There really are two schools of emo; those who remain stripped down to the essence, like neo-Fugazi's and the progressive school, who followed Sunny Day Real Estate, and to a lesser degree, Weezer, whose Pinkerton album was another key 90's release. The genre reached maturity in the late 90's, spawning a large amount of bands; some of them found relatively wide audiences, most remain cult bands. Noteworthy among them are Jimmy Eat World, Joan of Arc, Braid, Texas Is The Answer, At The Drive-In, and Modest Mouse.
Following the post-grunge alternative rock explosion of the early-mid 90's, rock's momentum waned somewhat, and as the 00's rolled in, there were few significant "movements" happening; emo was one of the few genuine rock movements to peak as the new decade began.
Some important/influential emo artists/songs include:
1. Fugazi: Waiting Room
Fugazi is immensely influential, not just as musicians, but as scene creators, providers of the $10 CD and $5 show, and through their famous work ethic. While their music is not well known among mainstream listeners, it is a rare punk listener who doesn't know of them, and this track in particular. Irresistably bass-driven, with great double vocals from Ian MacKaye and Gary Picciotto, with giant crashing choruses, this represents the seeds of the genre, as well as a good place to begin with Fugazi. Fugazi was formed in 1987 by Ian MacKaye (ex-Minor Threat, ex-Embrace) and Piciotto and drummer Brendan Canty from Rites of Spring; Joe Lally played bass. "Waiting Room" was from their 1988 debut EP, Fugazi.
2. Sunny Day Real Estate: In Circles
Formed in Seattle in 1992, and having recorded for Sub Pop records, Sunny Day Real Estate are often mistakenly pigeonholed as grunge; in fact, they had little in common with the grunge scene, and are now considered the first of the 90's-era emo bands. The band itself has one of the more unusual histories in recent rock music; formed as a three-piece featuring guitarist/vocalist Dan Hoerner, bassist Nate Mendel, and drummer William Goldsmith, the band didn't really develop an identity until the addition of a fourth member, the somewhat mysterious vocalist Jeremy Enigk. The band only released one photo to the press, never played the state of California with all four members present, and ultimately broke up in 1995 after Enigk found religion. Mendel and Goldsmith then joined Dave Grohl's post-Nirvana band, Foo Fighters, but reunited with Enigk in 1998 for two more Sunny Day Real Estate albums before disbanding the group for good in 2001. "In Circles" is from their 1994 debut, Diary, which is one of the genre-defining emo albums; essential listening for fans of the genre.
Article comments
1 - Aaron, Duke De Mondo
wonderful uao. thouroughly enjoyed everything here. i just been startin to sort of half-poke at the edges of emo on account of a lady-friend seems to like a hella lotta bands that could fit snugly within the confines of the genre. and politically, as a reaction to both commercial music business and the macho fuckin posturing of so many rock bands, i think its an incredibly positive thing.
Other than Weezer i dunno that any of these bands would've crossed my listening post until recently, save for Modest Mouse, who i didn't for a second ensvision as emo. I just imagine there ain't no right reason in the world for me to decry all that "whinin" no more. Look at the songs you wrote, folks would say. Look at those fuckin bright eyes records litterin the place. Look all that nonsense. And you don't like emo becuase it's all "whining for no good reason"??????
on the other hand, the number of emo bands straddlin the rock world at the minute, the number of them cynically exploiting the emotions of their fans for nothin other than commercial gain, that shit i can't get behind for a damn second.
but i could listen to Pinkerton all day.
i have NEVER been able to find Zen Arcade in a record strore, and had to make do with candy apple grey, which was fairly dissapointing.
2 - Mark Saleski
holy crap! the duke doesn't own that Fugazi record?
what the hell?!! buy it tomorrow!
3 - Aaron, Duke De Mondo
mark, Fugazi are one of the bands up yonder who have indeed infiltrated my record collection. i never much cared for the Straight Edge shenanigans (save for a brief weekend back in 99), but regardless, Fugazi and Minor Threat are sitting neath my keyboard at this very minute. even though, to be perfectly honest, the dead kennedys stuff next to it gets all the stereo-space.
and curse this, i just spent too long crouched over fumbling through CD's in order to find that Husker Du record. which i now have beside me for to iTune-ise. alongside a loada other stuff i always meant to fling on there. How could i have forgotten Gillian Welch or Bill Monroe or System Of A Down? makes no sense. but there there are, fit for to be ripped.
4 - Aaron, Duke De Mondo
an i think maybe the reason why i didnt even think of fugazi when commenting up yonder, is becuase never in my wildest pigeon-holeing delirium would i have considered them emo. most likely on account of i still don't especially know what the fuck emo means.
i have that documentary on VHS someplace, too. what was it called? the fugazi one... Document or somethin??
5 - Craig Lyndall
This read like a much more concise version of Andy Greenwald's book, "Nothing Feels Good" which blathered on a bit too long about Dashboard Confessional.
Anyway, a fine article. I am just waiting for the people who hate the word Emo to come out of the woodwork and call you an idiot. It will happen. Just warning you.
Good selections for meaningful songs. I would have to put Mineral on any list that I make of most influential artists. In terms of Modest Mouse, I wouldn't call them emo. This is where I think there is a clear split between emo and indie rock. Whenever a band like modest mouse pushes boundaries of weirdness, I say it is eclectic and think of indie. When a band is wearing its heart on its sleeve like Mineral or Sunny Day, it is emo.
Try and place a band like Death Cab for Cutie though and you are going to start getting into trouble.
6 - Mark Saleski
i'm not here to call anybody any names, but i am in duke's camp with this Emo thing...in that it's an interesting bit of categorization where there's not necessarily a unifying sound with these groups.
think about it. if you'd never heard about any of this stuff before, switched on the radio and heard Weezer's "Hash Pipe"...you'd think it was, what? to me, it's a just a rock song.
7 - The Theory
yeah, most of that I don't think I'd consider emo. That said, the genre is ambiguous enough that it is pretty worthless trying to argue it.
8 - Tom Johnson
Another very nice piece, uao.
I'll echo Craig - watch for the Fugazi supporters to ignorantly rip into you for labeling them as emo. ,a href="http://blogcritics.org/archives/2003/02/24/135437.php"My first post here was about Tortoise's self-titled album that, for whatever reason, talked about Fugazi and mentioned emo, and well over two years later it got a comment from just such a person.
9 - Julie
Fugazi is not EMO!.Emo is closer to green day that hardcore punk. Even mentioning Bad Brains in the same ARTICLE as Emo seems preposterous.Good Article though. Tries too hard to make Emo sound legit instead of wimpy(Which I feel it is).
10 - Craig Lyndall
This is another reason that I just call my band a melodic rock band. I have heard people tell us we are emo, alternative, etc, but it is just a form of rock really.
Give it a listen and tell me what it is if you like, but I just call it rock.
11 - uao
I didn't write the history; I just report it.
Honest injun; Fugazi and Dischord records' output were called "emocore" at the time for much the same reasons the 90's bands were called emo.
If the tough guys in Fugazi's audience want to pretend this isn't true, fine.
But while researching this piece I came across about a dozen comprehensive articles that say the same things this article does. Just do a google search "history of emo" or "fugazi + emo" and see what comes up.
Those Fugazi fans who don't like emo might want to consider listening to the late GG Allin instead.
;-)
12 - Craig Lyndall
Well said, uao...
By the way, if you want to see some fans attack, go check out the review I did of War All the Time by Thursday...
(sniff) they were so mean!
http://blogcritics.org/archives/2003/09/18/140826.php
13 - SFC SKI
Another good on, uao, I read it on your site first.
Not much for emo, but everyonce in a while I hear something worth listening to more than once.
14 - Aaron, Duke De Mondo
regarding comment #11 - gg was the KING of emo
15 - uao
Craig: I've had a few pieces go that way here, too. This one still might...
I liked your reply in your thread "Maybe you are blinded by your infatuation." Simple, and to the point. That was pretty funny.
Duke: now that you mention it, maybe GG indeed was the king of emo. You've cast him in a whole new light for me.
:-)
16 - BRICKLAYER
Lil' Brick says More Elmo. Less Emo. Thank you.
17 - Eric Olsen
super super job getting your ears around a very slippery genre, which basically means whatever the person talking says it means - thanks uao!
18 - Cordy
I would have to say that bands like Weezer, Death Cab, Bright Eyes, The Postal Service. I'd say they were Emo. Emo to me is strange out-there music, usually having some electronic stuff or an acoustic guitar.