59. Flowers in the Dirt Paul McCartney
This album got the best picks from the songwriting partnership of Paul McCartney and Elvis Costello. "That Day Is Done" and "Don't Be Careless Love" especially rate as odd, uniquely memorable songs.
60. Lies Guns n Roses
"Nice Boys" is fine, but this is here mostly for the newer acoustic material, particularly "Patience," which is pure beauty. "One in a Million" was the rare controversial song that was actually worth the bother. Then there's the happy singalong of "I Used to Love Her (But I Had to Kill Her)." C'mon everybody, sing along!
61. Black Album Prince
This whole album is superfunkycalifragisexi, particularly the concluding slinky sexy jam "Rock Hard in a Funky Place." Duke Ellington would have been proud of them horns. Then there's rap satire "Dead On It" and the infamous "Bob George."
62. Acoustic Soul India.Arie
"Video" was an excellent single, but "Promises" definitely means the most to me. She's real.
63. Mock Tudor Richard Thompson
As something broadly akin to classic 50s rock style, "Cooksferry Queen" and "Crawl Back" might be a good, easily digestible entry point for casual Thompson fans. Come for the simple rock, stay for the quiet psychodrama of "Hope You Like the New Me."
64. Spike Elvis Costello
Folks have been heard bad mouthing this record in particular. But as Elvis says in the opening track, you're nobody till everybody thinks you're a bastard. Song for song, this thing rocks. The lynch mob thrill of "Let Him Dangle" really does it. Papa's got a brand new tuba on "Chewing Gum." Surely "Deep Dark Truthful Mirror" ranks one of Elvis' finest slow jams.
65. The Lonesome Jubilee John Mellencamp
John gets all backwoods and Old Testament on "Paper in Fire," probably his best ever record. This was the best and most unique SOUND he ever got, and some of his best songs. Besides the hits, dig the chill out classic "Rooty Toot Toot."
66. Ill Communication Beastie Boys
Mostly, heavy metal and rap are NOT two great tastes that taste great together, but play to the lesser common denominators of both genres. "Sabotage" is the major exception that proves the rule. This is a real song, hard as a rock and the best thing the Beasties ever did. Also, you can't miss the funk bliss when you've got a "Sure Shot."
67. I'm So Confused Jonathan Richman
His most, probably mostly only, influential work was in the 70s, but Jonathan has continued to pursue and perfect a unique and compelling personal acoustic rock style. For stuff this simply presented, there's really quite a lot of nuance to this. "True Love Is Not Nice" belies notions that hes just a mushy head manchild. Most compellingly, the ghosts of hospitals past memorably haunt "I Can Hear Her Fighting With Herself."
Article comments
— go to most recent comments1 - Rob
Pretty good list. Must've taken a lot of thinking and time on your part. It's probably the Canadian in me, but I would add:
Blue Rodeo - "5 Days in July". This one's a classic. The songwriting doesn't get any better then this. Cuddy and Keelor were at there peak on this one. Just brilliant.
54-40 - "Dear Dear". Filled with great hooks.
Sarah Harmer - "All of Our Names". The songs are very well written and Sarah's voice is like silk. This album is flawless.
2 - Al Barger
Thanks. This post is still under construction. Someone helpfully published it from draft before it was quite soup. I'll have it finished up by the end of the day.
3 - gonzo marx
/disagree
many of these picks don't make my own top 500
but some deserve top 100 status
you completely lost me with anything from george michael...so much for "Objective"
but your mileage may vary
Excelsior!
4 - Eric Berlin
Nice complication of one man's opinion(s), Al.
As I went through, I thought, What happened to #53... then realized it was still in progress.
Man, Sinead at #1, eh? She wouldn't even register on my Top Whatever radar. Nothing against her, of course. I think of her and I think bald head and the tearing of the pope's picture and wailing Nothing Compares.... about 788 times.
Very hard to argue with The White Stripes in the Top 10. Your take on "The Nurse" made me go back and really give it a listen... which was a pure joy, of course.
5 - Eric Berlin
Just realized... no Beck, no REM.
Oof!
I may have to compile my own One Man's...
6 - godoggo
Really, you shouldn't be permitted to quote Ellington.
7 - Al Barger
Yes Mr Berlin, do please make your own list. Beck and REM were purposeful omissions on my part.
Again, I can understand how Sinead might well alienate a lot of folks, but nonetheless she absolutely has the goods. Plus, I LIKED hearing "Nothing Compares 2 U" hundreds of times.
Still, if you got burned out on that song, go back to that first album, which was not played to death on pop radio.
Also, I'm trying to limit myself at this point to only listening to the White Stripes album once a day. Gluttony is a mortal sin, and all.
8 - Al Barger
Mr Berlin, yes the omissions of Beck and REM were purposeful. They're both WAY overrated.
Also, please DO make your own similar post. I urge all Blogcritics to do likewise.
I can understand how Sinead alienated a lot of people. Nonetheless, she absolutely has the goods. Listen to The Lion and the Cobra again. And I LIKED hearing "Nothing Compares 2U" 788 times.
9 - Lisa McKay
Al, I bow to no one in my love for Mr. Costello, but Mighty Like A Rose? If I were put in a position of having to rescue my Costello collection from some natural disaster and had to leave one album behind, that would be the one.
Nonetheless, an interesting list, and you sure have eclectic tastes in music.
10 - Rodney Welch
This ought to be called "The 100 Albums Al Bought in the Last 20 years." Or maybe "The Kind of List You'd Expect From Someone Who Thinks Prince and Elvis Costello Are Not Capable Of Making A Bad Record." How else to explain honoring the suckathon that includes Around the World in a Day, Parade, Lovesexy, Batman AND Diamonds and Pearls? What strange level of fandom do you have to reach where you fail to see that these records are nowhere as good as Sign O' The Times? The same level, I suspect, that regards Costello's Spike on par with his late masterpiece King of America. You also include the absolute lamest Talking Heads disc, Naked, and while it's nice to know someone besides me has heard Zevon's Transverse City, (which in fairness does have one of the Z-man's best songs, "Splendid Isolation") the idea that it's a great record is just silly -- especially by WZ's standards. I'll give you credit for a handful of unusual choices that show insight, but on the whole you make the Spin list look like a model of judiciousness.
11 - gonzo marx
bah...
no Tool or Pantera
but Ben fols five makes towards the top of the list
tsk tsk
nice "Subjective" piece, big Al
Excelsior!
12 - Lisa McKay
Oh, and I think you forgot Soft Bulletin by the Flaming Lips...I'm sure it was an oversight ;-)
13 - Al Barger
Miss Lisa, I will confess to not being totally up to speed on the Flaming Lips. I was considering Yoshimi- but I don't think I've heard Soft Bulletin.
If it's even better than Yoshimi, I need to be hearing it. Downloading it now. And thank you for bringing it to my attention.
14 - Tan The Man
I think A Mighty Wind Original Soundtrack should be higher on that list. No Garth Brooks?
15 - Tiffany
Yay! Some Tori made it.
16 - gonzo marx
Tori made it, but not Alanis or even more egregious an error
no Ani DiFranco
and that omission is as damning as no Tool
nuff said?
Excelsior
17 - Tan The Man
No Tool. No Garth Brooks! <--- The G-Man!
18 - Al Barger
The old man once made the mistake of so much as lightly praising Garth Brooks. As he should know better, I've punished him repeatedly by actually making him listen to Garth. After about 10 minutes, he's begging for Porter or Merle or just anything real. That'll learn him.
Yes, Gonzo, no Pantera. I'd be canonizing frickin' stupid Motley Crue before I'd do that. Hell, I'd pick a damned MARIAH CAREY album before Pantera. I'm just saying...
19 - gonzo marx
poor Al...
it seems that all yer taste is in yer mouth...
i'm just sayin'
seriously, if you cannot hear the superior musicianship of Dimebag Darryl Abbott on guitar, and his brother, Vinnie Paul on drums...
well, i guess we just speak two different languages when it comes to music
so much for "Objective"
Excelsior!
20 - Matthew T. Sussman
Why don't you just poll all Blogcritics music reviewers the way baseball gives baseball writers a ballot for MVP?
5 points for No. 1
4 points for No. 2
and so on.
21 - Norton Malcontent
How is this list possibly objective? The vast majority of your entries are tedious at best. The range of artists you listen to is obviously severely limited due to the fact that you include the same artists over and over. And you can't even get your song references right. It was The Who who sang "It's the singer, not the song" in "Join Together". All in all a pretty lame list.
22 - Al Barger
Actually Matthew, we're in the process of doing just that. It was announced in the BC authors Yahoo group. I'm taking votes from Blogcritics by email, up to 50. And definitely please write an entry like this listing and explaining your picks. We intend to have results by mid next week.
23 - Matthew T. Sussman
Thanks Al. I'll get on that.
24 - gonzo marx
bah..now yer telling me i would hafta join some kind of yahoo group?
color me unsociable
Excelsior!
25 - Eric
I don't think I could listen to this list the whole way through, much less it be the top ever.
First of all, Tears For Fears's best album was Sowing the Seeds of Love.
Second, if you're going to make a statement, just drop U2 out of this list.
Almost Finally Bad by MJ was just that - Bad. Thriller, more than being his seminal work, was a much better album.
Finally.. I get it that you like Prince and Costello... but that many albums makes me wonder if you've heard 500 in your life.