The Daily Times of Pakistan cautions that the moves may not be enough
...One does not need to marshal arguments to prove that there can be no modern, progressive Pakistan while the country has a parallel, medieval and millenarian streak running through it.However, having said this, we need to put the new measures in a perspective.First, and let this come as no surprise, some of these measures are not new. Banning extremist organisations, arresting their leaders and streamlining and registering seminaries, are measures the government decided to take, with no less fanfare, back in 2002. Since then, their implementation has been the story of inefficiency and selectivity.
A truly insightful comment in the Daily Times editorial reads, referring to the private madrasas,
The sanctity of a private entity is directly proportional to the good that the entity can produce in a society. It does not mean freedom from regulation to do things that are patently against accepted or legal norms of behaviour or, as in this case, obviously murderous and criminal.Not all terrorists come from the seminaries. But there is enough evidence to suggest that some seminaries have a dubious character on that count. Moreover, nearly all seminaries produce students with sectarian biases and narrow, particularistic ideologies. So it makes sense to tackle the problem in all its aspects.
....
the real problem in the longer run lies with the nature of the state itself. That brings us to other facets of the problem about which General Musharraf remains quiet. The problem, as it stands, has been the creation of his constituency. While he might want to move against the seminaries, he is not prepared to put the army in its correct place within the polity. Neither has he shown any desire to link up with regular, mainstream parties.
President Musharraf, make the Islamic Renaissance happen!
Also: Enlightened Moderation for Dummies
Article comments
1 - RKC
President Musharraf, make the Islamic Renaissance happen!
All he needs is a magic wand.
2 - Aaman
AND big cojones
3 - Victor Plenty
Terrorism is the background noise of a free society. Trying to make terrorism impossible, just like trying to appease terrorists, is incompatible with freedom. The civilized world and its leaders must not let terrorists dictate our core values, our policies, or the structures of our governments.
We already know what needs to be done to make the world a better place. Our main task is to get on with that work. The sooner we realize this, and stop letting terrorism take center stage in every policy debate, the better off we all will be.
No other strategy would more effectively reduce terrorist activity than letting the terrorists grind their teeth in frustration, knowing nothing they can do could weaken the determination of the world's civilized peoples.
4 - Mihos
Right On Victor! Im going to go have a bloody mary and toast to that remark.
Catreus wallichi !
5 - theunknownshredder
The REAL Terrorists are OUR GOVERNMENT and RIGGED Elected officials
They were behind 911,Oklahoma City,Waco,London shall I go on?????
Bin Laden was created and trained as well as the Saudis that flew the planes by the CIA...Can anyone say INSIDE JOB
This Terrorist "Threat" is creating a climate of Fear that Bush has used to take away our Civil Liberties(see Bill of Rights)with The Patriot Act which makes anyone with an Extreme viewpoint a "Terrorist" and infringes on our Freedom and Privacy very Unconstitutionally
America is 1 step away from Martial Law and The New World Order
Notice how the London bombing coincided with Bush urging Congress to extend and expand the powers of The Patriot
Act??????????
These events are used to scare the general public(most of which is easily misled and downright stupid)into giving up their rights for supposed Security against "Terrorists" that dont even really exist
I believe if we were smart we would heed Ben Franklins words "If we give up Liberty for Security We shall have Neither"
Check out this site for the TRUTH about your Government
http://www.infowars.com
6 - Dave Nalle
LOL, an InfoWars drone rears his shaven head.
Dave
7 - Aaman
And what does all that have to do with the sources of terror?
8 - Dave Nalle
Ah, you don't realize that the Bush administration and its ties to the new world order are part of a conspiracy to control the world through the use of terrorism?
Bush blew up the WTC, you know....really.
Dave
9 - Aaman
No - it's the Worshippers of Ma'at - egged on by Pinhead and the other cenobites
Seriously, though, what would it take for a true multi-pronged approach to the sources of terror, as addressed in the Daily Times editorial?
10 - RKC
There is no "War on Terrorism". Terrorism is a tactic -- not an enemy.
Those who utilize terror as a tactic do so because other tactics are not at their disposal.
We are facing an enemy intent on driving Westerners out of their part of the world. We are facing a form of natiomalism combined with religious fundamentalism.
It is obvious why the "terrorism" misnomer is used. We don't want to admit that we are fighting nationalism.
To be honest we should stop calling it by the euphemism that disguises the reason for the attacks.
11 - one with no name
As I'm from Karachi, I might be able to add a bit to Aaman's article.
I remember in the 80s and 90s, I often had to shoo away people from my front gate, who wanted me to go with them to the mosque... and give them MONEY.
These visits happened everywhere, every week.
Now since last 2, 3, 5, years (specially since Mushi), these islamic pests have VANISHED. I haven't seen or heard of one since last 2 years.
So its a slow process, but it is taking place for sure.
I also notice one-tenth the number of women covering their heads (compared to early 90s) and even less men keeping beards. This might seem like a small thing, but actually it isn't.
Also, the number of people reporting their cable-tv cables being cut, has come down dramatically. This is what the madressa swine do when they're bored. They declare cable-tv, the work of the devil and go around climbing poles to cut cables. They are often caught, given a beating and handed over to the cops.
If you study Pakistan's history, you will see that nothing happens here suddenly or dramatically. Its always small evolutionary steps. This place moves like a leviathan and takes years to change its direction. The direction has already changed though it might not be seen as such by outsiders.
Its clear to me... judging from the signs on the ground....which direction we are going in. But don't expect anything much until the next couple of years.
12 - Mihos
"Comment 10 posted by RKC on July 31, 2005 08:54 PM:
There is no "War on Terrorism". Terrorism is a tactic -- not an enemy.
Those who utilize terror as a tactic do so because other tactics are not at their disposal.
We are facing an enemy intent on driving Westerners out of their part of the world. We are facing a form of natiomalism combined with religious fundamentalism.
It is obvious why the "terrorism" misnomer is used. We don't want to admit that we are fighting nationalism.
To be honest we should stop calling it by the euphemism that disguises the reason for the attacks."
Im cutting and pasting this to the signature of my email. You are a seer my fine feathered friend.
13 - Aaman
Thanks onewithnoname - your perspective is valuable and we will appreciate more details - my father was from 'Rawalpindi, and my mom was from Murree, so I have ancestral ties to your beautiful country
Keep the Faith!
14 - Dave Nalle
I don't buy it. It's still a war on terror, not just nationalism. There are plenty of forms of nationalism which are not our enemy. People dressing in costume and doing their national dance isn't a problem. The French getting some common sense and voting down the EU constitution is nationalism which has a positive outcome.
What distinguishes the individuals, organizations and states which we are fighting is their willingness to murder civilians at random to advance their nationalistic causes.
So it's not the nationalism which we're fighting, it's the combination of nationalism and - for lack of a better word - evil.
dave