A sequel to 2008's excellent The Stage Names, which ranked sixth on my 2007 best of list. Frontman Will Sheff continues to write erudite, loquacious songs about pop culture and the difficulties of the rock 'n' roll lifestyle, but succeeds where other wordy indie boys often fail - in that the songs still maintain their zip without getting completely lost in their naval. Thus his cleverness is still an asset, rather than a detriment, as the band's music is about more than just outlet for his ability to turn a phrase.
Basically, what I'm saying is Okkervil River are the anti-Bright Eyes. I enjoyed the album immediately, and grew to love it quickly, from the instrumental introduction to the sombre denouement. If even a down year in a music is capable of producing such a compelling, ambitious, and complete vision, then maybe I should stop whining about it being a down year.
Article comments
1 - Don
Great to see Okkervil River & Mates of State recognized. But this statement cracked my up "my favourite Icelandic experimental rock band" like Sigur Ros are one on a long list of Icelandic experimental rock bands :) they do make beautifully sounding albums no doubt. Disappointed to see no mention of Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds "Dig!!! Lazarus Dig!!!" an excellent album. I still don't get everyone fawning over Fleet Foxes & Vampire Weekend. Don't get me wrong , they are good bands but I don't see them as top ten material. Give me The Hold Steady's "Stay Positive" over either album any day.
2 - Andy
I gave The Hold Steady a bit more of a chance this year, but for whatever reason, I just can't get into them.
As for Fleet Foxes, I'm not sure I see them as top ten material either, it just so happens that this year they are. In other years, notsomuch. Still, it's a grower.