Today on Blogcritics
Home » Nintendo Wii Review: Madden NFL 08

Nintendo Wii Review: Madden NFL 08

Please Share...Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

Last year, Madden 07 was a great surprise for Wii owners who may have expected a poor port of EA Sports’ flagship title. The Wii remote was implemented well, and while it didn’t have the graphics or depth of the Xbox 360 version, it was still a very good game.

This year, the franchise is back in Madden 08, and it brings with it some new features. Unfortunately, other features are flat-out gone from the game, most notably the create-a-player and create-a-team modes. These Madden staples are sorely missed and they had better be back for Madden 09.

What comes to Madden 08 are several new features, some of them Wii-specific. New “weapons” allow certain star players to create game-changing plays. For example, a star cornerback might be able to stick with a receiver on an important down, no matter how fast they are. Likewise, a star receiver might be able to leap over defenders and make an amazing catch on an important play. Superstar Mode now allows players to make their own player or pick one of the 2007-08 NFL rookies instead, a nice addition to the series. Unfortunately, the Wii version doesn’t let you edit the appearance of custom superstars. The trophy room from the 360 version is also absent.

However, in place of these subtractions, the Wii version adds in online play and a party mode. Online mode currently has problems, though, because EA is having server space issues, but that will hopefully be fixed soon.

The party mode consists of a trivia contest, a mini-game tournament, and a telestrator mode that lets you play through the game as normal, but also use the telestrator like John Madden himself would. The telestrator mode is incredibly fun, though I wish it would have just been an added feature to the game as a whole and not a separate mode.

As for the mini-games themselves, they are mostly the standard practice games you’ve seen in past Madden titles with a few new ones tossed in. That’s actually not a bad thing, as playing these mini-games will help non-Madden gamers get better at playing the game.

Speaking of non-Madden gamers, EA Sports has created a whole new feature just for them. Called Family Play mode, it only uses the Wii remote, with the game doing the running for you. All you do is make the movements, such as hiking or passing the ball or juking around a defender. It’s good for gamers who might otherwise find the standard controls, which remain unchanged from Madden 07, a bit too much to handle. The idea of multiple control settings is going to become something standard in future Wii games, especially complex sports titles like Madden where every button is normally used.

With the Madden series, you pretty much know what you are getting. The game play itself is little changed from any of the recent versions of the game, and it likely won’t be changing anytime soon, as EA seems to have all their bases covered. It’s still not perfect though, and in some places – such as the game’s AI – there is room for improvement.

One aspect where the Wii version is lacking is in graphics. Not only do all players look the same height on the field, but the graphics clearly look a bit dated. Like Gamecube dated. Given the incredible graphics of the Xbox 360 version this is a big disappointment, but it’s not necessarily something that will ruin the game experience for you. The game’s soundtrack is as licensed and vibrant as ever, and the in-game sounds are still good. One interesting thing of note is that the Wii version makes use of the Wii remote’s speaker, emitting any signal calls from the QB before the snap.

The variety of modes in Madden 08 for the Wii, and hopefully an online mode without server issues, give this game plenty of replay value, regardless of if you are a hardcore or casual gamer. However, the more casual gamers you have around you, the more you are likely to get out of this title.

Despite its new features, the lack of some standard ones make Madden 08 feel like a step backwards from last year’s version, which is a damn shame. If you have a bunch of Madden newbies around and want to get them playing the game, you might want to pick the Wii version up. But keep in mind that the 360 version not only has all of the game’s features, but runs at a very nice 60 frames per second.

Pros: Controls are still generally the same from Madden 07. Family Play and Party Mode will help make the game accessible to just about everyone. Makes some use of the Wii’s online capabilities.

Cons: Graphically weakest of three current-generation versions. Lacks depth of options that 360 and PS3 versions have, as many longtime Madden features (create-a-player/team, for example) are cut from the Wii version.

Madden NFL 08 is rated E (Everyone) by the ESRB. This game can also be found on: GameCube, Nintendo DS, Mac, PC, PS2, PS3, PSP, Xbox and Xbox 360.


Powered by

About Brian Szabelski

  • Ray

    For the love of God can we get past the damn graphics already! We know that any Wii game will not look as good as xb360 or ps3 … we don’t care … it’s fun!

    The graphics could be much better if programmers put some time and effort into it. Anyone remember Rogue Squadron or Resident Evil 4 … they were gamecube games the Wii is capable of more. It’s a known fact programmers are rushed and write sloppy code.

  • Don

    Can reviewers please note that the graphics and the game processor on the Wii are only slightly better then the gamecube. Please stop talking about graphics. Compare it to the XBox and PS2 versions if you must. It would be like rating the Hoda Civic and knocking points off because it’s not as fast as a Formula 1 car. You can’t compare apples and oranges. No one compared consoles to computer games. No one compares PSP and DS to PS3 and 360. No one compares cell phone games to console versions. So please stop comparing the graphics off the Wii to the 360. Talk gameplay to gameplay.

    Let me finish the review for you. Gameplay on the Wii will have you wondering why the 360 uses all of those buttons. Playing on the Wii is more intuitive then on the 360. This is the way football should be played on the consoles.

  • http://www.breakingwindows.com/ Ken Edwards

    Interesting, I thought playing the Wii version to be awkward and all I wanted was a damn controller. I will take the 360 version over the Wii version any day of the week.