Hanging On The Edge Of A Cliff: Update On The Mideast - Page 2

OC Northern Command Lt.-Gen. Udi Adam said Thursday evening that the army has hit hundreds of targets in Lebanon since Wednesday night. Adam added that Israel has not ruled out sending ground forces into Lebanon. He told reporters that even Northern Command had come under Katyusha fire during the day. "I imagine over time that we will be able to rid ourselves of this threat entirely," he said.  

Tap Dancing On The International Stage

President Bush defended Israel's attacks but expressed concern about toppling the fragile Lebanese government. "Israel has a right to defend herself," Bush said at a news conference in Germany with Chancellor Angela Merkel. "Every nation must defend herself against terrorist attacks and the killing of innocent life." 

Western countries, Russia, and the United Nations called for restraint and demanded the return of the soldiers. The Arab League called an emergency meeting of foreign ministers in Cairo on Saturday, while the Lebanese Cabinet urged the U.N. to intervene, but all they got was a promise by U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan to send three veteran U.N. officials to the area to try to defuse the crisis. 

In a turnabout from last night’s response, The European Union “criticized Israel for using what it called "disproportionate" force in its attacks.”  EU foreign policy chief Javier Solana said he too was planning a peace mission.

Although there has been no media response or analysis, a review of comments by moderate Arab governments showed relative restraint, “apparently reflecting a sentiment in Egypt, Jordan and Saudi Arabia that Hezbollah — and by implication its top ally Syria — had started the fight with Israel.”

On the other hand, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas warned that Israel's Lebanon offensive "is raising our fears of a new regional war" and urged world powers to intervene.  

The Analysts Begin To Weigh In 

Forbes reports that Israel appears to be using the current crisis to strike a decisive blow against what Haaretz military correspondent Zeev Schiff called an "extreme foursome" — Hamas, Hezbollah, Syria and Iran. 

Continued on the next page Page 1 — Page 2 — Page 3

Article tags

Spread the word
Bookmark and Share
Profile image for mark-schannon

Article Author: Mark Schannon

Crisis/risk/issues management and communications and PR consultant, free-lance writer, aspiring pundit and author. Blogcritics.org asst. ed, politics. Wanted to set world on fire, but bride won't let me play with matches, so I'm counting on upcoming, …

Visit Mark Schannon's author pageMark Schannon's Blog

Read comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own
  • Imperial Hubris: Why the West is Losing the War on Terror Imperial Hubris: Why the West is Losing the War on Terror

    Though U.S. leaders try to convince the world of their success in fighting al Qaeda, one anonymous member of the U.S. intelligence community would like to inform the public that we are, in fact, losing the war on terror. ...

Article comments

— go to most recent comments
  • 1 - Ruvy in Jerusalem

    Jul 14, 2006 at 12:51 am

    Mark, unfortunately, the point where the analysts "weigh in" is not news. The world wants us killed off and resents if we dare to fight to live. If the Europeans threaten a boycott - not the first time they've done this - they may stifle our guns. Israeli politicians are not big on courage or willingness to really lead and inspire. But the strategic interest in survival is as yet too strong - I hope.

  • 2 - Phillip Winn

    Jul 14, 2006 at 1:25 am

    This is a fantastic and level-header report. Thanks!

    I happen to be in the "let Israel blow up the folks who refuse to acknowledge the right of Israel to exist" camp, so I'm quite happy to see some recognition that Israel didn't provoke this fight, but like most others I'm also worried about whether Israel's actions will cause any long-term progress, given the apparent focus of the surrounding culture on blood feuds.

    We had the Hatfields and McCoys, and their story is a reminder to the rest of us in the U.S. that an eye for an eye makes the whole world go blind. it doesn't seem that lesson has sunk in all around the world yet, though, so I wonder if Israel's action -- though justified as far as I'm concerned -- might not lead, yet again, to more response against them.

    Sigh.

  • 3 - Phillip Winn

    Jul 14, 2006 at 1:26 am

    Level-headed, I meant to say. Oops! Should've previewed my comment.

  • 4 - mschannon

    Jul 14, 2006 at 1:39 am

    Ruvy, what the analysts say becomes news because they create the environment in which people evaluate what's going on there. As for the EU, I may do an opinion piece on what a bunch of small-minded, aging, useless pile of wasted land it is...except I happen to love Europe for vacations.

    The world dosn't want you destroyed...just too many people in it. You do have friends.

    Phillip, thanks. I agree with you, although I'm trying to be an unbiased reporter. And I'll take lever-headed any day of the week, LOL.

    In Jameson Veritas

    and to quote a great scholar...and so to bed

  • 5 - Dave Nalle

    Jul 14, 2006 at 1:47 am

    I'm all for Israel's right to exist, but at the same time they have to some degree legitimized those who are arrayed against them through their draconian policies and treatment of the Palestinians. Hamas, Hezbollah and the other terrorist groups certainly deserve to be suppressed, but the problem for Israel is that in the process of doing that work they bring a lot of harm to innocents, and that keeps feeding the anti-israel sentiment in the arab world and among the sentimental worldwide.

    Dave

  • 6 - Ruvy in Jerusalem

    Jul 14, 2006 at 2:23 am

    Dave,

    If you've noticed, I've long advocated a very different kind of solution to the problems of the region - one that cuts out Aramco and cuts in the average Israeli and Arab - one that cuts out the Wahhabi and all of its relatives so that all the Children of Abraham can live in peace. As for oil, it is too precious to be wasted on gasoline or fuel. It has far better uses as plastic, and its use should be restricted as much as possible.

    I don't like it that Lebanese are dying in our bombing raids. I don't like it that Arabs in Israel do not have the kinds of economic opportunity they deserve - or most Jews don't either!

    But I'm afraid that matters are not only out of the hands of powerless new immigrannts like me - they will also be out of the hands of those who think they wield power as well.

    So oil your guns and stock your ammo. Things may get very interesting in the not too distant future.

  • 7 - Dave Nalle

    Jul 14, 2006 at 2:54 am

    To be bluntly honest, Ruvy, the worse things get in Israel the less chance there is of violence spilling over to the US. So long as Israel is raising itself up as the #1 badguy and we're just their big, dumb friend, we're going to get a lot of blame, but most of the bombs are still going to fall on Israel. If the current conflict escalates it may lead to a true tipping point where the US has to step in to stabilize the region after Israel does the dirty work, putting the US almost in the position of a savior for the arabs of devastated enemy nations. Or Israel could hit back a bit and then cave halfway through getting the job done - the modern standard - leaving everyone pissed off and another war just around the corner.

    But nonetheless I'm stocking my guns and oiling my ammo just on principle.

    Dave

  • 8 - Andrew

    Jul 14, 2006 at 3:11 am

    How do I get to Mars? All this makes my head hurt.

  • 9 - Ruvy in Jerusalem

    Jul 14, 2006 at 7:35 am

    Consider Mark,

    IMHO, an Israeli military force has to take the initiative and destroy in entirety the missile pods of HizbAllah in Lebanon, invade the Bekaa Valley and occupy it permanently and warn the Iranians that further attempts to destabilize the Jewish state would be met with NUCLEAR retaliation and there would be NO warning.

    Southern Lebanon must be reoccupied up to the Litani River and the PA totally destroyed. The Saudis must be similarly warned that ANY activity to destabilize the Jewish state would be met with NUCLEAR retaliation, and there would be NO warning. NONE.

    Middle Easterners do not understand "messages". They only understand actions and words backed with actions. I'm talking to you as a fellow who has learnt this of hard experience.

    Consider how this works. You have the set[WAHHABI]. Within this set, you have subsets [Moslem Brotherhood, Hamas, Taliban, Al Qaeda, Saudi regime]. The head of the snake is the Saudi regime in Riyadh, the subset that finances the entire set. So, this must be the object of destruction. Who occupies the oil fields? Irrelevant. There is present in Israel TODAY the technology to make the Arab oilfields worthless.

    That is what NEEDS to be done. The cowards in Jerusalem will not do this. They kowtow to the American and European régimes who prefer to deal with Arabs and find the elimination of Jews convenient, for a variety of reasons.

    Again, victory is wthin our hands, and again the cowards in on government hill here will just walk away.

  • 10 - Ruvy in Jerusalem

    Jul 14, 2006 at 8:34 am

    Dave,

    Whatever happens here, violence is unlikely to "spill over" to the United States. Let's leave the specific reason for things getting interesting in the States unmentioned for the moment.

    Nevertheless, you may be more prescient than you realize.

    This: "If the current conflict escalates it may lead to a true tipping point where the US has to step in to stabilize the region after Israel does the dirty work, putting the US almost in the position of a savior for the Arabs of devastated enemy nations. Or Israel could hit back a bit and then cave halfway through getting the job done - " is very close to my scenario for what will wind up happening here.

    I have a different spin than you do, but the essential description of events on the ground in my own scenario is much the same. I am convinced that eventually, American troops will be patrolling the streets in J-lem for a time...

  • 11 - Webmaster Mike

    Jul 14, 2006 at 8:54 am

    The solution screaming out to the world since 9/11 is so simple and un-escapable. All events of any import testify to what it will take to achieven World Peace.... DISARM ISLAM.

    Now go back and re-read all the news for the last week ... or last 5 years... with that sniplet of wisdom unblocking your brain cells. GWB knew this on 9/12 and acted accordingly.

  • 12 - troll

    Jul 14, 2006 at 9:06 am

    just what westerners love to see - Semites fucking each other over...manipulated by Persians no less

    as for the Muslim Problem - IMO no final solution is possible until control of Mecca is returned to followers of 'the true faith'

    troll

  • 13 - Nancy

    Jul 14, 2006 at 9:32 am

    My personal mindless, gut response to all this: Ruvy, I hope you guys kick the shit out of Hezbollah, Hamas, Syria, & anyone else who messes with you. I may not like all of Israel's policies, but I utterly respect them for their gutsy refusal to take crap from anybody, including the US. You go, guys!

  • 14 - Webmaster Mike

    Jul 14, 2006 at 10:05 am

    Get it on Israel and run up the body count of those feveriously trying to get weapons and Jehadis over the Lebenon & Syria border. You have the the Muslim bad actors broadcasting their direct involvement as the world watches.

    If need be, pass out weapons to any Israeli Nursing Home and let Grandpa and Granny get into some action too. I've always said the only real mistake GWB ever made was calling off the all out Iraq War machine after 3 weeks listening to Arabs begging for a ceasefire. He should have listened instead to Gen Tommy Franks and fought on killing any Iraqi with a AK-47 for at least 3 more months.

    Now it's Muslim on Muslim Civil War there and our Troops should be in secure MAD MAX type fortified encampments ... not doing any police work. Call in the US warriors when need who come in shooting to kill anyone with a weapon. Then they leave back to camp with NO PRISONERS, and let the Iraquis deal with the aftermath. If they don't like the results ... don't call.


    Best Islam learns they aren't responsible enough to have weapons. It should be a world crime to even sell a Muslim a weapon. Then we won't have to worry about all these terrorist blood trails leading to some Maoque throughout the world.

  • 15 - mschannon

    Jul 14, 2006 at 11:25 am

    Dave, the Arabs have left Israel with no choice but full-scale war, although I fear, like Ruvy, that the Israeli government doesn't have the balls for it. Israel withdraws from Gaza...the terrorists see it as weakness and continue to attack. Israel withdraws from Northern Lebanon, Hezbollah takes over and sees it as weakness and attacks.

    There are no options for Israel in the long term but to demonstrate without question that it has and will use the power to bomb the Arabs into the stone age until the Arabs themselves control the terrorists.

    To an Arab, restrait=cowardice. They only respect strength. Make them pay such a horrible price for their continuing desire to destroy Israel that they'll never consider it again.

    In Caffine Veritas

  • 16 - troll

    Jul 14, 2006 at 11:44 am

    Mark - *To an Arab, restraint=cowardice. They only respect strength.*

    IMO it is cunning that is most respected

    troll

  • 17 - J

    Jul 14, 2006 at 12:11 pm

    The creation of the state of Israel was a big mistake. The only blame can be placed on the ignorance of the allies after WW2. The reason Israel finds itself under constant attack from Muslim extremists is because the Koran gives them a a religious mandate to expell all foreign relgious bodies out of the pre-established Islamic holy land (Dar'al Islam).
    So here we have a self-proclaimed Jewish state smack in the middle of the Islamic holy land. What do you think is going to happen, a slumber party? The simple fact of Israel's existence is the only reason Muslism extremists need to start a fight. They will not stop until Israel is in ruins. 180 million sum Muslims agaist a mere 5 million Jews in Israel... You do the math. Israel only has the support of the United States which is worth nothing anymore since the US is a stagnant blundering beast at the moment.

  • 18 - mschannon

    Jul 14, 2006 at 12:25 pm

    J, you neglect one important fact. The entire Arab world, save Egypt was a creation of the Europeans, most England and France after WWI.

    Jordan was actually the home of the Palestinians but they gave it to the Hashemite thugs in payment for their terrorism during WWI.

    Saudi Arabia didn't exist but they gave it to the Saud family for the same thing.

    Iraq was a collection of warring tribes (thing Iraqi war) thrown together for convenience.

    The borders of Syria, Lebananon, and the baby emirates were equally haphazardly drawn. The Arabs were a nomadic, barbaric people with no sense of nation--only tribe. So to talk about the Islamic Holy Land is absurd. None of them thought that way--until Israel came along.

    And, by the way, when you're ready to give the U.S. back to the Native Americans, I'll consider suggestions about Israel giving any land back. Conquering land by force is as old as humanity.

    In Decaf Veritas.

  • 19 - mschannon

    Jul 14, 2006 at 12:26 pm

    Oh, and Troll, yeah, cunning is good too, but as Ruvy would attest, we ain't got a lot of cunning folk running Israel these days. But we do have lots o' bombs.

    In decaf Veritas

  • 20 - nick

    Jul 14, 2006 at 12:57 pm

    May God bless the lebanese people. Our thoughts and prayers are with them.

  • 21 - bobupanddown

    Jul 14, 2006 at 1:08 pm

    It has to be recognised that there is huge animosity towards israel from the arab countries, i do however, find it disgusting that the arabs are labelled as being responsible for ALL escalation. Loss of life on both sides of this conflict is equally bad, but I feel the israeli government could go much further to decreasing tension, in fact I think they are aiming to do the opposite. Every engagement I've seen involves a small terrorist attack, and a massive retaliation from israel that kills many innocents. In fact, israel seems to want conflict as much as possible. I think beofre Israel has the right to demand ANYTHING of the arab nations, especially palestine, it needs to conform to its UN sanctions (of which there are over 60) and leave the occupied territories. Essentialy you have a rich small island (israel) surrounded by a third world situation ( palestine) if israel wants peace, it needs to help palestine regain control of its own area, this is what will eliminate terrorism, when there is no longer public support for it. As long as israel bombs infrastructure and arrests democratically elected leaders from another country, while simultaneously occupying that countries land, the population will feel nothing but hate. what else would you expect?

  • 22 - Nancy

    Jul 14, 2006 at 1:22 pm

    I for one am sick & tired of the various arab factions and their endless excuses for why they hate this & why they attack that; in their minds, it's everyone's fault but theirs, they're always the blameless victims of injustice, etc. etc. ad nauseam - and then they go out & blow up or kidnap & murder/decapitate/mutilate innocent parties, and they just can't understand why the West perceives them as barbarian vermin who aren't worth the slugs to shoot them with.

    It's a pity someone hasn't been able to come up with some kind of permanent sterilyzing compound that could be dumped in the water, that would ensure that in a generation or so there would be no more of these scum to perpetuate murder & mayhem around the world. Frankly, I hope this time around Israel just lets fly & flattens once & for all the surrounding terrorist states & mindlessly violent semitic neanderthals that seem to comprise most of their citizenship.

  • 23 - Kwadwo Danso

    Jul 14, 2006 at 3:38 pm

    America stands with Israel No Matter What

  • 24 - Kwadwo Danso

    Jul 14, 2006 at 3:40 pm

    but seriosly though what is an Arab life worth in camparison to an Israelis?? Israel is untouchable in the world and with our ally America vetoeing UN demands against us..we are ready for anything

  • 25 - Jet in Columbus

    Jul 14, 2006 at 7:52 pm

    My opinion is that the day is coming soon when the region runs out of oil, than no none will pay attention to them.

    At the rate they're pumping it vs the consumption from China and India, soon they'll be empty handed.

    maybe that's why Iran is threatening to hold hout, they want to be the last one "holding" so they can make a financial killing.

Add your comment, speak your mind

Personal attacks are NOT allowed.
Please read our comment policy.
Please preview your comment.

blogcritics lists for Nov 11, 2009

fresh articles Most recent articles site-wide

fresh comments Most recent comments site-wide

most comments Most comments in 24hrs

top writers Most prolific Blogcritics for October

top commenters Most prolific Commenters in 24 hrs