Today on Blogcritics
Home » Culture and Society » News Analysis from Israel: Mugging Israel in the Media

News Analysis from Israel: Mugging Israel in the Media

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

When one uses the term "media" in reference to news these days, one has to realize that it refers to any medium of communication between a relatively small group of individuals and a far larger audience. This holds just as true for the apocryphal 'Gutenberg Gazette' as it does for CBS News. The news media can be manipulated today just as it was in the early 1800's by Napoleone Buonaparte (the Corsican spelling of the name he had as the child of Letizia Buonaparte) with his "bulletins" from the front, by which he manipulated the news of his wars in Europe, by plebiscites, by which Napoleon Buonaparte, and later his nephew, Louis Napoléon, (Napoléon III) manipulated French public opinion, by censorship, which Napoleon (and later his nephew), used to control the press in their respective French Empires.

These methods of control, improved upon with the advent of new technologies, have been used by dictatorships and illiberal regimes that have sought to suppress freedom ever since. It goes without saying that the international organizations which are coalitions of Arab dictatorships and illiberal regimes, as well as their allies, use these methods as well. One of the goals of these international Arab organizations is the destruction of Israel, and this effort can be carried out on and off the battle field.

'Once is happenstance. Twice is coincidence. The third time it’s enemy action' Al Capone
This blogsite quoted the full Israel Today article: Obama told the Egyptian foreign minister that he is a Muslim, the son of a Muslim and that he sympathizes with what he calls "the Muslim agenda"; he asked the Egyptian foreign minister to have patience while he cleared the table of domestic problems – then he'd show the world how to deal with Israel. The interview where Obama is reported to have said this took place in March 2010. When one reconsiders the events leading up to the "flotilla" incident on 31 May 2010, one has to realize that Obama's hand was in it, and he was demonstrating to Muslims "how to deal with Israel". The subsequent media lynch is only proof of this.

This media lynch goes beyond the pages of the alleged "mainstream" media in the United States, "al-Reuters" or the Associated Press. These idiots on the Left Coast with the missing brains are going to condemn us for defending ourselves. Northern Irish sources report that on Thursday night (10 June 2010), the Council of USPG (United Society for the Propagation of the Gospel) – Anglicans in World Mission – agreed that a letter should be sent to the British Foreign Secretary, Mr William Hague, expressing “shock and dismay at what happened last week when the Israeli naval forces stormed a Gaza-bound convoy carrying humanitarian aid in international waters, killing nine people and injuring many more.” Turkey is boycotting a holocaust conference in Jerusalem. In the meantime, the Palestinian Authority, while alleging to not indulge in anti-Israel incitement, does precisely this. This video shows how the PA attempts to de-legitimize the existence of our country. The quiz in it asks "which seaport is in "Palestine" and offers three cities in Israel. This is only one tiny event, a single video among tens of thousands, that pursues the goal of destroying Israel in the minds of its Arab viewers.

But the attacks on Israel and its supporters are far wider. Over the Sabbath of rosh Hodesh tammuz, (12-13 June 2010), Youtube pulled "We Con the World" in its continuing campaign to silence those of us who are pro-Israel. Even though YouTube hides behind the "copyright infringement" claim of Warner/Chappell Music, Inc., one has to note that Edgar Bronfman, who allegedly supports Israel, is the CEO of Warner Music Group, the conglomerate that owns Warner/Chappell Music, Inc. One is forced to wonder where Mr. Bronfman's real loyalties lie. YouTube's consistent harassment of the IDF's videos — as opposed to not touching thousands of videos that encourage hate and vilify Israel and Jews — impels one to conclude that YouTube is pursuing an anti-Jewish and anti-Israel agenda, however unsystematically. Caroline Glick, the leading Israeli journalist and commentator who had produced "We Con the World" as part of her satire series, fought back with satire. There is another weapon – Wejew. Why use the not so gentle "gentile" media when we Jews can use our own?

That is not the only avenue of attack being used in mugging Israel and its supporters. Paypal generally doesn't do business with Israel directly, but shutting off the money spigot – shutting down freedom of speech by calling anti-terror sites 'hate-speech' is now being used by Paypal. The point is not that all 'hate-speech' sites are targeted by Paypal. Were this the case, Pam Geller of Atlas Shrugged would not have a leg to stand on in her complaints. To her knowledge, and to mine, Paypal does not touch terror sites or other hate speech sites that denigrate or seek to destroy Israel or incite against Jews. This is the same precise pattern we see at YouTube. Were I a mafia don, I might suggest going to Paypal's CEO, tying him to a chair, and "making him an offer he couldn't refuse". One has to wonder if anti-Israel groups haven't beaten me to the punch (pun intended) with that idea. Establishing an alternative to Paypal is a little trickier than establishing an alternative to YouTube.

We should not assume from all of this that all non-Jews hate Jews and hate Israel. This could not be farther from the truth. Even Patrick Comerford, who was a moving force behind that shameful Anglican letter to the British Foreign Secretary referred to above, has written articles condemning anti-Semitism. There is a large grey area in this field, even among those who do not necessarily support Israel. With respect to individuals, Jews and Israelis have many friends and fervent supporters world-wide. But what is the truth is that those in power, those who shape the world's opinions, dislike Jews, and dislike Israel, and would be just as happy to see us dead as see us at all. This includes, one must note with pain, many Jews who hate themselves and the nation their brethren have created as a refuge.

There is a final point that needs to be made with utmost clarity, regarding this media mugging of Israel, which well fits Al Capone's definition of "enemy action". Santayana pointed out that he who fails to learn from history is doomed to repeat its mistakes.

While many of us Jews and Israelis on the ground have absorbed this lesson, the weak-kneed leaders of the State of Israel, who give more evidence each succeeding week of being sellouts and mere puppets of the United States and other nations not at all friendly to Israel or the Jews, fail to absorb the hard lessons they need to. And we, who have learned, must do something about it to survive.

Daily, History's Scythe moves closer, going from Kyrgyzstan westwards.

Writer's note – thanks to Ed Driscoll, for the quote of Al Capone used in the movie Goldfinger.

Powered by

About Ruvy

Hi!! Thanks for coming to my article! I was raised in Brooklyn, was graduated from the City University of New York in 1978 with a BA in political science and public administration there. I lived in Minnesota for a number of years. There I managed restaurants and wrote stories. We moved with our children family to Israel where we now reside. My work can be found at Ruvy's Roost, Jewish Indy,, and on Facebook under my full name, Reuven Kossover
  • Dave Nalle

    I took the liberty of embedding the “We Con the World” video in Ruvy’s article. It’s been reposted to YouTube numerous times and they seem not to be blocking it anymore after their initial blocking of the original posting.

    Ruvy doesn’t mention it, but the fact is that under US law there is a clear and absolute protection for works of parody as free speech and there’s absolutely no legal basis for YouTube to remove the video or for Warner Publishing to request that they do so.


  • John Wilson

    Israel is the author of their own discomfort.

  • roger nowosielski

    Another attempt at self-acclaim.

    How interesting!

    A question,though. How many Israeli journals are ready to post your BS. Has BC become a matter of last resort.

    If I were you, I would surely try to communicate your POV to your own countrywomen and men. I wouldn’t waste my time on BC.

  • Irene Wagner

    Ruvy, I am glad that you appreciate that it is not “all or nothing.” You’ve been careful to avoid branding all who try to speak up for those in Gaza as anti-Semites.

    Quote: There is a large grey area in this field, even among those who do not necessarily support Israel… But what is the truth is that those in power, those who shape the world’s opinions, dislike Jews, and dislike Israel, and would be just as happy to see us dead as see us at all.

    Yes. I’m hoping for peace, but I don’t think it will come without the realization that the blame does not entirely belong with one side or the other, Jew or Palestine.

  • roger nowosielski

    Well, if Ruvy admits there is a grey area, good for him, but it’s news to me.

    I’ve longed ceased reading his stuff. It’s the comments that I find interesting.

  • Dave Nalle

    Irene, I’d argue that blame remains entirely with BOTH sides who are chronically unreasonable and contentious and equally reprehensible.


  • Glenn Contrarian

    Ruvy –

    Over the hundreds of comments of yours that I’ve read, I don’t remember a single one that referenced a criticism by a media outlet of which you approved. So far, whenever we quote a media outlet, you’re quick to point out how anti-Semitic they are, or how they’re being manipulated by the Wahhabis, or how they’re simply lying.

    So…would you please list media outlets (if any) who meet your approval who ARE critical of Israel?

  • Irene Wagner

    Dave Nalle. Neither blame, nor anything else, be “entirely” “on both” “sides” at once, but I think I hear what you’re saying. I just don’t think you’re arguing with me.

    Now, if I’d said, “once we’ve passed out blame where it belongs, to the Palestinians and Jews, there is no more blame to go around,” which, I wouldn’t say, THEN you’d have something to argue with me about.

  • Dave Nalle

    Not sure I’m actually trying to find grounds for an argument. I just don’t think that either side in this situation has a defensible position and anyone who does try to defend one side over the other is suspect.