Okay, so first we drop prices of CDs (Universal does anyways), now the RIAA is considering offering Amnesty to all the file shareres... IF (And this is a BIG IF) they receive a notarized letter, photo ID of the person sharing the files (YOU). Next they'll want your Social Security Number, blood and DNA sample... All because you share music files. Some of which you might actually own!
Isn't this getting a little out of hand?
Article comments
1 - Craig Lyndall
The other part that you left out is that if you have already been targeted by the RIAA, they will not give you amnesty. They are trying to get illegal downloaders to proactively admit wrong-doing in exchange for their amnesty.
I would want to know more about this database that would contain my identity, but I think it is a fair trade considering the settlements so far have been in the 10's of thousands of dollars, which is more than I have.
2 - Eric Olsen
I'm with Z on this one: I am not a lawyer but I would strongly advise anyone from participating in this program. What happens to the database? How long will it be held? This is a cynical PR ploy aimed at frightened parents. With the RIAA's record on civil liberties, would you trust them? Not if you're sane.
3 - Zaldor
Good point Eric - I'm sure the way it's worded is exactly a way to influence frightened parents: "Each infringing household member" - What Parent wouldn't see that and think, "My son/daughter" ??
4 - Mark Saleski
there are some good viewpoints on these issues over at boycott-riaa.com
5 - TDavid
This amnesty thing is on its face a nice offer but when exposed is pretty weak and intrusive.
A better solution IMO would be to take all the heavy file traders they have targeted and interview them for what it would take for them to be compelled to buy music legally and develop a marketing strategy based upon/around that information and market research. Didn't somebody famous once say the easiest way to defeat an enemy is to befriend him?
I don't think filetraders are the RIAA's "enemy", but they sure are treating filetraders like pond scum instead of seizing an opportunity to learn from and possibly maximize marketability from their interest in music.