The unquestioned highlight of the album is “Through No Fault of My Own.” The band must have known they were on to something, allowing it to stretch longer than any other song on the album. The guitars snarl more, and so does Whitten's voice. His vocal and Dustin Arbuckle's harmonica howl righteously, both touched up with some effects. This is a contender for song of the year.
The guitars on the title track are thicker than those on “God Knows I'm Trying,” but it is by no means hard rock. “Wish I Had You” is another slow burner, similarly drummed. These songs never become showcases for flashy solos or mindless noodling despite the presence of two guitars. The interplay on “My Getaway” is a little more interesting, but the vocal and the song are a bit more generic.
The knock on The Rounders is that they will sink or swim on the strength of their songs. Whitten has some great vocals on the album, but he doesn't have the kind of superstar voice that can elevate average material. Similarly, the musicians either can't or choose not to let loose. That absence of bombast can be refreshing when a song is interesting enough on its own merits, but it can be boring when there's nothing to generate any kind of spark.
There are enough good things about this record and enough good songs to recommend it. There's enough promise to think their next effort might be even better.
Article comments
1 - A.L. Harper
You are such a reviewing stud Josh. Will you have my babies?
2 - Josh
Biologically impossible, but I am every bit the Review Stud. You're a clown, A.L., thanks for reading.
3 - Oklahoma Rock
Thanks for reviewing The Rounders!