Despite many fans’ opinion that Argus simply cannot be improved, Martin decided to plough ahead regardless and re-record the classic album. In doing so he risked further dividing the already split loyalties of the fan base. However, the result is an album that is remarkably loyal to the original.
The running order of Argus Through The Looking Glass is slightly different though. “Blowin’ Free” now appears as the final track whereas on the original vinyl album it closed the old side one. Martin reasons that he had written this song before the rest of the material that eventually formed Argus developed.
In general that incredible guitar sound, bass, and drums remain loyal to the original. However, there are differences, and this is particularly the case on “Throw Down The Sword,” which features the added keyboards of Geoff Downes. It also has John Wetton providing harmony vocals.
As subtle as this change is, it will be immediately apparent to fans of the band, most of who know this album note for note. In general though, he brings a contemporary feel and superb 2008 sound to the album whilst reminding everyone of his credentials within the band’s creation and, of course, it's history. Whatever the motives are for re-recording this classic album, the end result is still a valuable addition to the now huge Wishbone Ash heritage.
Whether Martin Turner intends to take his version of the band forward in a similar way to that done by Andy Powell’s over the years, remains to be seen. Hopefully there might be an album of new material to follow as the musicianship here is everything you would hope and expect any band using such a name to produce.
It is always sad when, for whatever reasons, different versions of a band exist, but this is in no way unique to Wishbone Ash. You only have to think of Whitesnake and Saxon as two random examples.
Andy Powell has worked tirelessly to keep the long running version of the band relevant whilst paying respect for all that went before. However there may also still be a place for Martin’s band. After all if you love this band, like most of the rock world did back when Argus came out, two versions are surely better than none.
You can visit Martin Turner's Wishbone Ash at their official webpage. Meanwhile the 'official' Wishbone Ash can also be found on their website.
Article comments