm sorry to hear that you are having trouble with EMC 10. So I can better understand, could you let me know the method you purchased the product- either online download, retail store, or online store (such as Amazon)?
    Look forward to seeing how we can help.
    All best,

    Kara
    Roxio, A division of Sonic Solutions

  • 3 - Gus

    Nov 20, 2007 at 10:05 am

    I am specifically getting this for dvd use only and after what mel said, I don't know if i should!
    Is it worth it?

  • 4 - Josh Lasser

    Nov 20, 2007 at 10:13 am

    I did not have any of the same problems Mel did, it never crashed for me.

  • 5 - Alan

    Nov 24, 2007 at 7:14 pm

    I'm amazed that someone actually got EMC10 to install properly. I guess my own hardware just isn't compatible with it. Anyway, I'm very familiar with all the hoops that were necessary to install previous versions of Easy Media Creator. I actually got Version 9 to play pretty well with Vista, but I can't say that about Version 10. And, yes I did go through all the steps to perform a clean install as specified by Roxio. I carefully removed all traces of the former Roxio software and cleared the registry before attempting to reinstall EMC10. How about this for an idea? Why doesn't EMC check for past versions during installation and actually remove it? Who should no better about their own code than the ones writing it. Anyway, to repeat myself, this is not the first time that I've went through all the motions. Past versions have required some of the very same frustrating proceedures. On the up side, some of the apps can be pretty good when they actually work.

  • 6 - CP

    Nov 25, 2007 at 12:28 pm

    Any advise between EMC 10 and Photoshop Element 6 with Premier 4 bundle? I have EMC 8.0 and it works OK but had many issues in order to make it work with XP, ATI graphics card and Windows Media software. Is there a list of softwares the EMC 10 compatible with and the once to watch out for?
    Chirag

  • 7 - Sid

    Dec 02, 2007 at 7:05 pm

    I find the product extremely slow and difficult to work with. I've already ruined 4 blank DVD's. Error messages are obtuse or non-existent and programs often hang.
    For example, MyDVD express will not display fonts correctly - they are blank unless I change font type to gradient. Adding a new movie may take up to a minute or more just to display a directory.
    Version: 1.0.044
    Build: 100B44B, R03
    Serial Number: K5-6C1V2-DZV0T-JCU6H




    Sid

  • 8 - Joe

    Dec 03, 2007 at 1:46 pm

    I have used and enjoyed roxio products since the days of 1x cdrom drives, and I have to say, this is the worse experience I've had with a product. This thing simply won't install. I even reformated my drive and it still won't install on my vista pc. I had high hopes for some of the pieces of this product, but I'm at a loss. I'm not the only one that has had this difficulty, so beware.... I understand some of the version 9 issues, but for a product to rave about Vista compatibilites and have basic install issues is shameful

    -Joe

  • 9 - Glen

    Dec 08, 2007 at 10:27 pm

    I also have not had any luck to date installing EMC10 on Vista. I have gone thru the Clean Install doing the steps verbatum but the program will not start. My V9 that came with my HP Pc was working well.

    I agree, what a shame for Roxio to do this to past and potential future customers. Not worth the hassel. Very Flustrated.

  • 10 - Forrest

    Dec 18, 2007 at 11:58 pm

    MyDVD and also VideoWave were crashing my computer (an HP Media Center PC running Vista, with NVIDIA graphics). I got these programs to run properly by going into the "Options" menu on MyDVD and changing "Rendering" from "Hardware" to "Software." The program comes out of the box checked "Hardware" for rendering. But it has some kind of fatal conflict with my video drivers, I think, leading to the infamous "blue screen of death" style of crash. The conflict disappeared by choosing software rendering instead of hardware. This was a very frustrating problem until I tried this solution. BTW, if you check this option for one of the programs in the suite, it appears to change it for all.

  • 11 - DC

    Jan 09, 2008 at 4:07 pm

    Last version I could get to work was 7.0. Since that time nothing but problems...not with install but getting EMC to work. Won't consider buying 10.0, but might see if I can download a copy.
    Downloaded demo of Adobe Premiere Elements 4. As with most Adobe products, it ain't simple. Tried to remove an effect, couldn't for the life of me figure out how, then it crashed. Not for the faint of heart.
    Now moving on to demo of Nero. Fingers crossed.
    Oh yah, picked up a Macbook Pro to use their video editing programs. They don't crash but pretty rudimentary.

  • 12 - bobc

    Feb 17, 2008 at 9:06 am

    Roxio EMC 10 under Vista. MYDVD seems to work ok through preview and encoding. However, the output DVD is junk. Tried the suggested drive emulation and loading the drive image file for preview - result worse. Also, slideshows just come out black. Have not gotten one usable product out of EMC 10. Have uninstalled and reinstalled. No difference.
    My opinion of Roxio products is no longer good.
    Going to look at Nero. I want something that works.

  • 13 - dave

    Mar 10, 2008 at 8:49 pm

    i just purchased emc 10 online and downloaded it. I have an hp running vista and i abolutly love this program. i mainly purchased it to move my video from my mini dv camcorder to dvd.(windows movie maker sucks). the plug and burn feature is awsome. i would highly recommend this product.

  • 14 - Minkey

    Mar 17, 2008 at 3:25 pm

    I have had BIG problems with EMC 10. The tech support really does not help. I have errors with Video Wave and MYDVD. Runtime errors in C++. I had problems with CinePlayer and MPEG-2 codecs.

    When you talk with them by phone, they say do a clean install. I have done thisabout 10 times. EMC 10 will work for a few days, then crashes again.

    Finally, the thechs and Roxio throw up their hands. They blame windows XP Pro. I have 2 different Geeks from 2 different companies and a Dell Geek say there is nothing wrong with Windows.

    The techs at Roxio/Sonic said something was wrong with my sound card. I got an upgraded card. Still had same ERRORS.

    This is the first company in all my considerable computer experience who does not seem to care about the customer or have 2nd tier support.

    Buyer Beware!!

  • 15 - JoeB

    Mar 23, 2008 at 11:00 pm

    Yes, Buyer beware. I wish I had read these comments before buying Roxio EMC 10 a few days ago and installing it on my XP Pro computer last night. It just doesn't work right and hangs all the time. I just opened a case with their tech support so we'll see how it goes, I may be wasting my time.

    My wife has Roxio 9 Basic that came bundled with her HP XP Pro laptop and it works fine. That one was free but has limited features. I may see if I can downgrade to Roxio 9 since they broke it when Roxio EMC 10 came out. There are lots of complaints on Roxio's own user forum at their website.

  • 16 - Schlist

    Mar 26, 2008 at 11:47 pm

    I'm having a devil of a time just getting this thing to install. I even thought I may have picked up a virus (not from EMC) so I did a restore of my computer from backup! Still can't get it to install. It takes forever then when it appears to be getting close to finished it says it's rolling back the install!

    Also it warns that it must uninstall .net 1.1! WTF!? .net 1.1 can't be on a machine with Roxio software...that's crap. I bought online from their store, so I'm going to get the 30 day refund.

  • 17 - Jason

    Apr 02, 2008 at 4:24 am

    This program crashed several times for me at first. I had to uninstall programs completely unrelated to Media Creation to get it to stop locking up when I was saving video files to usable formats. (Why would I have to completely disable my automatic Media Center features is beond me.) After that though, it started working perfectly. Has some weird quirks when you are running other programs that are unrelated to what it has to do though.

  • 18 - Chris W

    Apr 02, 2008 at 7:37 am

    I have been a very happy owner of Versions 5 and 6. I decided to buy Version 10 online with the Sonic Store. I am having enormous problems with components crashing (like audio editing and creator classic) after a 20 minute long installation! It's like going back to a 25 year High School reunion and saying, "What happened to you??!"

    I have been very happy with Roxio over Nero in the past, but I'm feeling VERY uneasy with this product.

    I run a pretty clean XP pro setup with a Pentium 4 with 2GB of RAM. I am not a new-bee. I have installed and uninstalled TWICE and cleared my registry, but the crashing problem remains.

    I see that CNet has still not done a review and the product has been out for some time.

    I am considering going back to Version 6 if I cannot get this resolved fast.

    CW

  • 19 - Chris W

    Apr 02, 2008 at 9:24 pm

    I got a prompt email from Roxio support indicating that my previous installation of Roxio was causing conflicts. They provided uninstallation instructions here.

    This worked and the installation was successful. So, I'm keeping EMC 10, but am very concerned at how BIG it's gotten and how long it takes to install.

    I appreciated the good tech support. Features are important, but keep in mind that regular users will need to be able to install...Roxio should have been able to detect the version 6 installed.

    Thx,
    Chris W

  • 20 - Ian Forsey

    Apr 08, 2008 at 7:13 am

    I purchased a Sony FZ31Z with a Blu Ray Drive. It came with EMC V 9 which worked fine. Wanted BD features so I purchased EMC V10.

    What a mistake to purchase V10. Spent days, countless clean installs, countless support messages and now my version 9 does not work.

    Support supplied a link for V10 update to cure problems. 719mb on a slow download. And it still ill not install!

    Stick with V 9. I am going to get my money back for V10 but has cost me much more in time and effort.
    It's the last time I buy from Roxio period!

    Now I have to Restore my computer to factory default and spend hours downloading updates and re loading all my software.

    Ian

  • 21 - Jon

    Apr 08, 2008 at 2:39 pm

    Hey All -

    I'm seeing mostly install issues here, so I'm going to take a shot at those first.

    @#19, Chris W suggested using our clean install instructions and he's spot on. This is the best way to resolve any type of installation issue. We have two:

    Clean Install Instructions for Creator 9 & 10 on Windows Vista
    Clean Installation of Easy Media Creator


    Make sure you follow the steps exactly. Let me know how it goes.

    Jon
    Roxio Customer Care

  • 22 - Robert

    Apr 08, 2008 at 4:52 pm

    Suggestion - a better uninstall application. I just went thru the clean uninstall instructions word for word ("clear out cookies and browsing history"? really? - seems a bit ridiculous just to install an application). Also, since the instructions are so long, perhaps some software company could write an uninstall program (heck, a batch file) just for this purpose? ;)

    I'm actually also a bit perturbed to see that this thread was closed as I am currently experiencing this, and there's been no clear resolution other than to perform a "clean install" - and by the way, these are "clean UNinstall" directions.

    It's a bit of a cop-out to uninstall and re-install, especially since it appears to be mostly affecting those who are upgrading from an existing Roxio product.

    I'd say find the root issue and remedy that. If that doesn't happen, the the same mistakes may be made in the next version.

  • 23 - Jim

    Apr 12, 2008 at 5:04 am

    I'm exhausted. Endless trouble ticket dialog. Followed many good suggestions from these comments. Nothing works. I'm probably going to have to eat the $150 EMC 10 Deluxe cost and re-install my four year old Videowave.

    Very disappointing.

  • 24 - Brian aka Guppusmaximus

    Apr 12, 2008 at 11:21 pm

    Wow... People still waste their time & money on Roxio?? Return EMC 10 and purchase the latest version of Nero...You won't regret it! Hell, there are atleast 5 other inexpensive media burners that are better than this crap. Ha, Roxio...

    Oh & thanks to the brainchild in comment #7 who posted his serial number...Uh-Duh?!

  • 25 - Jim

    Apr 12, 2008 at 11:28 pm

    Brian thanks for the Nero advice. The one component of Roxio that I am hooked on is Cinemagic. I don't have the time or interest to edit video and I like the simplicity of that program.

    Does Nero have a program that functions somewhat like Cinemagic?

Add your comment, speak your mind

Personal attacks are NOT allowed.
Please read our comment policy.
Please preview your comment.

blogcritics lists for Mar 18, 2010

fresh articles Most recent articles site-wide

fresh comments Most recent comments site-wide

most comments Most comments in 24hrs

top writers Most prolific Blogcritics for February

top commenters Most prolific Commenters in 24 hrs

Upcoming Stories from Blogcritics
  •