It's more self-assured than any of their previous releases, comfortably taping into levels of despair and melancholy in songs like "Cath..." and "Grapevine Fires" where in the past they may have buried some of the sentiment under protective layers of irony.

3. Flight of the Conchords - Flight of the Conchords: Normally, I wouldn't put a comedy act so high on an album list, but, hey, that's what kind of year it was. Plus, Bret McKenzie and Jemaine Clement are a lot more talented than your average novelty comedy act, even if they're "formerly New Zealand's fourth most popular guitar-based digi-bongo acapella-rap-funk-comedy folk duo".
Along with genuinely funny tracks that lose little of their humour with repeated listens, the Conchords are fantastic musical mimics, resulting in the most eclectic release of the year. This is the only album on this list that I instantly loved, and not only because it reminded me of the episodes in which the songs appeared (in truth, I love the album far more than I do the series). The only problem with the album is that hearing the types of songs they parody is now more difficult, as its hard not to think of FOTC and laugh.

2. Bon Iver - For Emma, Forever Ago: Also federally mandated: when speaking of For Emma, Forever Ago, one must tell the story of its making. This is both because the story gives the album the authenticity fans crave so desperately and because the story informs the music within.
Recovering from the breakup of both a relationship and his former band, while suffering from mononucleosis of the liver, Justin Vernon retreated to his father's Wisconsin cabin for three months in the winter. Eventually, he began to play around with some recording equipment he had around, writing and recording what became this record, playing all the instruments and overdubbing many layers of vocals, in the hopes of maybe coming up with a demo to help get a contract. The result is a wintry, introspective, deeply personal album that grabs you by the gut, then punches you in the heart, and puts you in that cabin with Vernon. Of all the albums on the list, this is the one most likely to become a classic.

1. Okkervil River - The Stand Ins: The top two were neck and neck for the top spot, with The Stand Ins earning the Album of the Year honours simply because I enjoy it more.








Article comments
1 - Don
Great to see Okkervil River & Mates of State recognized. But this statement cracked my up "my favourite Icelandic experimental rock band" like Sigur Ros are one on a long list of Icelandic experimental rock bands :) they do make beautifully sounding albums no doubt. Disappointed to see no mention of Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds "Dig!!! Lazarus Dig!!!" an excellent album. I still don't get everyone fawning over Fleet Foxes & Vampire Weekend. Don't get me wrong , they are good bands but I don't see them as top ten material. Give me The Hold Steady's "Stay Positive" over either album any day.
2 - Andy
I gave The Hold Steady a bit more of a chance this year, but for whatever reason, I just can't get into them.
As for Fleet Foxes, I'm not sure I see them as top ten material either, it just so happens that this year they are. In other years, notsomuch. Still, it's a grower.