Wish You Were Here, recorded in 1974, was the band's fresh attempt at a re-start. All the band members contribute songs, some of which are among the band's finest: "Just A Chance" opens Rhino records' Poptopia power-pop collection, Molland comes up with some of the strongest songs in his life, the band's sound was becoming progressive but retained its tuneful essence, the lyrics were worldly and honest, and produce Chris Thomas came up with just the right sound for them; clean and clear, a contrast to the more heavy-handed wall-of-sound production they received from George Harrison on Straight Up.
The album earned them the best critical notice of their career, and the album was at #60 with a bullet in its first weeks of release when it was discovered that all of Badfinger's earnings had disappeared from an escrow account into which they had been placed, without the band's knowledge; a flurry of lawsuits in all directions followed, which resulted in Warners yanking the record from release just as it was breaking through.
This, for all intents and purposes, finished the band. Broke, unable to tour, their album in limbo, and realizing their financial managers had robbed them blind, the band fell apart. Molland left, and keyboardist/singer Bob Jackson came in. With little choice but to record another album under their contract, they recorded the bitter and confused Head First in late 1974. Warners wouldn't touch it, because of the lawsuits, and dropped the band from its label.
This was the final blow. With no money, no prospects of working again, a daughter on the way, a despondant Pete Ham, who had trusted their financial managers right up to nearly the last minute, hung himself in his garage.
![Badfinger: day After day [Live 1974] (1990)](http://img208.exs.cx/img208/7503/badfingerdayafter7wo.jpg)
Joey Molland released an album as part of a new band Natural Gas in 1976, but the album failed, and within two years he had resorted to installing carpets for a living. Tom Evans worked briefly with a band called the Dodgers, who eventually fired him. Mike Gibbins recorded drums for Bonnie Tyler and appeared on her hit "It's A Heartache" in 1978.
Article comments
1 - Eric Olsen
what a terrific, empathetic career overview/review, and I was quite unaware they had done much of note after Straight Up - will definitely give my Apple Greatest Hits collection another listen. Thanks uao!
2 - The Proprietor
"Without You" is an engaging read, and it's somewhat blood-boiling to see how Stan Polley swindled not only Badfinger but "investors" in other projects and managed to get away scot-free. Joey Molland's spinning Badfinger history towards himself these days, minimizing Pete Ham and Tom Evans' legacy.
"Baby Blue", "No Matter What" and "Day After Day" always are high on my playlists. Terrific stuff that deserves more exposure than it gets.
Great article!
3 - Vern Halen
I remember a friend finding a used copy of Straight Up, & we used to play it all the time. An essential part of a classic rock fan's collection.
4 - uao
Glad to hear from some other Badfinger fans. The Proprietor is right; Stan Polley, the culprit in this story, had also allegedly cheated a sizable number of other investors and musicians, and did get off scot-free.
The book,"Without You", is a good, informative read, too.
5 - Andy DeWitt
Glad to see your article. A nice
overview. However, the book you mention
unfortunately is a self-serving project
by the author, in which certain facts
were glossed over, and some were deliberately ignored as to not affect
it's credibility and intent of the
author. A lot of info was presented,
but with such a slant it taints the
rest, and has readers forming opinions
they wouldn't have, had they been
presented with all the facts.
6 - uao
The slant is certainly there; I realize that the book ("Without You")is controversial among serious Badfinger fans.
For this article, I relied on other sources for facts, and avoided speculating on the motives of the bandmembers, their family members, and their business associates (which the book does).
I still recommend it, since it contains a lot of useful hard facts, and a lot of good photos. Also, since it remains the only book (I'm aware of) about the band.
Andy DeWitt's caveat does have merit though; however, the author's allegiances are evident in the writing (and the accompanying CD), and can be glossed over by an alert reader in favor of the historical events depicted.
As such, it's all there is on Badfinger beyond bio info in music encyclopedias and the like.
If someone writes a better, less biased one, I'll buy it ;-)
7 - John
What facts were glossed over or ignored in Without You? I hear this criticism often, but nobody ever really explains it in detail. "Glossing over" is a phrase I would more associate with Joey's approach to the Badfinger legacy.
8 - John
What facts were glossed over or ignored in Without You? I hear this criticism often, but nobody ever really explains it in detail. "Glossing over" is a phrase I would more associate with Joey's approach to the Badfinger legacy.
9 - Brad
Who is the model on the No Dice Album?
She looks just like Raquale Welsh or a little like Cher.Joey Molland didn't even remember her name.I was told the house hippie at Apple Records hired her and
took the photo.He also took the photo for
the No Dice and Stright Up Album.Joey
did say she wasn't a well know modle.
10 - Cary
3/22-"Joey Molland's spinning Badfimger history towards himself these days, minimizing Pete Ham and Tom Evans' legacy"-The Proprietor
3/25-"'Glossing over' is a phrase I would more associate with Joey's approach to the Badfinger legacy"-John
I have known Badfinger since 1971 and been regarded by all 4, individually and collectively, as though I were family. I have attended well over 100 of their performances over the years, including several which included Pete and Tom in the line-up. I knew the history before there was a book to present it. I can assure you, the Badfinger legacy is reverently kept by Mr. Molland to this day. If Pete and Tom have been minimized, it can be attributed more to the fact that Pete and Tom are no longer with us (as this site's article points out), and to greedy people who took advantage of them along the way. Joey has never ceased to credit both with the authorship of their songs when he performs them (keeping them alive for those who may not have been around 30 years ago to hear for themselves) and he has nothing but admiration and praise for their outstanding musicianship, and the time, and friendship, they all shared together in the band. As for "spinning history toward himself" nothing could be further from the truth. In fact, he tends to divert attention and praise away, even when he is deserving of it. (And if you are among those who consider his exhuberance in accepting the ASCAP award as such, you are mistaken). The whole band was generally that way, especially in the shadow of their mentors, which is partly why they endured such raw deals from the very beginning. If anything, he has been put in the unenviable position of having to reel in the "spinning" that has already occured against him (and his wife, who has been depicted as a meddling menace, rather than a caring person who spoke up when she saw things weren't going well for the band-too bad Pete didn't take her concerns to heart, he might still be here today) and to react to his friends and bandmates being elevated to sainthood, as can happen when public figures die too young. I've heard Joey express many different emotions and his preference is to see the good in people and situations wherever possible and to look optimistically toward the future. If that's "glossing over", then so be it. It comes across to me as not dwelling on the past, or the negative, and I applaud him for the ability to do that amidst the adversity that is dircted his way. He and his wife are not perfect, but they are good, caring people who have been treated rather unfairly in the wake of the tragedies that befell Badfinger, and those of you who have not met these people personally would do well to take hearsay with the proverbial grain of salt.
11 - bet
In your free time, check some helpful info about on line free texas holdem tournament ... Thanks!!!
12 - uao
Sadly, I read that Mike Gibbins passed away at home on Oct. 4, 2005 from 'natural causes'. He was 56.
13 - uao
I messed up that link for Gibbins' passing. It should be: here
14 - ßill
The Badfinger book is packed with quotes (hundreds of people in/around Badfinger and the music business) and copies of contracts and other documentation. The facts speak for themselves.
15 - meredith
We saw Badfinger about 10 years ago at a pizza place in Dallas, PA for ten dollars.
They signed all of our albums, talked to us at length individually and I even got a peck on the cheek by Joey Molland.
The concert was so awesome. Probably the most humble, but genuinely kind musicians I have ever met. I would easily pay ten times that to see them again.
16 - Vic
Check this out! It sounds like Badfinger with John Lennon.
17 - Susan Burns
A year after Mike Gibbons unfortunate passing, I had the pleasure of meeting his wife and sons in Florida through a friend of mine. I arrived at their home without having the knowledge of who I was meeting beforehand, as I entered and was intoduced, I started noticing albumns on the walls, and a letter from Paul McCartney expressing his grief. I asked my friend what it was all about and she explaned how she was friends with Mike and Elly. It was an awesome experience, I met his two sons as well, who are also in a band and had been voted number one band in the Orlando area. After a while, some friends showed up and I was asked to play the guitar and sing, all the guitars in the house were left handed, except for one, which the boys said was their Dad's guitar. So, I played it, sang, and had a blast! If Mike's family were to ever read this, I would say thanks, from the bottom of my heart.
18 - Chris
Class act, and I'm sure they would of gone on to greater things. The world is far emptier without their great music, RIP. Never be forgotten.
19 - Jennifer
Dan Matovina's book Without You is excellent. He spent years writing down facts from business associates, friends and family in London, Liverpool, Swansea Wales, the USA. He did a great service to the band. No book will surpass his. Joey did not write Without You.
20 - Jennier
To add: Tom Evans and Peter Ham wrote the world wide hit *WITHOUT YOU*. And the ASCAP awards ceremony did these two men wrong. Petera Ham and Stephen Evans [The children of Pete and Tom] should have accepted the ASCAP SONGWRITING award.