Today on Blogcritics
Home » Culture and Society » Nation’s Highest Court Takes On Immigration Issue

Nation’s Highest Court Takes On Immigration Issue

Please Share...Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

The first of many court appearances for immigration reform is coming before the nation’s highest court, the U.S. Supreme Court. The lawsuit to appear first is the 2007 Arizona law penalizing employers who knowingly hire undocumented workers. The Obama administration asked the court to review the Arizona employment law and has indicated it will sue to block enforcement of the state's broader immigration law, scheduled to take effect July 29.

The issue of this suit varies somewhat from the main issue of immigration enforcement, but both center on the extent of a state's authority to enforce immigration-related laws without infringing on exclusive federal power. Laws similar to the 2007 Arizona law are in effect in 5 states, requiring employers to determine their workers' immigration status through a federal database. Employers who knowingly hire illegal immigrants face a license suspension for the first offense, and revocation if there is a second offense.

A federal appeals court in San Francisco last year affirmed the law as an exercise of a state's traditional power to regulate businesses, and noted that federal law allows states to use regulations against employers of illegal immigrants. Obama’s administration challenges that the Arizona law is a hiring ban, not a licensing law, and uses such action solely as a means of punishment. The Justice Department lawyers and opponents of Arizona's new Immigration law argue that the law is broader than federal law and violates the federal government's sole authority to regulate immigration.

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the American Civil Liberties Union requested and the Supreme Court agreed to hear the case Monday and is due to issue a ruling by the end of June 2011. The case is Chamber of Commerce vs. Candelaria, 09-115.

Arizona Governor Jan Brewer on Friday asked the federal court to dismiss 5 lawsuits filed that challenge the new law. They generally argue that Arizona's law will lead to racial profiling and that it is the federal government's responsibility to regulate immigration.

The federal government response to the problem is to send 1200 National Guard members to the border, giving Arizona 500 of the 1200 troops to add to those that are all ready protecting the U.S.- Mexico border in Arizona. Governor Brewer feels that this is not enough and that Arizona needs 3000 (and the entire Mexican border 6000) more troops.

VISITORS BEWARE!! And the other appear to be juvenile: posting signs on federal land within Arizona’s borders that warns visitors of possible illegal smuggling and immigration that might occur and that they are in an active drug and human smuggling region. Why now when the problem is nothing new? Is it the government’s way of looking at the immigration issue with a joke? Or is it to ridicule Arizona for its way of handling this problem? It makes the appearance that the government is also boycotting one of its 50 “children” by deterring tourist/visitors thus hurting their economy.

Other states are attempting to provide a more mature solution to their immigration issues than the federal government’s sign postings. Such as:

A constitutional amendment is being proposed by Secure Arkansas, a grass root organization in Arkansas that would restrict public benefits to illegal immigrants’ children 14 years of age and below. No one above the age of 14 would be eligible for public benefits such as healthcare, which now seems to be redundant since the Mexican Consulate began its health initative in the state capital city, Little Rock, in March of this year. It is the most recent one to be opened in the nation since the program began in San Diego in 2002 as a joint venture between the city and the Mexican government. Little Rock’s initative is the 40th to open for citizens of Mexico.

Powered by

About jtkindlenam