Why Puerto Rico Should Not Be Left Behind In The LGBT Debate

Author: JCBPublished: Oct 05, 2005 at 7:23 am 3 comments

Last time I checked, Puerto Rico was a territory of the United States of America, governed basically by the same judicial and legal provisions as all 50 states. Puerto Rico is home to more than 4 million American citizens and among those 4 million American citizens, there are more than 200,000 lesbian, gay, bisexual, transsexual and transgender citizens who are, for the most part, unaccounted for by local politicians, lawmakers and by their fellow citizens. I can’t help but wonder, why do LGBT mainland based organizations leave us behind? Why aren’t we part of their struggle, which is also our struggle? I can speculate about the reasons, but to tell you the truth, I really don’t have an answer. What I can truthfully tell you is why I believe Puerto Rico should not be left behind in the LGBT debate in the USA.

In case you don’t already know, please allow me to point out some historical and political facts about the relationship between the USA and PR. Puerto Rico became a territory of the United States as a result of the Hispanic-American War of 1898. Spain, by means of the Treaty of Paris, surrendered us as a bounty of war. The USA military took possession of the Island immediately. In 1917 the USA Congress, by means of the Jones Act, granted the people of Puerto Rico American citizenship; in 1948 the people of Puerto Rico elected their first native (Puerto Rican) Governor; in 1952 the people of Puerto Rico approved and enacted The Constitution for the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, which, by the way, has a broader scope of protection than the USA Constitution, in terms of due process and equal protections. Throughout our 107 year relationship, Puerto Rican soldiers have fought and are currently fighting to preserve and uphold the liberties and freedom granted by the American democracy. Our LGBT soldiers also have to put up with the “Don’t Ask. Don’t Tell” policy. The USA Congress has granted us treatment similar to that of any other state of the union, in terms of benefits and legislation. We are part of the American judicial system: we have a District Court for the District of Puerto Rico, which belongs to the 1st Circuit of the Court of Appeals; our writs for Certiorari invoking any protection under the USA constitution or any federal law are also considered by the USA Supreme Court. The DOMA (Defense of Marriage Act) was ratified by the Puerto Rico legislature in 1998. We have no hate crime or employment anti-discriminationact. Puerto Ricans participate in national politics, comprising a delegation in both the Republican and Democratic parties.

Continued on the next page Page 1 — Page 2Page 3

Article tags

Spread the word
Bookmark and Share
Profile image for jcb

Article Author: JCB

Visit JCB's author pageJCB's Blog

Read comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own
  • No image found
  • No image found
  • No image found
  • No image found

Article comments

  • 1 - a friend

    Oct 05, 2005 at 10:51 am


    hey sweetie you need to get rid of the bit at the end for your link to work... i hear your pain and echo your sentiments. well written article. i pray for you all with shrub aka george w bush as your despot!

    toodles

  • 2 - TBJ

    Oct 05, 2005 at 4:15 pm

    Good report.

    Like you, I am Puerto Rican. I am also gay. I totally understand your point but there is one thing you are not pointing out in your report, one very important thing.

    US Politicians seem to not care about Puerto Rican's thoughts on many issues for the simple fact that we do not get to vote for them. We are US Citizens, with most rights and privileges as anyone born on the "mainland". The only major difference is, we can only vote for our own government.

    You probably know that the ONLY reason Bush is "conservative" is to get votes. Politicians are out to get the most votes, plain and simple. Their personal opinions and thoughts are hidden, they only do what they think the people want to see and hear. So basically, Bush and his cronies don't need us. They don't need to cater to us because they have nothing to gain. It's all very simple.

  • 3 - Dee Tate

    Oct 07, 2005 at 5:31 pm

    Hi!
    The following is a letter I've sent out somewhere over 800 times or so,so
    far.First to 96 of the 99 Senators who have a website.Then to
    newspapers,state legislators,and any GLBT organization I could find.As well
    as 14 other countries so far.
    It was published in part by two online magazines.UKGAYNEWS and NUMBER ONE Q
    formely known as rawstory Q.I did have to ask After noticing it on their
    site I had to write them again and request that if they were to pass it
    along to please do so as is.
    A Mr.Meade who runs the local Pflag chapter in Jackon,MI. I think is the
    right location asked if he could publish it in his local newsletter.Which I
    told him he was free to do as long as I got credit.
    The title of my letter is Wolves in Sheep Clothing/Moral
    Laws/Traansitioning/Humanities Judgement
    The part they published was Wolves in Sheep Clothing and Moral Laws plus a
    different poem I also sent them.
    Being a professional writer as you are.You know if words are changed it can
    change the point or meaning.They changed the title Moral Laws to Choices
    which in my case and others can be totally taken out of context.
    So as I have told everyone feel free to publish and pass it along if you
    like it.My goal is to promote Love,Compassion and Tolerance for every
    individual sharing this world.
    I have had one response who informed that Transsexualism is different then
    then being intersexed.Which I know.I had to inform them that if they read my
    letter carefully they'd see I'm promoting Love,Compassion and Tolerance for
    everyone and that my letter just as personel aspects as to who I am.That was
    an organization in Australia called AIS Australia Intersexed Society.
    So if you like the following please pass it along as is.
    Love,your sister in
    Jesus Christ
    Dee
    A Christian Friend

    Wolves in sheep clothing
    This world is so hypocritical what's it worth.You have self righteous
    arrogant people who want to control how people are to live and act.I was
    taught that,that is a communist state.For us behaving and acting the way we
    do towards one another how can anyone including all the self righteous
    religions dare say we live in a free society.
    It seems religous organizations are more concerned about controlling what
    other do rather then help souls in this world.It makes me sick.They say
    their worried about the morality of this life.That's a joke how many of them
    lie cheat and steal thinking GOD doesn't see what their doing.How many
    adulterers are their going to church.How many of them are also the ones
    condemning others.
    NO WHERE does it say in the NEW TESTAMENT which is what Christianity is
    suppose to hold to,does it say Jesus went out and killed or hurt anyone NO
    MATTER who they were.
    The Church of Christianity has become a den of thieves and wolves in sheep
    clothing imposing whatever they think is right for them at the time.
    I believe every church should reread the first 3 or 4 chapters of
    Revelations about how even in the bible GOD has something against the seven
    churches, which anyone can clearly see is going on in todays time.Yes the
    wickedness has come into the church and it has become blind to the true ways
    of Jesus.
    The church is suppose to be a beckon for all souls not just for thoses who
    think their better then others.Obviously,thoses people need to find GOD more
    then others do.Jesus NEVER TAUGHT HATE or EXCLUSION.He invited all to come
    to him.If he were here today he'd be ministering unto the sick and weak.
    Plus theirs no church on earth worthy to recieve him.
    How can any church or anyone who goes to church dare judge another simply
    because they don't agree with the way a soul lives on this earth.Perhaps
    everyone should also reread Matthew chapter 7.
    I find it incorrigible that churches are hating and turning souls away.For a
    church to turn anyone away goes against what Jesus has taught us.Hating
    another goes against what Jesus taught us.It is of no wonder so many have
    left their churches.Many souls see that the wickedness has crawled in.THE
    CHURCH is for EVERY SOUL.I would ask and challenge anyone to tell me which
    soul thats in church is Righteous and Worthy of GOD and Jesus.
    How is it so many ministers go out of their way to condemn others for the
    way they live rather then helping souls that need food,clothing and
    shelter.Jesus went around preaching love and tolerance for one another.Why
    are so many ministers going forth doing the opposite of what Jesus
    preached.How mean,hateful and arrogant does one claiming to know the love of
    Jesus have to get until others realize that preaching hate and intolerance
    is actually a tool of the devil.
    When are souls that claim they know and love Jesus and his ways going to
    stop hating and condemning others.
    I am a firm believer in Jesus and his love.I also happen to be a soul who
    realizes that no matter how hard I try I will always be a sinner til Jesus
    ends this world or until I leave it.Churches NEED to get back to teaching
    LOVE,COMPASSION and TOLERANCE rather then then helping the Devil promote
    Hate and Intolerance.He who has not sinned may cast the first stone.But we
    all know their aren't any.
    Love,your sister in
    Jesus Christ
    Dee
    A Christian Friend

    Moral Laws
    I send this poem and
    e-mail so that you and everyone out there understand It is not a
    choice. I
    was born in 1963 in"66 I knew I was different and by "68 I knew who I
    was.I learned very young in life how wishes and dreams was nothing but
    a
    nice thought. Even back then when I was being taught that we could grow
    up
    and be and do what we want,being in a free nation.I knew that wasn't
    so.
    I've hid myself and have had other medical problems come at me when I
    was
    a teenager.Even with thoses problems.I still hid myself because of
    intolerance in our limited free society that wishes to make laws based
    on
    religion, calling them moral laws. Their are religious morals which I
    have
    and human morals.Both dictate that discrimination against anyone is
    wrong. Just because one group or organization including our government
    doesn't agree if something is moral or not, as long as one is not
    harming
    another one they should still be allowed their right to live free.
    Granted
    our nation has made great strides since the "60's yet we still seem to
    perpetuate intolerance instead of tolerance.We are the greatest nation
    on
    earth and we'll go around the world preaching our word of freedom and
    help
    the oppressed yet we still seem to oppress one another here.This is a
    major contradiction.Some of our own allies know and understand this.
    Until
    we as a nation can stop the oppression of our own citizens it seems
    arrogant to expect others to follow our lead. How many people in our
    society have gone against true freedom in favor of their own self
    righteousness.Our nation was partially founded on freedom of religion
    and
    the right not to be persecutated by it.Yet in less then 200 years we
    seem
    to allow it to happen.Has our government ever considered that when we
    have
    problems with our allies, they maybe thinking the same thing. How many of
    our citizens regardless of who they are have to be hurt,killed or
    commit
    suicide before our nation wakes up. Everyone regardless of who they
    are,are entitled to live free and have every right under the
    constitution.
    If we as a nation aren't going to up hold the rights and freedoms of
    every
    individual we better stop trying to convert the world to our ways.For
    our
    freedoms will have become limited to whatever one group or organization
    says it is.If I can not live free in this nation or world how could
    anyone
    expect me or anyone else to stay in it.What is moral to one is immoral
    to
    another so lets make moral laws based on human decency.Not any one
    organizations perception on it.
    Love,your sister in
    Jesus Christ
    Dee
    A Christian Friend
    A U.S.Citizen
    in Transition

    Transitioning
    Transitioning happens with everything.
    Seed to flower,sweet to sour
    Transitioning is something apart of life,
    theirs no sense denying it, theirs no point fighting it.
    Transitioning is such a beautiful thing
    Butterflys flying in the breeze,
    Nature flourishing,during spring.
    Transitioning takes time, with all things.
    when souls transition, angels begin to sing.
    Transitioning is a basic fact of life.
    Sometimes easy sometimes hard,
    it happens all around us near and far.
    At times it whithers,struggles and dies,
    more often then not, it grows and thrives.
    Transition of mind, is what man needs.
    Hate to love, isn't hard to conceive.
    Dee
    Love,your sister in
    Jesus Christ
    Dee
    A Christian Friend

    Humanities Judgement
    As I have said all these years I've seen and experienced many things in this
    life.All was to gain a better understanding of GOD.I don't know if I learned
    everything I should have.All I know is I've learned that this isn't the end
    and all is for GOD to judge.
    Everyone has their own perception on things.Mine is that I don't see the
    world changing for the better.It seems as though as time passes society
    keeps going backwards.Our own government will either ignore or just change
    laws to suite it's own ambitions.TRUE FREEDOM IS NOT THE SUPRESSION OF ONE
    ANOTHER.Their is NO ONE better then another.Some may have more then others
    but, that doesn't make them any better.
    I have written and sent out a letter that states that their is a plague
    running across the world and that is that so many people THINK they are more
    righteous then others and they are condemning others for NOT THINKING the
    same way.This is what our society has labeled communition which is the
    controlling of others.Which our great nation seems to be doing.
    Has our country become so arrogant to think we know whats best for every
    individual.Have we become such a closed minded society as to dictate what is
    right or wrong for an individual.Has our country become so hateful towards
    one another that we don't even notice it.It appears that many so called
    religious organizations have turned to promoting hate and intolerance rather
    then promoting Love and Compassion.And if that be the case.How can they dare
    say they know our Lord GOD.My GOD is LOVING not hateful.MY GOD is
    COMPASSIONATE not intolerable.For all those who would use GODS WORD to
    condemn another is denying GODS love and compassion.
    My book of life will say that even though humanity has some potenial it has
    none unless it includes GODS love and compassion.Humanity has become a
    wicked society that won't even give a soul the right to live as it
    chooses.Humanity is fixated on making everyone conform to what one may think
    is right and forcing it on others.To many souls here give lip service to
    rights and freedom only wanting to supress others if they don't agree with
    them or what humanity says is the norm.
    The norm for humanity and society is to condemn and persecute one
    another.The norm is hating what is different.The norm is not allowing others
    to be who they are.The NORM is not accepting of ANYTHING DIFFERENT.The norm
    is that souls percecute one another even when what one does,doesn't hurt or
    have anything to do with another.
    The NORM of humanity and society isn't the way of GOD.
    GODS normality is diversity.GODS norm is loving even when he doesn't agree
    with the way things are.GODS normality is being compassionate towards every
    soul,none are excluded.GODS normality is loving those who hate.GODS
    normality is not placing one over or above another.GODS normality is
    allowing humanity and souls to do what they will even if it's to percecute
    one another in his name.GODS normality allows religious organizations to
    percecute his souls even if it's only his to judge.GODS normality is knowing
    their are many organizations who confess to know him yet knowing their only
    wolves in sheep clothing.
    You see what we as human souls perceive and say is normal isn't what GODS
    is.Don't be arrogant enough to say it is.Humanity has alot yet to learn yet,
    it seems as though humanity will not or is not willing to accept the
    diverity GOD has given us.Every soul is for GOD to judge not any given
    religious organization.
    Is religious organizations so arrogant to think one will judge another.Or
    that one is better then the other.Will the Jew judge the Christian,will the
    Christian judge the Jew.Or will any of them judge the atheist.No of course
    not.So why is it so many wish to judge in GODS name when it's not their
    place to do so.
    If one confesses a faith and judges another.Aren't they placing themselves
    above GOD.Humanity needs to learn to accept one another with all the
    differences GOD gave us rather then wasting what short time we have here
    condemning one another.Remember in judging another you have allowed yourself
    to be judged the same.
    Their are many churches in our country who need to reread Matthew chapter
    7and if they truely understand it their doors will be open to every soul
    that wishes to enter.
    Some may say I'm passing judgement, when in reality what I've said is all
    based on the reality of this world.Humanity has to be realistic about how it
    is in order to begin to learn and understand GOD.All is GODS' for him to
    judge not any one soul or organization.
    Love,your sister in
    Jesus Christ
    Dee
    A Christian Friend

    FREEDOM WHO'S IS IT ANYWAY?
    With what has happened recently It makes me feel as if their is hope for
    humanity.It's love and compassion is shining though.I wonder if it will
    still show after the current tragity is over.It seems to be basic human
    emotion to turn back to hating one another after such events.
    As I've written before people will hate,exclude,hurt or kill one another
    simply because they don't like the way another lives.This is not FREEDOM.
    How many of those organizations that hate the way another lives is now being
    a hypocrite by helping them and then go back to wanting to exclude,hurt or
    kill them.Their are many wolves in sheep clothing trying to keep up an
    appearance.
    I personelly have had enough of humanities prejudices,bigotry and being two
    faced when it comes to FREEDOM.
    My learned behavior from humanity is that even in a society that calls
    itself free,one must behave according to what someone else says is moral not
    by common human decency or their not allowed rights others have,this is not
    FREEDOM.It seems humanity can't handle freedom.If it could,it's governing
    bodies wouldn't be governing how or what an individual does with it.
    FREEDOM means organizations aren't allowed to force their views on
    anyone.Yet the first amendment keeps being thrown out the window.
    It seems our constitution no longer stands for FREEDOM.It appears to be a
    document that is used by some to justify the governments actions on
    restricting ones right in favor of anothers.Which isn't FREEDOM.
    Organizations want our (government) alleged free society to make laws based
    on their belief.Which isn't FREEDOM.I know of a country that once governed
    organizations by it's belief.It wasn't a free society.Now,those same
    organizations wish to control instaed of being controlled.They have went
    from being the oppressed to being the oppressers.This isn't FREEDOM.
    FREEDOM is FREEDOM for ALL..If not,FREEDOM doesn't exisit.It's simply a
    word.Don't be a idiot and try to misconstrue my words or thought.Things such
    as murder,rape or ANY thing that would hurt another is basic.No one has the
    right to do that.Yet some who claim FREEDOM will do such things because of
    their belief.Not allowing those who believe differently that same FREEDOM
    they claim.
    FREEDOM IS BASIC HUMAN DECENCY,TOWARDS ONE ANOTHER.FREEDOM IS TOLERANCE
    TOWARDS ONE ANOTHER,DISPITE DIFFERENCES.NOT SUPRESSING ONE ANOTHER BECAUSE
    OF THEM.FREEDOM ISN'T RESTRICTING RIGHTS BECAUSE OF DIFFERENCES IN FAITH OR
    WHAT IS CALLED LIFESTYLE.FREEDOM ISN'T PERPETUATING IGNORANCE OR
    LIES.FREEDOM IS UNDERSTANDING BY TRUTH OF FACTS.FREEDOM IS A CONCEPT A LOT
    OF HUMANITY CAN'T UNDERSTAND OR IS AFRAID OF.FREEDOM ISN'T CONTROLLING,YET
    SOME WISH TO CONTROL FREEDOM.THOSE WHO DO,ARE ENEMIES OF FREEDOM.WHETHER
    THEIR OUTSIDE A FREE COUNTRY OR THOSE WITHIN,WISHING TO RESTRICIT THE RIGHTS
    OF THOSE WHO LIVE WITHIN.

    FREEDOM!, WHO'S IS IT ANYWAY.RELIGIONS,PRIVITE
    ORGANIZATIONS,GOVERNMENTS?
    FREEDOM IS A (CONCEPT,BELIEF) ALL IT'S OWN.IT"S NOT BIAS OR PREJUDICE.
    FREEDOM and a SOCIETY CLAIMING FREEDOM EITHER ALLOWS FREEDOM FOR ALL AND IF
    THEY DON"T.THEY NEVER UNDERSTOOD THE CONCEPT OF FREEDOM OR BELIEF OF
    FREEDOM.


    Isn't it amazing how some seem to have nothing to do but worry about what
    others are doing,and people think I'm crazy.It's also amazing how some seem
    to want to invovle themselves with matters that don't have anything to do
    with them.Dispite expecting FREEDOM for themselves they wish to restrict it
    for others.How hypocritical can society get.People talk about believing in
    things such as GOD and FREEDOM yet in reality all they really want is to
    control that which they don't like.People never seem to want others to live
    life other then the way they are or want.Again how hypocritical of FREE
    society.Some believers are the worse when one is trying to live their life
    in a free society.Thinking you must believe the way they do or you are an
    abomination.Those souls don't understand or respect FREEDOM.Nor do they
    understand compassion or tolerance.Human society doesn't want FREEDOM it
    wants COMPLIANCE.
    Religious organizations want Americans to comply with what they believe and
    are willing to go againist it's teaching as well as disregarding America's
    FREEDOM in order for others to comply to the way they think and believe.As
    I've stated before Religious organizations are now wanting to oppress others
    like they were.No matter what organization it is,oppressing others is wrong.
    We Americans are unique and hypocritical.We wish to create laws surpressing
    FREEDOM and still try to claim we treasure it.How can anyone wonder why some
    don't like us,considering how we limit FREEDOM to those who only comply with
    the way religious organization feels.
    Morality is an issue humanity has been arguing about since the beginning.So
    lets take a look at it.We have organizations that hide pedifiles,yet claims
    morality.We have people who we trust to run our country,yet some will take
    advantage and use taxpayers money for their own greed.We have some people
    and organizations who claim same sex marriage is bad yet,many marriages have
    affairs.Some organizations will turn a blind eye to it allowing those
    marriages to be apart of their church not considering the morality of it and
    then EXCLUDE others claiming morality reasons.Is it moral for a church to
    exclude anyone seeking GOD.Are they not judging.Which they were told not to
    by the one the church is based upon.Or are they content in judging in his
    place.Human decency is the moral thing.Love,Compassion and Tolerance is the
    moral thing.Allowing another the same FREEDOM one expects is moral.Limiting
    anothers RIGHTS and FREEDOM because someone else or organization doesn't
    like what another does is IMMORAL and isn't FREEDOM.
    I know my words seem to be redundant after writting Wolves in Sheep
    Clothing/Moral Laws/Transitiong//Humanities Judgement but,if theirs one
    thing I've learned about humanity is that it's redundant in making the same
    mistakes over and over,century after century in wanting to control anothers
    life.I realize that FREEDOM is realitively a new concept for humanity to
    handle but,a nation that claims FREEDOM can not allow any organization
    including religious ones to dictate their view of morality on others.Even a
    government that is based on belief.If they do their not supporting FREEDOM
    their supporting favoritism and separatism.
    Love,your sister in
    Jesus Christ
    Dee
    A Christian Friend

Add your comment, speak your mind

Personal attacks are NOT allowed.
Please read our comment policy.
Please preview your comment.

blogcritics lists for May 19, 2013

fresh articles Most recent articles site-wide

fresh comments Most recent comments site-wide

most comments Most comments in 24hrs

top writers Most prolific Blogcritics for April

top commenters Most prolific Commenters in 24 hrs